A Unified Implicit Dialog Framework for Conversational Search

Song Feng, R. Chulaka Gunasekara, Sunil Shashidhara, Kshitij P. Fadnis, Lazaros C. PolymenakosarXiv 2018 · arXiv

Abstract

This paper presents a unified "Implicit Dialog" framework designed to automate the creation of conversational search (CS) systems. By grounding dialog logic in a Central Knowledge Representation (CKR) extracted directly from data schemas, the framework overcomes traditional bottlenecks such as domain entanglement and data scarcity. The system utilizes a modular pipeline including delexicalized Natural Language Understanding (NLU), semantic state tracking, and a human-in-the-loop dialog simulator. Experimental results demonstrate high intent classification accuracy and seamless domain transferability.

Introduction

Building Conversational Search (CS) systems—chatbots designed to help users find specific products or services—is traditionally a manual, labor-intensive process. Developers typically must explicitly model every possible user query and hard-code the underlying dialog logic. This creates two major bottlenecks: Domain Entanglement, where generic logic is fused with domain-specific knowledge, and Data Scarcity, as training these systems requires massive amounts of expensive, annotated chat data.

The proposed framework moves away from explicit rule-coding toward an "implicit" approach where the structure of the data itself defines the conversation flow.

The Implicit Dialog Framework

The core of the framework is the Central Knowledge Representation (CKR). This acts as the "brain" connecting the raw database to the conversational interface. The system scans a domain knowledge base to identify entities, attributes, and valid operations, allowing it to infer the necessary dialog slots automatically.

System architecture of the unified implicit dialog framework.

As shown in the architecture above, the pipeline consists of several modular components:

  • NLU with Delexicalization: To remain domain-agnostic, the system replaces specific terms with generic placeholders, allowing the model to learn intent rather than specific keywords.
  • State Tracking via Semantic Matching: The system uses a three-tier strategy—literal, fuzzy, and vector-based embeddings—to understand user input even when it involves typos or synonyms (e.g., matching "flat" to "apartment").
  • Prompt Generator: This component translates search results and dialog states back into natural language responses for the user.

Human-in-the-Loop Interaction

A critical component of the framework is the Dialog Simulator, a "Wizard-of-Oz" interface where humans can interact with the system in real-time. This allows the framework to collect "gold standard" dialog logs and capture the nuances of real conversation that static datasets often miss.

The Dialog Simulator interface used for human-in-the-loop refinement.

This interface visualizes how the CKR is rendered into a form (e.g., rental information like price and bedroom count) that the agent can use to guide the user through the search process.

Evaluation and Key Results

The authors evaluated the framework using the Maluuba Frames dataset and custom databases for NYC Apartment Renting and Restaurant Finding. Key findings include:

  • Intent Classification Accuracy: The system achieved an accuracy of 89% on a test set of 200+ utterances, proving the robustness of the delexicalized NLU approach.
  • Domain Agnosticism: The framework demonstrated successful "plug-and-play" capabilities. Switching from the apartment domain to the restaurant domain was achieved simply by swapping the database and re-generating the CKR, with the agent performing comparably in both scenarios.

Limitations and Future Work

While promising, the current evaluation scale is relatively small. Future work will focus on larger-scale testing in complex, multi-turn scenarios. Additionally, the authors plan to align the CKR more closely with schema.org standards to enable broader industry adoption. Finally, research is needed to determine how well implicit logic handles subjective or creative conversational tasks that are not strictly grounded in a database schema.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{feng2018unified,
  author = {Song Feng and R. Chulaka Gunasekara and Sunil Shashidhara and Kshitij P. Fadnis and Lazaros C. Polymenakos},
  title = {{A Unified Implicit Dialog Framework for Conversational Search}},
  year = {2018},
  eprint = {1802.04358},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1802.04358},
}
Figure