A Tourist Behavior Analysis Framework Guided by Geo-Information Tupu Theory and Its Application in Dengfeng City, China

Zhihui Tian, Yi Liu, Yongji Wang, Lili WuISPRS Int. J. Geo Inf 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel framework for analyzing tourist behavior, integrating geo-information Tupu theory with social network analysis and digital footprint data. By applying this framework to Dengfeng City, China, the study reveals uneven tourist flow patterns and identifies key attractions, offering valuable insights for tourism planning and management.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding urban tourist flows and behavior is crucial as tourism develops and urban functions evolve. While existing research has explored tourist behavior using digital footprints and various methods, it often overlooks the analysis of internal mechanisms and decision-making processes. This paper aims to bridge this gap by proposing a comprehensive framework that not only analyzes spatial patterns but also delves into the underlying reasons for tourist choices and provides actionable insights for tourism development. The study focuses on Dengfeng City, a location with significant cultural tourism resources but a low proportion of tourism in its economy, highlighting the need for better strategies to leverage its potential.

Methods

The core of this research is a novel framework inspired by Geo-information Tupu theory. This theory, which combines spatial and temporal analysis with diagnosis and implementation, is adapted into three modules:

  • Spatiotemporal Database Module: This module focuses on acquiring and cleaning digital footprint data from tourists.
  • Symptom Module: This module analyzes tourist flow patterns using information extraction models. It employs:
  • Gravity Center Model: To understand the spatial characteristics and shifts of the tourist flow's center of gravity over time.
  • Three-Dimensional Density Analysis: To visualize the spatial distribution and intensity of tourist flows, revealing patterns of agglomeration and diffusion.
  • Social Network Analysis (SNA): To analyze the network structure of tourist flows, examining roles, functions, and interactions between attractions. Key SNA metrics used include:
  • Structural Holes (Effective Size and Constraint): To assess a node's competitive advantage and independence.
  • Centrality Measures (Degree, Closeness, Betweenness): To quantify a node's influence, accessibility, and role as a transit hub.
  • Core-Periphery Indicator: To classify attractions into core and edge areas and quantify their interactions.
  • Diagnosis and Implementation Module: This module integrates the findings from the symptom module to analyze internal mechanisms and inform tourism decision-making.

Datasets

The study utilizes online travel diaries as the primary source of digital footprint data. Data was collected from Qunar.com, Ctrip.com, and Mafengwo.com for the period of January 2015 to December 2018. This data was cleaned and organized into three databases: online travel diaries, attraction coordinates, and attraction visits. The paper also references the true number of tourists from the Dengfeng Tourism Bureau for validation purposes.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Geo-information Tupu as a Holistic Framework: The paper demonstrates the utility of Geo-information Tupu theory in providing a structured and comprehensive approach to tourist behavior analysis, moving beyond simple pattern identification to include underlying mechanisms and decision-making.
  • Digital Footprints for Granular Analysis: Online travel diaries, despite potential limitations, offer a rich source of data for understanding detailed tourist trajectories and preferences, especially for smaller cities.
  • Core-Periphery Structure in Tourism: The study highlights that tourist flows in Dengfeng exhibit a distinct "core-periphery" structure, with a high concentration of activity in the northern region and less interaction with the southern areas. This imbalance presents a significant challenge for balanced tourism development.
  • Attraction Interdependence: The analysis reveals that an attraction's competitive advantage is not solely based on its intrinsic appeal but also on its connections and influence on other attractions, explaining seemingly inconsistent results between popularity and centrality measures.

Key Results

  • Uneven Tourist Distribution: Tourist flows in Dengfeng are unevenly distributed, forming a clear core-periphery structure with intense internal competition and unbalanced power among attractions.
  • Northern Dominance: The northern region of Dengfeng, particularly attractions like Shaolin Temple, Pagoda Forest, San Dengfeng Village, Songyang Academy, and Junji Peak, are the most popular visiting locations.
  • Core Attractions Identified: Shaolin Temple, Songyang Academy, and Zhongyue Temple emerged as key nodes with strong competitive advantages, high centrality, and significant roles in the tourist flow network.
  • Challenges in Southern Development: The southern region, despite the emergence of Daxiongshan Xianren Valley as a tourist node, struggles to maintain attractiveness and requires targeted development strategies.
  • Core-Periphery Dynamics: The core area exhibits strong internal connectivity, with higher linkage density from the core to the edge than vice versa, indicating a strong pull from established attractions.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Representativeness: The authors acknowledge that social media users and online travel diaries may not perfectly reflect the actual number of tourists or their complete travel routes. Young and educated travelers are more likely to use these platforms, potentially skewing the data.
  • Future Data Integration: To improve data precision, future research should consider combining online travel data with official survey data obtained through stratified random sampling.
  • Balancing Regional Development: The study suggests that future tourism development in Dengfeng needs to address the disparities between the northern and southern regions. This includes developing differentiated strategies for the southern region, potentially through special tourism projects and marketing, and exploring ways to balance development in the central and northern regions, perhaps by leveraging attractions with low constraint values.
  • Optimizing Network Flow: Recommendations include improving traffic guidance around core areas, optimizing public transportation, and developing new attractions to alleviate bottlenecks and promote flow to edge areas.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{tian2022tourist,
  author = {Zhihui Tian and Yi Liu and Yongji Wang and Lili Wu},
  title = {{A Tourist Behavior Analysis Framework Guided by Geo-Information Tupu Theory and Its Application in Dengfeng City, China}},
  journal = {ISPRS Int. J. Geo Inf.},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/ijgi11040250},
}
Figure