A Vicious Cycle Along Busy Bus Corridors and How to Abate it

Minyu Shen, Weihua Gu, Michael J. Cassidy, Yongjie Lin, Wei NiSSRN 2024 · DOI

Abstract

We unveil that a previously-unreported vicious cycle can be created when bus queues form at curbside stops along a corridor. Buses caught in this cycle exhibit growing variation in headways as they travel from stop to stop. Bus (and patron) delays accumulate in like fashion and can grow large on long, busy corridors. We show that this damaging cycle can be abated in simple ways. Present solutions entail holding buses at a corridor entrance and releasing them as per various strategies proposed in the literature. We introduce a modest variant to the simplest of these strategies. It releases buses at headways that are slightly less than, or equal to, the scheduled values. It turns out that periodically releasing buses at slightly smaller headways can substantially reduce bus delays caused by holding so that benefits can more readily outweigh costs in corridors that contain a sufficient number of serial bus stops. The simple variant is shown to perform about as well as, or better than, other bus-holding strategies in terms of saving delays, and is more effective than other strategies in regularizing bus headways. We also show that grouping buses from across multiple lines and holding them by group can be effective when patrons have the flexibility to choose buses from across all lines in a group. Findings come by formulating select models of bus-corridor dynamics and using these to simulate part of the Bus Rapid Transit corridor in Guangzhou, China.

The Vicious Cycle of Bus Corridors

While "bus bunching"—where buses arrive in pairs or groups—is a well-known phenomenon in transit planning, it is typically studied at single stops or in low-congestion environments. This research identifies a more complex "vicious cycle" that emerges in busy, multi-stop corridors where buses must queue to reach curbside berths.

The cycle begins when queuing at a stop creates irregular headways (the time between consecutive buses). A bus following a longer-than-average headway encounters a larger pool of waiting passengers at the subsequent stop. The resulting increase in boarding time further delays the bus, widening the headway even more and forcing trailing buses into longer queues. This irregularity amplifies as buses move downstream, leading to massive, compounding delays for both vehicles and passengers across the entire corridor.

Proposed Intervention: Entrance Control and Reduced Headways

To break this cycle, the researchers propose implementing a Control Point at the corridor entrance. By regulating the entry of buses, the system can stabilize headways before they begin to snowball downstream.

The core of the proposed approach is a "modest variant" of standard headway-based holding strategies. Instead of holding a bus until the full scheduled headway ($H$) has elapsed, the control point releases it at a slightly reduced interval ($\eta \cdot H$), where $\eta$ is a threshold factor typically around 0.9. This reduced headway threshold allows the holding queue to clear more rapidly, minimizing the initial delay penalty of the control point while still providing sufficient regularization to prevent downstream bunching.

Furthermore, the study suggests Group Holding. By grouping different bus lines that serve the same stops, the system can treat them as a single unit. This strategy is particularly effective when "common-line patrons"—passengers indifferent to the specific line as long as it reaches their destination—are present, as it reduces the necessary holding time at the entrance.

Simulation and Real-World Application

The effectiveness of these strategies was tested using a discrete-time simulation model calibrated with real-world data from the Guangzhou Bus Rapid Transit (GBRT) corridor in China. The study analyzed a 6.8-km stretch with 10 consecutive, 3-berth stops, using data from 8 bus lines collected during morning peak hours in October 2020. The simulation incorporated manual boarding/alighting counts, GPS-derived travel times, and arrival distributions.

Key Findings and Results

The simulation results confirmed that the "vicious cycle" is a significant driver of inefficiency; without intervention, bus delays trended upward monotonically as they moved downstream.

Key results include:

  • Significant Delay Reduction: The modified holding strategy ($\eta = 0.9$) saved more than 20% of overall bus delay on the Guangzhou site.
  • Superior Regularization: Releasing buses slightly ahead of schedule was more effective than strict adherence ($\eta = 1.0$) because it balanced the cost of holding against the benefits of downstream stability. The simple strategy often outperformed more complex, adaptive models from existing literature because it did not rely on perfect predictions of future traffic states.
  • Corridor Thresholds: The benefits of entrance holding generally outweigh the costs in corridors with a sufficient number of stops (typically more than eight), where the compounding delays of the vicious cycle are most severe.

Conclusion

This research demonstrates that simple, proactive headway management at corridor entrances can effectively abate the compounding delays caused by bus queuing. By utilizing a reduced headway threshold and group holding, transit agencies can significantly improve service reliability and reduce passenger wait times in busy urban corridors. Future work may explore combining these entrance controls with adaptive speed regulation and signal priority to further optimize transit flow.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{shen2024vicious,
  author = {Minyu Shen and Weihua Gu and Michael J. Cassidy and Yongjie Lin and Wei Ni},
  title = {{A Vicious Cycle Along Busy Bus Corridors and How to Abate it}},
  year = {2024},
  eprint = {2403.08230},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2403.08230},
  howpublished = {SSRN},
}
Figure