A Triangular Prism Spatial Interpolation Method for Mapping Geological Property Fields

Yang Cui, Qingquan Li, Qingyuan Li, Jiasong Zhu, Chisheng Wang, Kai Ding, Dan Wang, Bisheng YangISPRS Int. J. Geo Inf 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel triangular prism-based spatial interpolation method for mapping 3D geological property fields, addressing the limitations of existing methods in capturing directional variations (anisotropy). The proposed linear and quadric interpolation algorithms demonstrate improved accuracy and efficiency in representing complex geological structures compared to traditional methods like IDW and Kriging.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Accurately mapping geological property fields in three dimensions is crucial for applications like resource exploration and hazard assessment. Existing methods often struggle to represent the inherent anisotropy of these fields, meaning properties change differently in different directions (e.g., faster vertically than horizontally). This limitation arises because many interpolation techniques, like Inverse Distance Weighting (IDW) and Kriging, treat space uniformly or are not designed to explicitly capture directional dependencies. While some methods use volume elements like tetrahedrons or hexahedrons, they also have drawbacks in terms of computational complexity or their ability to represent directivity. The authors aim to fill this gap by developing an interpolation method that leverages the triangular prism, a geometric shape that naturally lends itself to representing directional changes.

Methods

The core of this paper is the development of two new interpolation methods based on a triangular prism volume element:

  • Linear Triangular Prism Interpolation: This method is designed for layered strata and aims to achieve $C_0$ continuity within a single prism. It utilizes volume coordinates derived from the triangular prism's geometry to express property values.
  • Quadric Triangular Prism Interpolation: This method builds upon the linear approach to achieve smoother transitions between adjacent prisms, aiming for approximate $C_1$ continuity. It employs a more complex approach involving Bernstein-Bézier tetrahedron polynomials and a B-net method to construct 15 spline bases within the prism. This method also incorporates horizontal and vertical adjustments to better capture directional property changes.

The authors also detail the derivation of triangular prism volume coordinates and the interpolation principles for various point positions within the prism, including edge, surface, and degenerate cases.

Datasets

The study uses borehole data from 365 sampling points in a mining area in Qinghai Province, China. This data includes 3D coordinates and property values for four stratum layers. The organic matter content was used as the property field to simulate and interpolate.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Triangular Prism as a Natural Fit for Anisotropy: The triangular prism's geometry is inherently suited to representing directional changes in geological properties, making it a more appropriate fundamental unit than tetrahedrons or hexahedrons for capturing anisotropy.
  • Bridging Geometric and Property Models: The proposed method allows for the construction of both vector and geometric models, while also enabling the expression of internal property changes within geological bodies.
  • Quadric Interpolation for Smoothness: The quadric interpolation method significantly improves the smoothness of property transitions between adjacent prisms, leading to a more realistic representation of geological heterogeneity.
  • Directivity is Key: Explicitly accounting for directivity (directional property changes) is crucial for accurate 3D geological modeling, and the triangular prism approach excels at this.

Key Results

  • Improved Accuracy: Both the linear and quadric triangular prism interpolation methods outperformed traditional IDW and Kriging methods in terms of accuracy.
  • Quadric Superiority: The quadric triangular prism interpolation algorithm, particularly with its 15-node spline bases, showed the best performance, achieving the highest accuracy and stability.
  • Efficiency: The triangular prism interpolation algorithms were found to be less time-consuming than Kriging and IDW, while producing more distinct local property values.
  • Cross-Validation: The quadric triangular prism interpolation achieved the highest correlation coefficient ($R^2 = 0.9703$) in cross-validation, indicating a strong agreement between interpolated and actual values.
  • Visual Representation: Profile results and fence diagrams (Figures 11 and 12) visually demonstrate the superior ability of the quadric triangular prism method to capture fine details and heterogeneity in the organic matter distribution.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Continuity Between Prisms: While the linear method achieves $C_0$ continuity within a prism and the quadric method aims for approximate $C_1$ continuity, the splicing method for adjacent prisms only yields approximate $C_1$ continuity. The authors suggest addressing this issue in future research.
  • Complex Geological Structures: The current study's accuracy and reliability have not been fully established for more complex geological conditions such as folds and faults. Future work will focus on these aspects.
  • Further Algorithm Development: The paper mentions other interpolation algorithms like 13-node pyramid and 21-node hexahedral elements, suggesting potential for further exploration and refinement of triangular prism-based methods.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{cui2017triangular,
  author = {Yang Cui and Qingquan Li and Qingyuan Li and Jiasong Zhu and Chisheng Wang and Kai Ding and Dan Wang and Bisheng Yang},
  title = {{A Triangular Prism Spatial Interpolation Method for Mapping Geological Property Fields}},
  journal = {ISPRS Int. J. Geo Inf.},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.3390/ijgi6080241},
}
Figure