A Two-Level Optimal Scheduling Strategy for Central Air-Conditioners Based on Metal Model with Comprehensive State-Queueing Control Models

Yebai Qi, Dan Wang, Yu Lan, Hongjie Jia, Chengshan Wang, Kaixin Liu, Qing’e Hu, Menghua FanEnergies 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel two-level optimal scheduling strategy for central air-conditioners (CACs) to participate in demand response programs. By modeling CACs with a comprehensive state-queueing approach and employing a new intelligent optimization algorithm (SEUMRE), the strategy effectively manages CAC power consumption under multiple constraints like price and user comfort, leading to improved efficiency and performance compared to existing methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The increasing integration of renewable energy sources into power grids presents challenges due to their intermittent nature. Demand Response (DR) is a crucial tool to help stabilize the grid by managing electricity consumption. While small appliances have been explored for DR, large-capacity loads like Central Air-Conditioners (CACs) offer significant potential. However, effectively controlling CACs for DR is complex due to numerous influencing factors: user comfort levels, historical usage patterns, electricity pricing, and the inherent operational characteristics of CAC units themselves. Existing methods often struggle to simultaneously account for these diverse and often conflicting constraints, leading to suboptimal DR participation or reduced user satisfaction. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a sophisticated control strategy that holistically addresses these multi-dimensional constraints.

Methods

The paper proposes a two-level control strategy:

  • Upper Level: SEUMRE Algorithm for Target Generation: A new intelligent optimization algorithm called Space Exploration and Unimodal Region Elimination (SEUMRE) is introduced. SEUMRE is designed to efficiently solve complex, nonlinear optimization problems with expensive simulations. It works by segmenting the feasible solution space into unimodal regions, predicting promising areas for global optima, and using a Kriging meta-model for efficient sampling and screening to find optimal demand response targets for groups of CACs.
  • Lower Level: Integrated Parameter Priority List (IPPL) Strategy for Device Control: Based on the targets generated by SEUMRE, the IPPL strategy creates device-level control commands. This strategy goes beyond simple temperature control by integrating multiple parameters: temperature extending margin (TEM), user willingness, electricity price, and historical switching number. These parameters are combined into an "integrated parameter" that prioritizes which CAC units should be controlled and how, ensuring a balance between DR objectives and user comfort.

The CAC system itself is modeled using three main components: the CAC central unit, water pumps, and a temperature simulation of terminal users.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The simulation parameters are described in Table 1 and are stated to be from a city park in Southern China.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • CACs as a significant DR resource: The paper highlights the substantial untapped potential of CACs for grid stabilization due to their large power consumption.
  • Multi-dimensional constraints are key: Effective CAC control for DR requires considering a complex interplay of factors beyond just temperature, including user preferences, economic incentives, and equipment longevity.
  • SEUMRE's efficiency: The novel SEUMRE algorithm demonstrates superior convergence speed and optimization effectiveness compared to traditional methods like the interior point method, especially for problems with many variables.
  • IPPL's comprehensive approach: The IPPL strategy's ability to integrate diverse parameters allows for more nuanced and user-centric DR control, leading to better performance and potentially higher user acceptance.
  • Temperature factor's dominance: The study suggests that the temperature factor (TF) plays a particularly significant role in CAC control performance, likely due to its direct physical coupling with power consumption.

Key Results

  • The SEUMRE algorithm achieved optimal solutions in significantly less time (e.g., 1.6 hours for 60 variables) compared to the interior point method (6.2 hours for the same problem).
  • SEUMRE required only one iteration to converge for 60 CACs, while the interior point method needed three iterations.
  • The optimized target distributed by SEUMRE was found to be closer to natural power consumptions than that of the interior point method, indicating a smoother and more efficient DR response.
  • Simulation results showed that considering multiple parameters (TF, WF, PF, HSN) in the IPPL strategy led to better response results and reduced errors compared to using single parameters.
  • The proposed strategy demonstrated the ability to control CAC power consumption within a smaller range with less oscillation.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Complexity: The paper acknowledges that the optimization problem has heavy computation requirements, which is addressed by the SEUMRE algorithm.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that future work will focus on exploring more aspects of big data to offer auxiliary services and improve strategies, particularly in handling multi-variable and complex requirements. They also mention that CAC users can set parameter weightings according to personal preferences, realizing customization, which could be further explored.

Summary updated

Abstract

Unlike some thermostatically controlled appliances (TCAs) with small capacities, Central Air-conditioner (CAC) has huge potential for demand response because of its large capacity. This paper presents a new CAC control strategy under multiple constraints. The CAC is modeled by three main modules: CAC central unit, water pumps, and temperature simulation of terminal users. The CAC’s power consumption is mainly determined by users’ load ratio. As the information and communication system have become the central nervous system of the smart grid, big data analysis is of great significance. Assuming that reliable two-way communication systems are preset, an integrated parameter priority list (IPPL) control strategy is used to control and monitor CAC. A new intelligent algorithm, Space Exploration and Unimodal Region Elimination (SEUMRE) algorithm, is introduced for solving the optimization problem of demand response targets generation under multiple constraints with the help of big data analysis. In this paper, influences and constrain factors, such as price and users’ comfortable levels are taken into account to satisfy the need of actual situation. Simulation results show that the proposed approach, when comparing with other typical optimization algorithms, yields better performances and efficiency.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{qi2017two,
  author = {Yebai Qi and Dan Wang and Yu Lan and Hongjie Jia and Chengshan Wang and Kaixin Liu and Qing’e Hu and Menghua Fan},
  title = {{A Two-Level Optimal Scheduling Strategy for Central Air-Conditioners Based on Metal Model with Comprehensive State-Queueing Control Models}},
  booktitle = {Energies},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.3390/en10122133},
}
Figure