A Velocity-Based Impedance Control System for a Low Impact Docking Mechanism (LIDM)

Chuanzhi Chen, Hong Nie, Jinbao Chen, Xiaotao WangSensors 2014 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel velocity-based impedance control system for Low Impact Docking Mechanisms (LIDMs). By directly relating contact forces to velocity, the system effectively handles random initial docking conditions and achieves robust, low-impact captures, crucial for spacecraft safety.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Docking spacecraft in orbit is a critical but challenging maneuver. Traditional docking mechanisms often require significant force to align and mate, risking damage to sensitive onboard systems. Low Impact Docking Mechanisms (LIDMs) aim to mitigate this by enabling "soft" captures. However, a key challenge is controlling the forces and torques during contact, especially when the initial relative positions and orientations of the spacecraft are uncertain or random. Existing impedance control methods, which typically rely on precise position information, struggle with these unpredictable initial conditions. This paper addresses the need for a robust control strategy that can achieve low-impact docking despite random environmental errors and unknown stiffness.

Methods

The core of this work is a velocity-based impedance control algorithm. Unlike traditional position-based impedance control, this approach establishes a direct relationship between the deviation of forces and the velocity of the docking mechanism. This is achieved by deriving an impedance equation that links the measured contact forces and torques to the relative velocities.

Key aspects of their method include:

  • Velocity-Based Impedance: The governing equation is formulated as $M_d(\dot{V} - \dot{V}_d) + B_d(\dot{V} - \dot{V}_d) + K_d(V - V_d)dt = E$, where $V$ and $V_d$ are actual and desired velocities, and $E$ is the force deviation. This formulation allows control without precise knowledge of desired positions.
  • Load Sensing Ring: The system utilizes a load sensing ring to measure contact forces and torques in real-time.
  • MATLAB/ADAMS Simulation: The proposed control system and the LIDM dynamics were modeled and simulated using MATLAB and ADAMS software. ADAMS was used for the multi-body dynamics simulation of the LIDM, and MATLAB was used to implement and test the control module.
  • Filtering Functions: A crucial component is a filtering function applied to the feedback loop. This filter helps manage the sensitivity of the control system to forces and torques along different axes, preventing excessive responses to minor disturbances and ensuring a smoother capture. Different filtering functions were investigated.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on simulations using models of the LIDM.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Velocity is Key for Randomness: Directly controlling impedance based on velocity, rather than position, is a more effective strategy when initial docking conditions are random and precise position tracking is not feasible.
  • Force-Velocity Relationship is Robust: The derived relationship between contact forces and velocities provides a robust mechanism for achieving low-impact docking, even with environmental uncertainties.
  • Filtering is Essential for Stability: The inclusion of a carefully designed filtering function is critical for managing the sensitivity of the control system and preventing large, sudden force/torque fluctuations, especially during contact transitions.
  • Impedance Parameters Matter: The choice of impedance parameters ($M_d, B_d, K_d$) significantly influences the response characteristics (reaction rate, damping, attenuation), and tuning these parameters is crucial for optimal performance.

Key Results

The simulations demonstrated that the velocity-based impedance control algorithm:

  • Achieves Low Impact: Contact forces and torques were kept within acceptable limits (e.g., max contact force < 250 N, max torque < 150 N·m in simulations, well within the target of < 450 N and < 450 N·m).
  • Is Robust to Randomness: The system performed well across various initial docking conditions (Cases 1-4), maintaining contact forces/torques close to expected values.
  • Responds Quickly: The algorithm showed a fast response to external forces.
  • Handles Contact Transitions: While sudden changes in contact type could momentarily increase forces/torques, the system generally managed these transitions effectively.
  • Filtering Improves Performance: Simulations comparing different filtering functions showed that the filter based on Equation (12) was more suitable for the capturing process, leading to significantly lower peak forces and torques compared to a less selective filter.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Parameter Tuning: While the paper explores the influence of impedance parameters, further optimization of these parameters and filtering functions is suggested for even better reduction of contact forces and torques.
  • Physical Testing: The study is based on simulations. Future work would involve validating these results through physical experiments with an actual LIDM.
  • Real-World Complexity: The simulations, while comprehensive, may not capture all the complexities of a real space environment (e.g., unmodeled dynamics, sensor noise).

The authors conclude that the impedance control algorithm based on velocity is robust and suitable for LIDM, but acknowledge that there is "still space or room for improvement."

Summary updated

Abstract

In this paper, an impedance control algorithm based on velocity for capturing two low impact docking mechanisms (LIDMs) is presented. The main idea of this algorithm is to track desired forces when the position errors of two LIDMs are random by designing the relationship between the velocity and contact forces measured by a load sensing ring to achieve low impact docking. In this paper, the governing equation of an impedance controller between the deviation of forces and velocity is derived, and simulations are designed to verify how impedance parameters affect the control characteristics. The performance of the presented control algorithm is validated by using the MATLAB and ADAMS software for capturing simulations. The results of capturing simulations demonstrate that the impedance control algorithm can respond fast and has excellent robustness when the environmental errors are random, and the contact forces and torques satisfy the low impact requirements.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chen2014velocity,
  author = {Chuanzhi Chen and Hong Nie and Jinbao Chen and Xiaotao Wang},
  title = {{A Velocity-Based Impedance Control System for a Low Impact Docking Mechanism (LIDM)}},
  booktitle = {Sensors},
  year = {2014},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=-HoKx06_YPY},
}
Figure