A Unifying Framework for Linearly Solvable Control

Krishnamurthy Dvijotham, Emanuel TodorovUAI 2011

TL;DR

This paper introduces a generalized framework for linearly solvable control problems, extending existing methods like Linearly Solvable Markov Decision Processes (LMDPs) by incorporating risk sensitivity through Rényi divergences. This unified approach allows for a spectrum of behaviors from risk-averse to risk-seeking, offering a more nuanced way to design controllers for complex systems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traditional optimal control methods often struggle with computational intractability, especially in high-dimensional, nonlinear systems. While recent work has introduced "linearly solvable" control problems (like LMDPs) that offer more tractability, these often focus on minimizing expected costs. However, many real-world applications require considering not just the average outcome but also the variability or risk associated with it. For instance, in robotics or autonomous systems, understanding and mitigating the impact of noise and uncertainty is crucial. This paper addresses the need for a more general framework that can handle risk-sensitive objectives within the computationally advantageous structure of linearly solvable control.

Methods

The core innovation of this paper is the generalization of the cost function in linearly solvable control problems. Instead of solely relying on the Kullback-Leibler (KL) divergence, the authors introduce Rényi divergences, parameterized by a scalar $\alpha$. This parameter $\alpha$ directly controls the risk sensitivity:

  • For $\alpha > 0$, the framework models risk-averse behavior, penalizing higher variance in costs.
  • For $\alpha < 0$, it models risk-seeking behavior, rewarding lower variance.
  • As $\alpha \to 0$, the framework recovers the standard risk-neutral LMDPs.

This generalization leads to a modified Bellman equation that, through an exponential transformation, remains linear. The authors also provide a game-theoretic interpretation, framing the problem as a two-player zero-sum game where the controller (player 1) aims to minimize cost and an adversary (player 2) aims to maximize it, with the strength of the adversary directly related to $\alpha$.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical development and demonstrates its framework with a simulated control problem involving a point mass on a hilly terrain.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Rényi Divergences as a Unified Risk Measure: The paper elegantly shows how Rényi divergences can unify risk-neutral and risk-sensitive objectives within a single framework, offering a continuous spectrum of risk preferences.
  • Linearity Preserved: A key achievement is maintaining the linearity of the Bellman equation, which is crucial for computational tractability, even when incorporating risk sensitivity. This is achieved through a clever transformation of the value function.
  • Game-Theoretic Equivalence: The connection to two-player zero-sum games provides an intuitive understanding of risk sensitivity. A risk-averse controller ($\alpha > 0$) is effectively facing a stronger adversary, forcing more conservative decisions.
  • Compositionality of Controllers: The framework allows for combining solutions of simpler control problems to solve more complex ones, a property inherited from LMDPs and valuable for modular control design.
  • Path-Integral Representation: The optimal value function can be expressed as an expectation over trajectories sampled from the uncontrolled dynamics, offering a powerful tool for controller synthesis, particularly in continuous-time settings.

Key Results

The paper presents a generalized framework for linearly solvable control problems, termed $\alpha$-Risk Sensitive Linearly Solvable Control Problems ($\alpha$-RLCs). They demonstrate that:

  • $\alpha$-RLCs encompass previous work on LMDPs and risk-sensitive path-integral control as special cases (limits of $\alpha$).
  • The Bellman equation for $\alpha$-RLCs can be made linear, enabling efficient computation.
  • The framework allows for qualitatively different control behaviors depending on the value of $\alpha$, as illustrated by numerical experiments on a terrain-following problem. For instance, risk-averse controllers tend to favor more stable, less risky regions, while risk-seeking controllers might exploit riskier but potentially lower-cost areas.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Infinite State Spaces: While the paper proves existence of solutions for finite state spaces, the extension to infinite state spaces is acknowledged as a direction for future work, requiring appropriate technical assumptions.
  • Function Approximation: For practical applications with high-dimensional state spaces and nonlinear dynamics, developing scalable function approximation techniques for $\alpha$-RLCs is highlighted as a necessary next step.
  • Generality of $\alpha$-RLCs: An open theoretical question is whether $\alpha$-RLCs represent the most general class of linearly solvable control problems possible.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{dvijotham2011unifying,
  author = {Krishnamurthy Dvijotham and Emanuel Todorov},
  title = {{A Unifying Framework for Linearly Solvable Control}},
  booktitle = {Conference on Uncertainty in Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {2011},
}
Figure