A Treatment of Functional Definite Descriptions

Hajime WadaCOLING 1994

TL;DR

This paper proposes a novel classification of Functional Definite Descriptions (FDDs) into two main types: relational and non-relational. It argues that FDDs behave more like pronouns than standard definite descriptions, obeying similar anaphoric resolution constraints, and presents a Discourse Representation Theory (DRT) based approach for their analysis and implementation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper tackles the challenge of understanding and formally analyzing "Functional Definite Descriptions" (FDDs). These are definite descriptions where the reference isn't directly stated but is determined functionally based on another entity in the discourse. A classic example is "Every book about Picasso made the author rich," where "the author" isn't a previously mentioned individual but is understood in relation to "book." While FDDs are common in natural language, they have been considered difficult to formalize. Previous work has offered insights but often missed the full range of FDDs or lacked a robust mechanism for their resolution. This paper aims to provide a more comprehensive classification and a principled analysis within a DRT framework, highlighting their pronominal-like behavior.

Methods

The paper proposes a classification of FDDs into two primary categories:

  • Relational FDDs: These denote relations between objects, with the relation being a lexical property of the head noun. They are further subdivided into:
  • Lexical Relations: Paraphrasable with possessives (e.g., "John's mother," "the mother of John").
  • Temporal/Locational Relations: Linking temporal or locational points (e.g., "the morning of December 31," "the top of the house").
  • Situational Roles: Linking a situation to its unique element (e.g., "the bride" in the context of "a wedding").
  • Non-Relational FDDs: These denote functions from sets of individuals to individuals, often involving modifiers like superlatives, ordinals, or identifying adjectives (e.g., "the tallest tree," "the third book," "the same girl").

The core analytical framework is Discourse Representation Theory (DRT). The authors propose that FDDs introduce discourse referents of a pronominal type and that their anaphoric links must adhere to the same accessibility conditions as pronominal anaphora. A DRT construction rule is presented for handling relational FDDs, which involves introducing relational conditions and reference markers that are then resolved through anaphora resolution.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical analysis and provides examples from natural language, but does not present experiments on specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • FDDs as Pronominal Anaphora: The most significant insight is the claim that FDDs behave more like pronouns than standard definite descriptions. This means they should follow similar constraints on anaphoric resolution, such as accessibility conditions within DRT.
  • Two-Tiered Classification: The division of FDDs into relational and non-relational types provides a structured way to understand their diverse forms and underlying mechanisms.
  • Lexical vs. Modifier Licensing: Relational FDDs are licensed by the lexical properties of their head nouns, while non-relational FDDs are licensed by modifiers (superlatives, ordinals, etc.).
  • Situational Triggers: The concept of "situation triggers" (e.g., "wedding" for "bride") is crucial for understanding situational role FDDs, suggesting a common-sense knowledge component is necessary.
  • DRT Formalization: The paper offers a concrete DRT-based approach to represent and resolve FDDs, integrating them into existing discourse processing frameworks.

Key Results

The paper presents a theoretical framework and a classification rather than quantitative results from empirical evaluation. The key "results" are the proposed classification and the analytical framework, which are demonstrated through examples. The paper shows how its DRT construction rule can handle examples like "Usually if John buys an interesting book, he writes to the author," successfully resolving the functional antecedent. It also contrasts felicitous and infelicitous FDD uses, aligning them with pronominal anaphora constraints.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Distinguishing Relational Nouns: The paper acknowledges that distinguishing between functional and non-functional nouns can be challenging, as seen in Lobner's work.
  • Formalizing Situation Triggers: While the concept of situation triggers is introduced, the paper notes the need for a more formal characterization of situations and their triggers, as well as a more general solution based on common-sense reasoning.
  • Implementation Details: The paper briefly mentions the implementation of FDD resolution within ITP's Interpretext system, highlighting the importance of hypothesis ordering for efficiency, but detailed implementation specifics are not the focus.
  • Further Research: The authors suggest that more research on functional anaphoric expressions in general is needed to fully understand FDDs. They also point to a forthcoming paper for further discussion on Functional Indefinite Descriptions (FID).

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{wada1994treatment,
  author = {Hajime Wada},
  title = {{A Treatment of Functional Definite Descriptions}},
  booktitle = {International Conference on Computational Linguistics},
  year = {1994},
}
Figure