A Thermally Robust Method of Sample Sealing for Capillary DLS

Alexander V. Malm, Sharla Harvey, Jake Austin, Darrell BancarzSSRN 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel and robust method for sealing capillaries used in Dynamic Light Scattering (DLS) experiments, specifically addressing the limitations of previous sealing techniques with organic solvents and elevated temperatures. By employing a UV-curing resin, researchers can now perform thermal ramp studies on small sample volumes without compromising data integrity, opening doors for more complex assays in pharmaceutical development and materials science.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Dynamic Light Scattering (DLS) is a powerful technique for determining particle size in dispersions. Recently, capillary DLS has emerged as a valuable approach for analyzing very small sample volumes, which is particularly crucial for precious or limited samples, such as those encountered in drug development. However, a significant hurdle for capillary DLS has been the sealing method. Previous protocols relied on clay-based seals, which are incompatible with organic solvents and fail at elevated temperatures (around 40°C). This limitation restricted the application of capillary DLS to simpler aqueous systems and prevented its use in thermal aggregation studies, where samples are subjected to increasing temperatures to assess stability. This paper tackles the problem of developing a sealing method that is compatible with a wider range of solvents and can withstand the thermal stresses of temperature ramp experiments, thereby expanding the utility of low-volume capillary DLS.

Methods

The core of this paper is the development and validation of a new sample sealing method for capillary DLS. The authors explored and rejected several traditional sealing techniques:

  • Clay with PTFE: While an attempt was made to improve clay seals with PTFE tape, this method still failed at elevated temperatures, leading to sample loss.
  • Wax: Wax sealing was found to be problematic due to potential interactions with the sample and the difficulty in achieving a consistent seal at temperatures required for thermal stress studies.
  • 3D Printing Pen (PLA/ABS): Although these materials offer higher temperature resistance, the process was found to be difficult and posed a risk of sample contamination due to the proximity of the hot extruder.

The novel approach presented involves using a UV-curing resin applied with a pen-like applicator. This resin is applied to the open end(s) of the capillary, and then cured using a UV light source, which takes approximately 5 seconds. This method allows for precise application and rapid sealing. The authors then subjected this method to rigorous testing, including:

  • Thermal ramp measurements: To assess the seal's integrity under increasing temperatures.
  • Chemical compatibility tests: Using various organic solvents to determine if the resin degrades or leaks.
  • Repeatability and reproducibility testing: To ensure the method is consistent across multiple measurements, users, and instruments.
  • Comparison with conventional methods: Results were compared against measurements in low-volume quartz cells.

Datasets

The paper does not explicitly mention "datasets" in the traditional machine learning sense. Instead, it utilizes well-characterized standard samples for evaluation:

  • Bovine Serum Albumin (BSA): Used extensively for thermal ramp studies to investigate aggregation behavior.
  • 200 kDa Polystyrene Standard: Used in toluene to test chemical compatibility with organic solvents.
  • 38 nm Silica Sample (Ludox): Used to assess the thermal stability and potential degradation of the UV resin itself.

These samples are standard materials used in DLS characterization, allowing for direct comparison with established knowledge and conventional methods.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • UV-curing resin is a game-changer for capillary DLS: The UV resin offers a robust, repeatable, and thermally stable seal, overcoming the limitations of previous methods. This significantly broadens the applicability of low-volume capillary DLS.
  • Thermal ramp studies are now feasible with minimal sample: The ability to perform thermal aggregation studies on small sample volumes (as low as 10 µL) is a major advancement, particularly for expensive or limited biological samples.
  • Chemical compatibility extends DLS applications: The UV resin's compatibility with a range of organic solvents means capillary DLS can now be used for non-aqueous systems, opening up new avenues for materials science and formulation studies.
  • Sealing both ends is crucial for thermal ramps: While sealing one end of the capillary was sufficient for isothermal measurements, sealing both ends was found to be essential to prevent sample movement and signal loss during temperature ramps.
  • The method is user-friendly and reproducible: The UV resin sealing method was demonstrated to be easily transferable between users and instruments, indicating its practical utility in a research setting.

Key Results

  • The UV curing resin sealing method successfully maintained sample integrity during thermal ramps up to at least 70°C, with no observed sample loss or significant degradation of the seal.
  • Measurements of BSA aggregation using the sealed capillaries showed good agreement with those obtained using conventional low-volume quartz cells, both in terms of hydrodynamic size and the onset of aggregation.
  • Chemical compatibility tests showed that the UV resin was compatible with most tested organic solvents for short-term measurements (1 min), and several for longer durations (24 h), with only hexane and acetone showing leakage after 24 hours.
  • Repeatability and reproducibility tests demonstrated good agreement between measurements performed by a single operator, across different users, and on different instruments, highlighting the robustness of the method.
  • The method allows for reliable measurements with as little as 3 µL of sample, and typically 10 µL is loaded into the capillary.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Solvent Compatibility Limitations: While generally good, the UV resin showed leakage with hexane and acetone after 24 hours. This means that for long-term storage or measurements in these specific solvents, alternative methods or shorter measurement times might be necessary.
  • Potential for Resin Degradation: Although tests with a silica sample indicated no apparent degradation of the resin affecting measurements, the authors acknowledge that the stability of the resin as a function of temperature and time warrants further investigation, especially for very long-term studies or extreme conditions.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that this method opens up possibilities for a wider range of measurements, including those involving organic solvents and complex thermal assays. Further exploration of the resin's compatibility with an even broader spectrum of chemicals and its long-term stability under various conditions would be beneficial. The potential for automating this sealing process could also be a future direction.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{malm2023thermally,
  author = {Alexander V. Malm and Sharla Harvey and Jake Austin and Darrell Bancarz},
  title = {{A Thermally Robust Method of Sample Sealing for Capillary DLS}},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.2139/ssrn.4359641},
  howpublished = {SSRN},
}

Loading related content...

Figure