A Two Element Phased Array Coil Enabling Widespread Application of High Resolution MR Coronary Angiography

Patricia K. Nguyen, Greig Scott, Jan Engvall, Juan M. Santos, Michael V. McConnell, Graham A. Wright, Dwight G. Nishimura, John M. Pauly, Bob S. Hu, Phillip C. YangThe Open Cardiovascular Imaging Journal 2009 · DOI

Abstract

Parallel imaging using sophisticated receiver coils has improved the clinical feasibility of magnetic resonance coronary angiography (MRCA). However, these techniques are often restricted to advanced imaging centers due to high hardware costs and complexity. This study presents a custom-made, inexpensive 2-element phased array coil designed to enable high-resolution MRCA in standard clinical settings. By optimizing coil geometry specifically for the depth and size of the human heart, the prototype achieves superior signal-to-noise ratios (SNR) and anatomical coverage compared to larger, more expensive commercial alternatives.

Introduction: The Challenge of Coronary Imaging

Magnetic resonance coronary angiography (MRCA) is one of the most demanding applications of MRI. Coronary arteries are small, tortuous, and subject to constant motion from both cardiac and respiratory cycles. While multi-channel parallel imaging has made MRCA more feasible, the required hardware is often prohibitively expensive for local hospitals. Most standard facilities rely on general-purpose surface coils, which frequently lack the sensitivity required to visualize the distal (far-end) segments of coronary vessels. The authors sought to bridge this gap by designing a dedicated, inexpensive coil that any center could theoretically assemble to perform high-quality MRCA.

Design and Methodology

The research team developed a dedicated 2-element phased array coil specifically tuned for cardiac imaging at 1.5 Tesla. The design prioritizes simplicity and cost-effectiveness, utilizing copper tape to form two 4-inch circular loops.

Schematic of the custom 2-element phased array coil design, featuring two overlapping 4-inch loops optimized for cardiac depth.

The 4-inch diameter was selected to match the typical depth of the human heart within the chest cavity. This specific sizing maximizes sensitivity to the myocardium while minimizing "noise" from deeper, non-target structures. To eliminate mutual inductance (interference) between the elements, the coils were overlapped by exactly 1 inch.

The prototype was tested on 14 healthy volunteers and compared head-to-head against two industry standards: a single 5-inch surface coil and a larger commercial cardiac phased array (10 x 11 inches). Imaging was performed using a 1.5T GE scanner equipped with a real-time architecture that allowed for rapid scouting followed by high-resolution spiral data acquisition.

Comparative Performance and Results

The specialized geometry of the 2-element prototype yielded significant quantitative and qualitative improvements in vessel visualization.

  • Signal and Contrast Gains: The prototype achieved a signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) of 13.5, compared to 9.0 for the commercial array. Similarly, the contrast-to-noise ratio (CNR) nearly doubled (7.5 vs. 3.7).
  • Superior Anatomical Coverage: The most striking gain was in the visualization of distal vessel segments. The prototype successfully visualized 92.6% of all coronary segments, whereas the larger commercial array only captured 76.3%. Specifically, the distal Left Anterior Descending (LAD) artery was visualized in 93.3% of cases with the prototype, compared to only 33.3% with the commercial hardware.
High-resolution MRCA image of the coronary arteries acquired using the optimized 2-element phased array coil.

Overall, 85.9% of the images produced by the custom coil were rated as "excellent or good," outperforming both the surface coil (77%) and the commercial array (71%).

Discussion and Clinical Impact

The study demonstrates that specialized coil geometry can be more critical than raw channel count for specific applications like MRCA. While commercial arrays are versatile for whole-chest imaging, their large size dilutes sensitivity for the heart. By focusing the "receptive field" on the target anatomy, this 2-element prototype provides a high-performance, low-cost alternative for centers without access to high-end parallel imaging suites.

Future developments may involve integrating this optimized loop size into higher-density arrays (e.g., 8 or 16 channels) to combine the benefits of targeted geometry with the acceleration capabilities of modern parallel reconstruction.

Summary updated

Abstract

Parallel imaging using sophisticated receiver coils has improved the clinical feasibility of magnetic resonance coronary angiography (MRCA). These techniques, however, are not readily available outside advanced imaging centers. Our custom-made 2-element phased array coil is readily and inexpensively assembled to address this limitation and enable the widespread application of MRCA.
BibTeX
@article{nguyen2009two,
  author = {Patricia K. Nguyen and Greig Scott and Jan Engvall and Juan M. Santos and Michael V. McConnell and Graham A. Wright and Dwight G. Nishimura and John M. Pauly and Bob S. Hu and Phillip C. Yang},
  title = {{A Two Element Phased Array Coil Enabling Widespread Application of High Resolution MR Coronary Angiography}},
  journal = {The Open Cardiovascular Imaging Journal},
  year = {2009},
  doi = {10.2174/1876538600901010030},
}
Figure