A Time Series Study for Effects of PM10 on Coronary Heart Disease in Ganzhou, China

Tingting Liu, Hui Huang, Gonghua HuInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that even low concentrations of PM10 air pollution are linked to increased daily hospitalizations for coronary heart disease (CHD) in Ganzhou, China. The findings highlight that older adults and females are particularly vulnerable, underscoring the need for targeted public health interventions to protect susceptible populations.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Air pollution, particularly particulate matter (PM), is a well-established threat to human health, especially cardiovascular health. While much research has focused on high pollution areas, there's a growing concern about the health impacts of PM exposure even at levels below current regulatory standards. This paper addresses the question of whether short-term exposure to low concentrations of PM10 can still trigger hospitalizations for coronary heart disease (CHD) in a specific region of China, Ganzhou, which has a subtropical monsoon climate and a significant elderly population. Understanding this relationship is crucial for developing effective local environmental policies, especially for vulnerable groups.

Methods

The researchers employed a time-series analysis using two statistical modeling techniques:

  • Generalized Additive Model (GAM): This model was used to assess the health effects of PM10 at different lag days (immediate and delayed effects) and sliding-average lags. It allows for flexible modeling of non-linear relationships between PM10 and CHD hospitalizations, while controlling for confounding factors like long-term time trends, temperature, relative humidity, and day-of-the-week effects.
  • Distributed Lag Non-linear Model (DLNM): This advanced technique was used to specifically model the exposure-response relationship between PM10 concentration and the relative risk of CHD hospitalizations. It allows for the examination of both the lag structure (how delayed effects manifest) and the shape of the dose-response curve.

The study also conducted subgroup analyses to investigate whether the association between PM10 and CHD hospitalizations differed by gender and age. Furthermore, a dual-pollutant model was used to assess the robustness of the PM10 association when accounting for the presence of other common air pollutants (SO2, CO, and O3). Model stability was further tested by varying the degrees of freedom.

Datasets

The study utilized three primary datasets collected in Ganzhou, China, between January 1, 2019, and December 31, 2021:

  • Daily hospitalization data for CHD: Obtained from the electronic medical record systems of two major tertiary hospitals in Ganzhou. A total of 33,653 CHD inpatient records were collected, including patient demographics (age, sex), admission date, and principal diagnosis.
  • Daily air quality monitoring data: Collected from five state-controlled monitoring points in Ganzhou. This included daily concentrations of PM10, PM2.5, SO2, NO2, and CO, as well as the maximum 8-hour average concentration of O3.
  • Meteorological data: Daily average temperature and humidity data were obtained from the Ganzhou Meteorological Bureau.

The paper notes that there were no missing values for the air pollutant concentration and meteorological data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Low-level PM10 is not benign: The study strongly suggests that even when PM10 concentrations are below China's secondary standard, they can still trigger significant health events like CHD hospitalizations. This challenges the assumption that current air quality standards are sufficient for protecting public health.
  • Delayed effects matter: The impact of PM10 exposure on CHD hospitalizations isn't always immediate. The study found significant associations at lag days 0 and 1, with the strongest effect observed at lag 1, indicating a delayed physiological response.
  • Vulnerable subgroups identified: The research pinpoints older adults (≥65 years) and females as being more sensitive to the effects of PM10. This is a critical insight for public health messaging and targeted interventions.
  • Robustness of findings: The association between PM10 and CHD hospitalizations remained significant even after adjusting for other common air pollutants and when varying model parameters, lending strong credibility to the findings.
  • Non-linear exposure-response: The relationship between PM10 concentration and CHD hospitalization risk isn't linear. The risk increases significantly at lower PM10 levels (10-30 µg/m³), plateaus in the mid-range (30-100 µg/m³), and slightly decreases at very high concentrations (>100 µg/m³), possibly due to long-term adaptation or selection bias.

Key Results

  • A 10 µg/m³ increase in PM10 was associated with a 1.69% increase in daily CHD hospitalizations at lag day 1 (95% CI: 0.39~3.00%).
  • The cumulative lag effect (lag0-1) showed a 2.10% increase in CHD hospitalizations per 10 µg/m³ increase in PM10 (95% CI: 0.59~3.62%).
  • Females showed a slightly greater cumulative effect (lag0-2) of 2.56% increase in CHD hospitalization risk per 10 µg/m³ PM10 increase, compared to males (1.97%).
  • Elderly individuals (≥65 years) were significantly associated with PM10 at lag day 1, while younger individuals (<65 years) showed an association at lag day 0. The cumulative lag effect (lag0-2) was higher for the elderly.
  • In the dual-pollutant model, adjusting for SO2, CO, and O3, the effect of PM10 on CHD hospitalization risk was still significant, with increases ranging from 1.78% to 2.23%.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Ecological study design: The study cannot establish individual causality due to the inability to control for individual confounding factors like diet, lifestyle, and socioeconomic status.
  • Exposure misclassification: Using average values from five monitoring points may not accurately represent individual exposure.
  • COVID-19 impact: The period included the COVID-19 pandemic, during which mask-wearing might have reduced PM inhalation, potentially underestimating the true impact.
  • Single-city study: The findings are specific to Ganzhou and may not be generalizable to other regions with different pollution compositions, climates, or populations.
  • Limited disease specificity: The study did not differentiate between specific types of CHD.
  • Unclear admission status: It was not possible to distinguish between new admissions and readmissions.

Future work suggested includes multi-city studies to assess the generalizability of findings and further analysis into the specific composition of fine particulate matter and its influence on CHD. The authors also emphasize the need for more evidence to clarify gender differences in PM10 sensitivity.

Summary updated

Abstract

Objective: To investigate the effect of PM10 exposure in low concentration areas on the daily hospitalized patients with coronary heart disease. Methods: Daily air quality monitoring data, meteorological monitoring data and daily hospitalization data of coronary heart disease during 2019−2021 in Ganzhou, China were collected. Generalized additive model and distributed lag nonlinear model were used to evaluate the association between environmental PM10 and daily hospital visits for coronary heart disease. Stratified by sex and age to see their potential impact on this association. Results: PM10 exposure was correlated with an increased risk of hospitalization in coronary heart disease patients. Single-pollutant model analysis shows that at the day of lag1, for every 10 µg/m3 increase in PM10, the risk of coronary heart disease hospitalization increased by 1.69% (95%CI 0.39~3.00%); Subgroup analysis showed that females and older adults (>65 years) were more sensitive to PM10 exposure. In addition, in the dual-pollutant model, by adjusting other pollutants (including SO2, CO and O3), it was found that the relationship between PM10 exposure and coronary heart disease hospitalization was robust. And with changing the model’s degree of freedom was still robust. Conclusion: Short-term exposure to low concentrations of PM10 is associated with hospitalization for coronary heart disease. These results are important for local environmental public health policy development, so as to protect vulnerable populations.
BibTeX
@article{liu2022time,
  author = {Tingting Liu and Hui Huang and Gonghua Hu},
  title = {{A Time Series Study for Effects of PM10 on Coronary Heart Disease in Ganzhou, China}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph20010086},
}
Figure