A Topological-Framework to Improve Analysis of Machine Learning Model Performance

Henry Kvinge, Colby Wight, Sarah Akers, Scott Howland, Woongjo Choi, Xiaolong Ma, Luke Gosink, Elizabeth Jurrus, Keerti Kappagantula, Tegan H. EmersonarXiv 2021 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel topological framework to analyze machine learning model performance, treating datasets as "spaces" rather than simple collections of points. This approach allows for a more principled and fine-grained understanding of model behavior across various data subpopulations, moving beyond simplistic global accuracy metrics.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As machine learning models become larger and more complex, and the datasets they are trained on grow in size, relying on a few summary statistics (like overall accuracy) to evaluate performance is becoming increasingly inadequate. This is especially problematic in real-world applications where understanding why and where a model fails is crucial. Current evaluation methods can obscure critical failures on specific subsets of data, a phenomenon known as underspecification. The authors aim to provide a more robust and insightful way to analyze model performance by considering the inherent structure and metadata within datasets.

Methods

The core of the paper is the proposal of a "topological framework" for dataset analysis. This involves:

  • Datasets as Topological Spaces: Instead of treating a dataset as a flat set of points, the authors suggest viewing it as a topological space. This space is constructed using metadata associated with the data points (e.g., image attributes, labels) as a subbasis. This allows for defining notions of "neighborhoods" and "proximity" between data points based on their shared characteristics, going beyond simple feature similarity.
  • Presheaves for Performance Encoding: To systematically store and analyze model performance across these topological spaces, the paper leverages presheaves. A presheaf is a mathematical structure that allows data (in this case, model performance metrics like accuracy) to be attached to open sets (subpopulations) within the topological space. Crucially, presheaves define restriction maps that enable comparing performance data between different, potentially overlapping, subpopulations.
  • Accuracy Presheaf: The authors specifically define an "accuracy presheaf" where the value attached to an open set is the model's accuracy on the data points within that set. This allows for detailed analysis of how accuracy varies across different data subsets.

Datasets

  • Caltech-UCSD Birds 200 dataset (Wah et al., 2011): This dataset, containing 11,788 images of birds across 200 species, was used for experimental evaluation. It's notable for its rich metadata, including 312 binary attributes per bird, which were instrumental in constructing the topological subbasis.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Beyond Global Metrics: The paper strongly advocates for moving beyond single-number evaluations. By treating datasets as spaces, we can uncover nuanced performance differences across subpopulations that are invisible to global metrics.
  • Metadata as Structure: The authors highlight that dataset metadata isn't just descriptive; it can be used to define a meaningful topological structure, revealing relationships between data points that are not immediately obvious from the data itself.
  • Principled Subpopulation Analysis: The topological framework provides a mathematically rigorous way to define and analyze performance on arbitrary subpopulations, including those defined by combinations of attributes and classes.
  • Local vs. Global Performance: The framework allows for precise definitions of "local" performance (e.g., how a model performs in the vicinity of a specific data point) and how performance changes as we move between related subpopulations.

Key Results

  • Performance Variation: Using a ResNet18 model trained on the Caltech-UCSD Birds 200 dataset, the authors demonstrated significant performance variations. While the overall test set accuracy was 0.571, the model achieved 1.000 accuracy on 16 subpopulations and 0.000 on 18 subpopulations.
  • Attribute-Based Performance: The analysis revealed that certain attributes, like "bright colors" (red, blue, green), were associated with higher accuracy, while others, like "underparts color: grey ∩ throat color: blue," led to perfect accuracy on specific subsets.
  • Local Inconsistency: The paper introduced a measure of "local k-bounded inconsistency" to quantify how much performance changes when restricting to smaller subsets. They found higher inconsistency on subsets defined by attributes compared to those defined by classes.
  • Neighborhood Analysis: The framework enabled analyzing a specific image by examining the model's performance in its topological "neighborhoods," revealing that the model performed poorly on images of rhinoceros auklets lacking bright plumage but well on those characterized by bird shape or bill features.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Complexity: The authors acknowledge that constructing and analyzing the full topology of a large dataset can be computationally intensive. They suggest limiting the number of intersections and unions considered in practice.
  • Scope of Analysis: The toy experiments in Section 5 used only a small subset of the full topology. A more comprehensive analysis would require exploring a larger portion of the topological space.
  • Future Directions: The authors express hope that this work is a first step towards using human spatial intuition to evaluate complex ML models. They suggest that this framework can be extended to analyze other performance statistics beyond accuracy, such as loss, precision, or recall, and applied to a wider range of datasets and model architectures.

Summary updated

Abstract

As both machine learning models and the datasets on which they are evaluated have grown in size and complexity, the practice of using a few summary statistics to understand model performance has become increasingly problematic. This is particularly true in real-world scenarios where understanding model failure on certain subpopulations of the data is of critical importance. In this paper we propose a topological framework for evaluating machine learning models in which a dataset is treated as a "space" on which a model operates. This provides us with a principled way to organize information about model performance at both the global level (over the entire test set) and also the local level (on specific subpopulations). Finally, we describe a topological data structure, presheaves, which offer a convenient way to store and analyze model performance between different subpopulations.
BibTeX
@misc{kvinge2021topological,
  author = {Henry Kvinge and Colby Wight and Sarah Akers and Scott Howland and Woongjo Choi and Xiaolong Ma and Luke Gosink and Elizabeth Jurrus and Keerti Kappagantula and Tegan H. Emerson},
  title = {{A Topological-Framework to Improve Analysis of Machine Learning Model Performance}},
  year = {2021},
  eprint = {2107.04714},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2107.04714},
}
Figure