A theoretical evaluation of possible transition metal electro-catalysts for N2reduction

Egill Skúlason, Thomas Bligaard, Sigríður Guðmundsdóttir, Felix Studt, Jan Rossmeisl, Frank Abild‐Pedersen, Tejs Vegge, Hannes Jónsson, Jens K. NørskovPhysical 2011 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper uses theoretical calculations to explore the feasibility of electrochemically producing ammonia at ambient conditions. It identifies early transition metals like Sc, Y, Ti, and Zr as promising candidates, particularly on defect-free surfaces, due to their strong binding of nitrogen intermediates, which favors ammonia formation over competing hydrogen production.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Haber-Bosch process, the dominant industrial method for ammonia synthesis, requires high temperatures and pressures, making it energy-intensive and centralized. There's a significant need for alternative, more sustainable ammonia production methods, such as electrochemical reduction of nitrogen (N₂) at ambient conditions. While nitrogenase enzymes in nature achieve this, replicating their efficiency in artificial systems has been challenging due to slow kinetics and the competing, more favorable reaction of hydrogen gas formation. This paper aims to identify transition metal catalysts that can overcome these kinetic limitations and selectively produce ammonia.

Methods

The researchers employed Density Functional Theory (DFT) calculations to model the energetics of various elementary steps involved in N₂ reduction. They utilized the computational standard hydrogen electrode (SHE) method to account for the influence of applied electrochemical potentials and pH. To predict trends in catalytic activity across a range of transition metals, they established linear scaling relationships between the adsorption energies of different intermediates (like N, N₂H, and N₂H₂) and the binding energy of N adatoms. This allowed them to construct "volcano plots" that map catalytic activity against a descriptor (N binding energy) and identify optimal materials. Both flat and stepped surfaces of various transition metals were investigated.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on theoretical calculations rather than experimental datasets for training or evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Early Transition Metals Shine: Early transition metals (Sc, Y, Ti, Zr) show significant promise because they bind nitrogen adatoms much more strongly than hydrogen adatoms. This strong N binding is crucial for overcoming the high activation barrier of N₂ dissociation and favoring ammonia formation over hydrogen evolution.
  • Surface Structure Matters: Defect-free (flat) surfaces of these early transition metals are predicted to be more catalytically active for ammonia synthesis than their stepped counterparts.
  • Mechanism Dependence: Both associative (similar to enzyme mechanisms) and dissociative (similar to Haber-Bosch) pathways were considered. For early transition metals, the dissociative mechanism is favored due to strong N binding.
  • Volcano Plots as Guides: The use of volcano plots, correlating catalytic activity with N adatom binding energy, effectively visualizes trends and identifies optimal materials for both flat and stepped surfaces, and for different reaction mechanisms.
  • Potential is Key: Applying a negative electrochemical potential is essential to drive the energetically uphill steps in the N₂ reduction pathway, making the overall process thermodynamically favorable.

Key Results

  • Promising Catalysts: Mo, Fe, Rh, and Ru were identified as active catalysts, but hydrogen formation remains a significant competitor.
  • Selective Ammonia Production: Early transition metals (Sc, Y, Ti, Zr) are predicted to favor ammonia production over hydrogen gas formation at applied potentials of -1 V to -1.5 V vs. SHE, due to their strong N-adatom binding.
  • Optimal Conditions: For flat surfaces of early transition metals, a dissociative mechanism is favored, with an estimated potential of around -1.0 V to -1.5 V vs. SHE.
  • Ru Performance: For Ru, a well-studied catalyst, the associative mechanism requires a potential of -1.08 V on flat surfaces and -0.43 V or -0.94 V on stepped surfaces to become downhill. The dissociative mechanism on stepped Ru requires a lower potential of -0.16 V.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Approximations: The study acknowledges several approximations: neglecting lateral interactions between adsorbates, assuming activation energy barriers are solely dictated by thermodynamics, and not explicitly including water molecules (though H-bonding effects were estimated).
  • Water's Role: The explicit inclusion of water in simulations would significantly increase computational cost but could provide a more detailed understanding of its stabilizing effects on intermediates.
  • Potential-Dependent Barriers: The study did not account for potential-dependent or independent activation barriers that might be larger than thermodynamic predictions.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that future work should include more detailed modeling of solvated ions and explicitly incorporate water into the simulations. They also recommend experimentalists investigate the N₂ reduction on early transition metals.

Summary updated

Abstract

Theoretical studies of the possibility of forming ammonia electrochemically at ambient temperature and pressure are presented. Density functional theory calculations were used in combination with the computational standard hydrogen electrode to calculate the free energy profile for the reduction of N(2) admolecules and N adatoms on several close-packed and stepped transition metal surfaces in contact with an acidic electrolyte. Trends in the catalytic activity were calculated for a range of transition metal surfaces and applied potentials under the assumption that the activation energy barrier scales with the free energy difference in each elementary step. The most active surfaces, on top of the volcano diagrams, are Mo, Fe, Rh, and Ru, but hydrogen gas formation will be a competing reaction reducing the faradaic efficiency for ammonia production. Since the early transition metal surfaces such as Sc, Y, Ti, and Zr bind N-adatoms more strongly than H-adatoms, a significant production of ammonia compared with hydrogen gas can be expected on those metal electrodes when a bias of -1 V to -1.5 V vs. SHE is applied. Defect-free surfaces of the early transition metals are catalytically more active than their stepped counterparts.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{skulason2011theoretical,
  author = {Egill Skúlason and Thomas Bligaard and Sigríður Guðmundsdóttir and Felix Studt and Jan Rossmeisl and Frank Abild‐Pedersen and Tejs Vegge and Hannes Jónsson and Jens K. Nørskov},
  title = {{A theoretical evaluation of possible transition metal electro-catalysts for N<sub>2</sub>reduction}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2011},
  doi = {10.1039/c1cp22271f},
}
Figure