A vector radiative transfer model for simulating the microwave emissivity of sea foam based on matrix operator method

Xuchen Jin, Xianqiang He, Yan Bai, Difeng Wang, Jianyun Ying, Qiankun Zhu, Fang Gong, Chenghu Zhou, Delu PanFrontiers in Marine Science 2023 · DOI

This paper, published in Frontiers in Marine Science, introduces a more flexible way to model how sea foam interferes with satellite-based ocean observations. By applying a matrix-operator method to radiative transfer equations, the researchers have created a tool that accurately predicts microwave emissivity across various frequencies and sea conditions, which is essential for improving the accuracy of global climate data.

TL;DR

Researchers developed a new vector radiative transfer model using a matrix-operator method to simulate how sea foam affects microwave signals. The model accurately accounts for foam thickness and the vertical distribution of air bubbles, providing a vital tool for correcting satellite measurements of ocean salinity and temperature.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Satellite microwave radiometry is a cornerstone of oceanography, allowing us to measure Sea Surface Salinity (SSS) and Sea Surface Temperature (SST) from space. However, these measurements are sensitive to the state of the ocean surface. When wind speeds pick up, waves break and create sea foam.

This foam acts like a complex "blanket" that changes the surface's microwave emissivity. Because foam is a mixture of air and water, its dielectric properties vary significantly with depth (the "void fraction profile"). Existing models often struggle to handle this vertical complexity across different temperatures and frequencies. Without an accurate model for foam emissivity, satellite data can be significantly biased, leading to errors in our understanding of global water cycles and ocean circulation.

Methods

The authors propose a Vector Radiative Transfer (VRT) model based on the matrix-operator method.

  • Matrix-Operator Method: Instead of solving complex differential equations for the entire foam layer at once, the model divides the foam into several thin sub-layers. It then uses matrix algebra to calculate how radiation is reflected, transmitted, and emitted within each layer and how these layers interact.
  • Vertical Profiling: A key feature is the use of an exponential function to describe the "void fraction" (the ratio of air to water) as it changes from the top of the foam down to the seawater. This is controlled by a shape parameter ($m$).
  • Vector Approach: The model is "vector" because it simultaneously tracks both horizontal and vertical polarizations, which is critical for modern satellite sensors.
  • Simplifications: To keep the model computationally efficient, the authors assumed the foam emission is azimuthally symmetric and ignored volume scattering (the bouncing of waves between individual bubbles), arguing that seawater's high absorption makes scattering a secondary effect at lower microwave frequencies.

Datasets

The study validates the model against three distinct experimental datasets from previous literature:

  1. Camps et al. (2005): L-band (1.4 GHz) measurements taken in a controlled pool using air diffusers to generate foam.
  2. Wei et al. (2014): L-band measurements specifically focused on low-water temperature conditions (near 0°C).
  3. Rose et al. (2002): Higher frequency measurements at 10.8 GHz and 36.5 GHz.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Saturation" Effect: The impact of foam depends heavily on frequency. At high frequencies (like 37 GHz), even a very thin layer of foam (0.5 cm) "saturates" the signal, meaning the sensor only "sees" the foam and not the water beneath. At lower frequencies (L-band), the sensor can "see through" thinner foam, making the total foam thickness a much more critical variable for correction.
  • Stratification Matters: The shape of the void fraction profile (how quickly air gives way to water) is a major driver of emissivity. The authors found that a "well-stratified" layer (represented by a small shape-control parameter $m$) provided the best fit for experimental data.
  • Sensitivity to Salinity: The paper highlights that foam can cause a massive signal enhancement compared to clear seawater. Since the sensitivity of brightness temperature to salinity is quite low (0.2–0.8 K/psu), even a small amount of uncorrected foam can completely swamp the salinity signal.

Key Results

  • High Accuracy: The model showed excellent consistency with experimental data across all tested frequencies (1.4 to 36.5 GHz).
  • Low Error Rates: Root-Mean-Square (RMS) errors for horizontal polarization were consistently low, ranging from roughly 0.008 to 0.016 across different test cases.
  • Improved Performance: The model demonstrated comparable or better accuracy than the widely used Dense Medium Radiative Transfer (DMRT) models, while offering more flexibility for different seawater properties (temperature and salinity).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Ignoring Bubble Scattering: While ignoring volume scattering works well for lower frequencies, the authors note that at very high frequencies, the multi-scattering effect of bubbles becomes more significant. They plan to incorporate this into future versions of the model.
  • Flat Surface Assumption: The model treats the boundaries (air-foam and foam-water) as flat planes (Fresnel boundaries). In reality, the sea surface is rough, and future work could integrate surface roughness models to further improve realism.
  • In-situ Data Gap: The authors point out that there is still a lack of abundant in-situ (on-site) measurements of the vertical structure of foam in the open ocean, which limits the ability to perfectly tune the $m$ parameter for all sea states.

Summary updated

Abstract

Modeling sea foam emissivity is important for microwave remote sensing of the ocean. Based on the matrix-operator method, we propose a vector radiative transfer model (RTM) for the simulation of wave propagation in the foam layer and the sea foam emissivity is then calculated. The RTM simulates the emissivity of a vertically structured foam layer with various water properties. We assess the model simulations under different conditions. It is found that the foam thickness and the void fraction profile could be critical parameters in modeling foam emissivity. The sea foam emissivity could range from 0.2 to 0.3 in our simulations with varying foam thicknesses and void fraction profiles. Then, comparisons were made to experimental data for validation, and our model achieved a good consistency with the different experimental measurements of three previous studies. And it was also found that the modeled emissivity fits the experimental data well using an exponential profile with a small profile shape-control parameter.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{jin2023vector,
  author = {Xuchen Jin and Xianqiang He and Yan Bai and Difeng Wang and Jianyun Ying and Qiankun Zhu and Fang Gong and Chenghu Zhou and Delu Pan},
  title = {{A vector radiative transfer model for simulating the microwave emissivity of sea foam based on matrix operator method}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Marine Science},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/fmars.2023.1103843},
}

Loading related content...

Figure