A theoretical explanation of the effect of oxygen poisoning on industrial Haber-Bosch catalysts

Brian A. Rohr, Aayush R. Singh, Jens K. NørskovJournal of Catalysis 2019 · DOI

Abstract

The industrial Haber-Bosch process for ammonia synthesis requires high temperatures and pressures, presenting a significant energy challenge. Efforts to transition to low-temperature, decentralized production are hindered by a rapid decline in reaction rates as temperatures drop. This study provides a theoretical explanation for this phenomenon, identifying "oxygen poisoning" from trace water vapor as the primary cause. Using density functional theory (DFT) and microkinetic modeling, we demonstrate that while potassium promoters enhance activity by stabilizing transition states, they simultaneously increase the catalyst's oxophilicity, leading to site blockage at lower temperatures where entropic protection is lost.

Introduction

The Haber-Bosch process is a cornerstone of modern agriculture, yet its reliance on extreme conditions (~400–500°C and ~150–250 bar) necessitates massive, centralized infrastructure. Developing catalysts capable of operating at lower temperatures and pressures is essential for integrating ammonia production with intermittent renewable energy sources. However, experimental observations show that ammonia synthesis rates on industrial catalysts collapse at lower temperatures far more severely than predicted by standard kinetic theories. This research investigates the role of oxygen atoms, derived from trace water vapor, in poisoning the active sites of these catalysts.

Theoretical Framework and Methodology

To investigate the poisoning mechanism, the study employed a multi-scale theoretical approach. First, Density Functional Theory (DFT) calculations were performed to determine the chemisorption energies of key intermediates (N, NH, NH₂, NH₃, O, and OH) on various metal surfaces, including Rhenium, Ruthenium, Iron, Rhodium, and Platinum.

A critical component of the model was the inclusion of potassium (K) promoters, which are standard in industrial iron catalysts. The active site was modeled as a stepped metal surface promoted by K atoms to simulate industrial conditions.

Top and side views of the K-promoted metal surface model used in DFT calculations.

These DFT results were then integrated into a steady-state microkinetic model. By utilizing scaling relations—linear correlations between the binding energies of different species—the researchers could simulate ammonia production rates across a wide range of temperatures, pressures, and water concentrations.

The Role of Potassium Promoters

Potassium is a "double-edged sword" in ammonia synthesis. The study reveals that K-promotion shifts the scaling relations of the catalyst surface in several beneficial ways: it stabilizes the N-N bond-breaking transition state and destabilizes $NH_x$ intermediates, preventing them from occupying active sites.

However, these benefits come at a cost. The presence of potassium significantly increases the oxophilicity (oxygen affinity) of the surface. As shown in the scaling relation plots, the binding energy of oxygen ($E_O$) is strengthened in the presence of potassium compared to pure metal steps, while $NH_x$ species are destabilized.

Scaling relations for reaction intermediates on metal and K-promoted steps, illustrating the shift in binding energies.

Results: Temperature-Dependent Poisoning

The model successfully validated experimental data for industrial BASF S 6–10 catalysts, capturing the three-order-of-magnitude drop in production when cooling from 550°C to 380°C in the presence of just 30 ppm water.

The primary driver of this collapse is the loss of "entropic protection." At high industrial temperatures, the high entropy of gas-phase water makes the adsorption of oxygen energetically unfavorable. As the temperature decreases, the entropic penalty for adsorption diminishes. Because the K-promoted surface binds oxygen so strongly, even parts-per-million levels of water vapor become sufficient to completely cover the active sites with oxygen atoms, effectively "choking" the catalyst.

Conclusion and Future Directions

This work identifies oxygen poisoning as the fundamental barrier to low-temperature Haber-Bosch synthesis on promoted iron catalysts. To overcome this, future catalyst design must focus on breaking the link between N-N activation and oxygen binding. Potential strategies include the development of "extreme oxygen guards" to purify feed gases or the engineering of catalysts that maintain high activity while exhibiting lower oxophilicity. While this study focused on K-promoted transition metals, the "oxygen poisoning" lens provides a vital framework for evaluating alternative catalyst classes, such as nitrides or complex hydrides, in the quest for sustainable ammonia production.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{rohr2019theoretical,
  author = {Brian A. Rohr and Aayush R. Singh and Jens K. Nørskov},
  title = {{A theoretical explanation of the effect of oxygen poisoning on industrial Haber-Bosch catalysts}},
  journal = {Journal of Catalysis},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1016/j.jcat.2019.01.042},
}

Loading related content...

Figure