A Transmission Efficiency Evaluation Method of Adaptive Coding Modulation for Ka-Band Data-Transmission of LEO EO Satellites

Zhongguo Wang, Fan Lu, Dabao Wang, Xiao Zhang, Jionghui Li, Jindong LiSensors 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a new metric, the Transmission Efficiency Factor (TEF), to evaluate data transmission schemes for LEO Earth Observation satellites. They demonstrate that Adaptive Coding Modulation (ACM) significantly outperforms Constant Coding Modulation (CCM) and Variable Coding Modulation (VCM), especially in areas with moderate to heavy rainfall, by balancing link availability and data rate.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

LEO Earth Observation (EO) satellites generate massive amounts of data that need to be transmitted to ground stations (G/S). Traditional methods like Constant Coding Modulation (CCM) and Variable Coding Modulation (VCM) have limitations. CCM uses fixed settings, while VCM offers some adaptability but still struggles with the dynamic nature of satellite communication, particularly the significant atmospheric attenuation at Ka-band frequencies. This attenuation, especially due to rain, can drastically reduce data throughput and necessitate larger link margins, wasting valuable satellite resources. The challenge is to find a transmission scheme that maximizes data throughput while ensuring reliable communication, especially considering the intermittent nature of LEO satellite passes and varying weather conditions.

Methods

The core contribution of this paper is the proposal of a new metric: the Transmission Efficiency Factor (TEF). TEF is defined as the product of link availability and the average useful data rate. This metric aims to provide a quantitative way to select the optimal satellite-to-ground data transmission scheme.

The authors then develop and apply this TEF to compare three schemes:

  • CCM (Constant Coding Modulation): Fixed modulation and coding scheme (MCS) throughout the transmission arc.
  • VCM (Variable Coding Modulation): MCS is switched based on elevation angles.
  • ACM (Adaptive Coding Modulation): MCS is dynamically adjusted in real-time based on the link condition (e.g., signal-to-noise ratio, atmospheric attenuation).

They also define modified TEF equations for VCM and ACM to account for their dynamic nature, incorporating time-varying data rates and link availability. The paper uses a simulation approach based on established ITU recommendations for atmospheric attenuation and a link budget analysis. They select eight MCSs from the DVB-S2 standard for their analysis.

Datasets

The paper does not use traditional "datasets" for training. Instead, it relies on:

  • Simulated data: Generated based on link budget parameters, atmospheric attenuation models (ITU-R P.618-13, P.840-8, P.676-12), and satellite orbital characteristics.
  • Real-world G/S locations: Three representative ground stations in China (Kashgar, Beijing, and Sanya) were chosen to represent different climate conditions (temperate continental, temperate monsoon, and tropical monsoon, respectively). These locations provide varying rainfall probabilities and intensities, crucial for evaluating the performance under different weather scenarios.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • TEF as a Unified Metric: The TEF provides a single, comprehensive metric that balances the often-conflicting goals of high data rate and high link availability, which is crucial for LEO satellite communication.
  • ACM's Superiority in Adverse Conditions: ACM's ability to dynamically adapt to changing atmospheric conditions, especially rain, is its key advantage. It can switch to more robust (lower rate, higher availability) MCSs when needed, preventing complete data loss.
  • The Trade-off is Critical: Simply maximizing link availability (by reserving large margins) leads to lower useful data rates, while prioritizing high data rates can result in unacceptable outage periods. TEF helps quantify this trade-off.
  • Location Matters Significantly for ACM: While ACM generally outperforms CCM and VCM, its benefit is most pronounced in locations with higher rainfall (like Sanya), where the atmospheric attenuation is more severe.

Key Results

  • ACM Significantly Improves TEF: Compared to CCM with the highest MCS (MCS 28), ACM with its minimum MCS (MCS 1) achieved substantial TEF improvements: 3.62% for Beijing (moderate rainfall) and 24.51% for Sanya (abundant rainfall).
  • Reduced Outage Periods: ACM also drastically reduces outage periods. For Beijing, the outage period was reduced by 82.47%, and for Sanya, by 75.18%.
  • VCM Offers Moderate Gains: VCM provides some improvement over CCM, but its gains are less significant than ACM, especially in wetter conditions.
  • Location-Specific Recommendations:
    • Kashgar (low rainfall) is best suited for CCM with MCS 28 due to its low atmospheric attenuation.
  • Beijing (moderate rainfall) and Sanya (abundant rainfall) benefit significantly from ACM, particularly with its minimum MCS (MCS 1) to handle adverse weather.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Simplification of VCM: The paper notes that VCM's MCS switching is based on fixed elevation angles, which is a simplification. Real-world VCM might have more complex switching criteria.
  • Focus on Ka-band: The analysis is specific to Ka-band frequencies. Future work could explore other frequency bands.
  • "Simplification of Satellite Ground Interaction": For Kashgar, the paper suggests CCM of MCS 28 is more suitable due to the minimal improvement offered by ACM and the desire for simpler ground interaction. This implies a practical engineering consideration beyond pure efficiency.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest their proposed method can be applied to system design and implementation of Ka-band ACM satellite-to-ground data transmission links, implying broader applicability and further refinement of the TEF concept.

Summary updated

Abstract

Nowadays low Earth orbit (LEO) Earth observation (EO) satellites commonly use constant coding modulation (CCM) or variable coding modulation (VCM) schemes for data transmission to ground stations (G/S). Compared with CCM and VCM, the adaptive coding modulation (ACM) could further improve the data throughput of the link by making full use of link resource and the time-varying characteristics of atmospheric attenuation. In order to comprehensively study the data transmission performance, one new index which could be utilized as a quantitative index for the satellite-to-ground data transmission scheme selection, the transmission efficiency factor (TEF) of LEO satellites is proposed and defined as "the product of the link availability and the average useful data rate". Then, the transmission efficiency of CCM, VCM and ACM at typical G/S with different weather characteristics at Ka-band is compared and analyzed. The results show that ACM is more suitable for the G/S with moderate and abundant rainfall. Compared with the CCM of MCS 28, for Beijing G/S and Sanya G/S, ACM not only improves the transmission efficiency with the TEF increased by 3.62% and 24.51%, respectively, but also improves the link availability with the outage period reduced by 82.47% and 75.18%, respectively.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2022transmission,
  author = {Zhongguo Wang and Fan Lu and Dabao Wang and Xiao Zhang and Jionghui Li and Jindong Li},
  title = {{A Transmission Efficiency Evaluation Method of Adaptive Coding Modulation for Ka-Band Data-Transmission of LEO EO Satellites}},
  booktitle = {Sensors},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/s22145423},
}
Figure