A Theoretical Analysis of the Pricing and Advertising Strategies with Lévy-Walking Consumers

Wei Wang, Gang LiJournal of Theoretical and Applied Electronic Commerce Research 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel economic model that incorporates "Lévy-walking" consumer behavior into pricing and advertising strategies. It finds that consumers converging towards a firm leads to higher prices and advertising, boosting both profits and social welfare. Interestingly, the distance consumers travel (Average Movement Distance - AMD) has opposing effects: it amplifies the impact of convergence on advertising but dampens it on pricing.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In today's hyper-connected world, mobile devices and proximity technologies (like beacons and geofencing) allow businesses to track consumer movements with unprecedented detail. This creates a direct link between consumer mobility and a firm's marketing and operational strategies. However, traditional economic models often assume static consumer locations, failing to capture the dynamic nature of how people move and how this movement influences purchasing decisions. This paper aims to bridge that gap by developing a theoretical framework to understand how consumer mobility, specifically their tendency to move in patterns resembling "Lévy walks," impacts a firm's optimal pricing and advertising strategies, and ultimately, social welfare.

Methods

The authors build an analytical model based on a linear Hotelling city, where consumers are distributed and can move. The core innovation is the incorporation of Lévy-walking behavior to model consumer movement. This means a consumer's step size (distance traveled) follows a power-law distribution, a pattern observed in many real-world human mobility studies.

Key aspects of their model include:

  • Lévy Walks: Capturing the "heavy-tailed" nature of human movement, where occasional long-distance jumps are common.
  • Overall Movement Tendency (OMT): Represented by parameter $\tau$, indicating whether consumers are more likely to move towards ($\tau > 0.5$, Convergent Movement - CM), away from ($\tau < 0.5$, Divergent Movement - DM), or equally split ($\tau = 0.5$, Symmetric Movement - SM) the firm.
  • Average Movement Distance (AMD): Represented by parameter $\beta$, where a smaller $\beta$ signifies a longer AMD.
  • Proximity Technologies: The model considers scenarios both with and without these technologies, allowing for an analysis of their impact.

The analysis involves deriving optimal pricing and advertising strategies for a firm that aims to maximize its profit, and then examining the resulting market outcomes and social welfare.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper presents a theoretical model and uses numerical analysis for illustration, rather than empirical datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Convergent Effect": When consumers are more likely to move towards a firm (CM), the firm benefits. It can increase its product price and advertising level, leading to higher profits and increased consumer surplus, ultimately boosting social welfare. This suggests that firms should adapt their strategies to capitalize on consumer convergence.
  • Opposing Influences of AMD: The distance consumers travel (AMD) plays a crucial, and somewhat counter-intuitive, role. Longer AMD (smaller $\beta$) strengthens the impact of convergence on advertising strategies (firms advertise more) but weakens its impact on pricing strategies (firms are less inclined to raise prices significantly).
  • Under-Advertising Tendency: The study confirms a common finding that firms tend to under-advertise compared to the socially optimal level. However, consumer convergence suppresses this under-advertising tendency. This suppression is, in turn, weakened by longer AMD.
  • Proximity Technologies' Double-Edged Sword: While proximity technologies generally improve a firm's ability to adjust strategies and increase profits, their impact on consumer surplus is mixed. In the CM case, consumer surplus increases. However, in the DM case, it decreases, though social welfare can still increase if AMD is long enough. This highlights the complex interplay between technology, consumer behavior, and market outcomes.

Key Results

  • CM vs. DM: Convergent movement (CM) leads to higher prices, advertising, demand, profit, consumer surplus, and social welfare compared to symmetric (SM) or divergent (DM) movement. Conversely, DM leads to lower outcomes across the board.
  • AMD's Impact:
    • In CM: Longer AMD leads to higher advertising levels and lower price increases.
  • In DM: Longer AMD leads to lower advertising levels and higher price increases.
  • Profitability: Longer AMD magnifies the profit gains from CM but also magnifies profit losses from DM.
  • Proximity Technologies: Numerical analysis shows that proximity technologies generally increase firm profit. Their effect on consumer surplus is positive in CM but negative in DM. Social welfare can be improved by these technologies even in DM scenarios if AMD is long.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations and suggest avenues for future research:

  • Monopoly Setting: The current model assumes a single firm. Future work could explore market competition, where convergence might lead to price wars rather than price increases.
  • Homogeneous Consumer Preferences: The model assumes all consumers have the same base utility for the product. Relaxing this to consider heterogeneous preferences, potentially linked to location (e.g., a sports fan at a stadium), could offer richer insights.
  • Simplified Utility Function: The utility function currently only includes price. Incorporating other factors like "persuasive advertising" (which adds emotional value) could lead to more complex advertising decisions beyond just coverage rate.
  • Dynamic vs. Discrete Time: The model uses a discrete two-period setting for simplicity. Extending this to a continuous-time framework could provide a more nuanced understanding of dynamic adjustments.

Summary updated

Abstract

The pervasive adoption of mobile devices and proximity technologies enables firms to trace consumers’ trajectories and locations. This connects firms’ marketing and operations strategies more tightly with consumer mobility. In this paper, we propose a novel analytical model to examine the economic effects of consumer mobility on pricing and advertising strategies by incorporating consumers’ Lévy-walking behavior into advertising economics models. We ascertain the convergent effect of consumer mobility, i.e., consumers’ convergence to a firm leads to higher product price and advertising level. Meanwhile, it improves social welfare by increasing firm profit and consumer surplus. More interestingly, we find that consumers’ average movement distance (AMD) has opposing influences in pricing and advertising strategies. Specifically, longer AMD strengthens the convergent effect on advertising strategy but weakens that on pricing strategy. Finally, we also conduct a numerical analysis to uncover the impacts of the presence of proximity technologies on advertising outcomes. The results of this paper provide advisable guidance to firms on how to craft and adjust pricing and advertising strategies in accordance to consumer mobility. Moreover, the results present insights on welfare implications of informative advertising from the perspective of consumer mobility.
BibTeX
@article{wang2021theoretical,
  author = {Wei Wang and Gang Li},
  title = {{A Theoretical Analysis of the Pricing and Advertising Strategies with Lévy-Walking Consumers}},
  journal = {Journal of Theoretical and Applied Electronic Commerce Research},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3390/jtaer16060119},
}
Figure