A Traceable Blockchain-Based Vaccination Record Storage and Sharing System

Jingshou Chen, Xiaofeng Chen, Chin‐Ling ChenJournal of Healthcare Engineering 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel system that leverages blockchain technology to create a secure, traceable, and shareable vaccination record (VR). By storing VRs on a decentralized blockchain, the system aims to overcome the limitations of traditional paper-based records and centralized databases, enhancing data integrity, privacy, and accessibility for both patients and healthcare providers.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The current system for managing vaccination records (VRs) is fraught with issues. Traditional paper vaccination booklets are easily lost, damaged, or forged, leading to difficulties for healthcare professionals in quickly and accurately assessing a patient's vaccination history. Relying on centralized government databases for retrieval is time-consuming and can increase medical risks, especially in urgent situations. Furthermore, the lack of direct, secure sharing mechanisms between clinics and hospitals hinders efficient data access. This paper addresses the need for a robust system that ensures the integrity, traceability, and secure sharing of VRs, while also protecting patient privacy.

Methods

The proposed solution is a blockchain-based vaccination record storage and sharing system. Key components and techniques include:

  • Blockchain Technology: Utilizes a decentralized blockchain as the core storage mechanism for VRs, ensuring immutability and transparency.
  • Smart Contracts: Programmed to manage the storage, retrieval, and access control of VRs, automating processes and enforcing security policies.
  • Elliptic Curve Digital Signature Algorithm (ECDSA): Employed for digital signatures to guarantee data integrity, nonrepudiation, and mutual authentication between parties.
  • BAN Logic: Used for formal proof of mutual authentication between system participants, ensuring secure communication.
  • Mutual Authentication: Implemented at various stages (patient-clinic, patient-hospital) to verify the identities of all parties involved.
  • Traceability: Achieved by storing VRs with signatures on the blockchain, allowing for a verifiable audit trail.
  • Data Integrity and Nonrepudiation: Ensured through cryptographic signatures and the inherent properties of blockchain.
  • Resistance to Attacks: The system is designed to withstand replay and man-in-the-middle attacks.

The system involves four main parties: the Blockchain Center (BC) (government-managed), the Patient, the Clinic, and the Hospital.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The system is designed to manage and store vaccination records, implying it would operate on real-world vaccination data, but no specific datasets were used for training or evaluation in this theoretical framework.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Blockchain as a Trust Anchor: The paper highlights how blockchain's decentralized and immutable nature can serve as a fundamental trust anchor for sensitive medical data like vaccination records, moving beyond the vulnerabilities of centralized systems.
  • Smart Contracts for Automation and Security: The use of smart contracts is crucial for automating the secure storage and sharing of VRs, reducing manual intervention and potential human error.
  • Formal Security Proofs are Essential: The application of BAN logic to formally prove mutual authentication underscores the importance of rigorous security analysis in healthcare systems.
  • Addressing Real-World Gaps: The proposed system directly tackles practical issues like lost vaccination booklets and slow data retrieval, offering a tangible improvement over existing methods.
  • Comprehensive Security Features: The system's ability to resist common attacks like replay and man-in-the-middle attacks, alongside ensuring data integrity and nonrepudiation, makes it a robust solution.

Key Results

The paper presents a theoretical framework and analyzes its security and performance.

  • Security Analysis: The system is shown to provide mutual authentication, data integrity, nonrepudiation, and resistance to replay and man-in-the-middle attacks through formal proofs (BAN logic) and cryptographic mechanisms.
  • Performance: The authors claim "good performance" with low computational and communication costs, suitable for real-time applications. Specific figures indicate transmission times in the order of milliseconds or microseconds for various network environments (3.5G, 4G, 5G).
  • Functionality Comparison: The proposed scheme is compared to previous works, demonstrating superior functionality in areas like blockchain architecture, mutual authentication, resistance to replay and man-in-the-middle attacks, and nonrepudiation.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Registration Requirement: All parties must register with the Blockchain Center (BC) and obtain public/private key pairs, which could be a barrier to adoption.
  • Dependence on Infrastructure: The system relies on stable power and network connectivity for normal operation.
  • Unpopularity/Slow Internet: The authors acknowledge potential issues with the unpopularity or slow speed of internet environments, which could impact real-time usability.

Future Work: The authors suggest improving the system by integrating artificial intelligence (AI) and deep learning techniques for storing VRs in different formats and enabling more efficient VR search.

Summary updated

Abstract

Blockchain technology is essentially a decentralized database maintained by relevant parties and has been widely used in various scenarios such as logistics and finance. In terms of applications in the medical field, it is becoming more and more important because the patient's symptoms may be related to a certain vaccine. Whether the patient has been vaccinated with this vaccine will lead to different diagnostic results by the doctor. However, in the current vaccination environment of many regions, the vaccination record (VR) can only be kept in the patient's vaccination booklet, which is easy to lose or destroy. Therefore, the doctor needs to retrieve the patient's VR through a centralized database maintained by the government, which is time-consuming and will increase the medical risk. This study proposes a traceable blockchain-based vaccination record storage and sharing system. In the proposed system, the patient gets the vaccination at any legal clinic and the VR can be saved accompanied by the signature into the blockchain center, which ensures traceability. When the patient visits the hospital for treatment, the doctor can obtain the detail of the VR from the blockchain center and then make a diagnosis. The security of the proposed system will be protected by the programmed smart contracts. Through mutual authentication, our system can also provide and guarantee data integrity and nonrepudiation. Moreover, the proposed system has resistance to replay and man-in-the-middle attacks, and the performance is good.
BibTeX
@article{chen2022traceable,
  author = {Jingshou Chen and Xiaofeng Chen and Chin‐Ling Chen},
  title = {{A Traceable Blockchain-Based Vaccination Record Storage and Sharing System}},
  journal = {Journal of Healthcare Engineering},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1155/2022/2211065},
}
Figure