TL;DR
Researchers have developed the Terpenoids database embedded with Content information (TPCN), the first database to integrate chemical content data for terpenoids. This resource, containing over 6,300 terpenoids from 1,200 plant species, aims to accelerate drug discovery by identifying high-yield plant sources and facilitating the search for drug alternatives with enhanced content.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Natural products are a rich source for drug discovery, with terpenoids being the most abundant class. However, the development of drugs from these compounds is often hindered by their low yield and complex extraction processes. While existing databases catalog terpenoid structures and bioactivities, they largely overlook the crucial aspect of chemical content – how much of a specific compound is present in a plant. This lack of quantitative data makes it difficult to select high-yielding plant species or identify alternative compounds with similar therapeutic effects but better availability. The TPCN database aims to bridge this gap by providing a comprehensive resource that links terpenoid structures with their quantitative content in various plant sources.
Methods
The TPCN database was built through meticulous manual curation of over 10,000 scientific papers published between 1946 and 2022. Data extraction involved identifying terpenoid chemical names, their biological sources (family and species), the plant parts from which they were isolated, and crucially, their quantitative content. Chemical structures were standardized using RDKit, with cross-validation against SciFinder to ensure accuracy.
Beyond data compilation, the researchers implemented several analytical tools:
- Data Distribution Analysis: Terpenoids were categorized by structural type (monoterpenoids, sesquiterpenoids, diterpenoids, triterpenoids), biological source, extraction part, and content ranges (segmented into seven logarithmic bins).
- Similarity Calculation: Molecular fingerprints (Daylight, ECFP4, ECFP6, MACCS) and similarity indices (Tanimoto/Jaccard, Dice, Cosine) were used to assess structural similarity between terpenoids. The Tanimoto coefficient with Daylight fingerprints was the default.
- Murcko Scaffold Analysis: This method identifies the core ring structures of molecules to explore relationships between chemical scaffolds and their content.
- Physicochemical Property Calculation: Eleven key physicochemical properties (e.g., molecular weight, hydrogen bond acceptors/donors, lipophilicity) were calculated using RDKit to investigate their correlation with terpenoid content.
Datasets
The primary dataset for the TPCN database was compiled from a manual search of the Web of Science database, using keywords related to terpenoids. This resulted in the integration of:
- 6,383 unique terpenoids
- 7,508 content records
- 1,254 distinct plant species
- 156 plant families
- 17 different plant extraction parts
No new benchmark datasets were introduced; instead, the paper focuses on curating and organizing existing literature data into a novel, content-focused database.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Content as a Key Agronomic Trait: The paper strongly advocates for considering chemical content as a vital "agronomic trait" for natural products, akin to yield or disease resistance in crops. This perspective shifts the focus from mere presence to abundance, which is critical for practical applications.
- Structural Similarity and Content Variation: A striking finding is the significant variation in content for structurally similar terpenoids. This suggests that even minor structural differences can lead to vastly different accumulation levels in plants, offering opportunities to identify high-yielding "analogs."
- Glycosylation and Content: There's a positive correlation between terpenoid glycosylation levels and their content. This implies that attaching sugar moieties might enhance water solubility and stability, facilitating storage and accumulation within plants.
- Root as a Primary Accumulation Site: The root emerged as the most predominant organ for terpenoid accumulation across various types, highlighting its importance for extraction.
- TPCN as a Drug Discovery Catalyst: The database is positioned not just as a repository but as a tool to actively drive drug discovery by enabling the selection of high-content plant species, identifying alternative drug candidates, and fostering sustainable pharmaceutical farming.
Key Results
- The TPCN database contains 6,383 unique terpenoids with 7,508 content records derived from 1,254 plant species.
- Triterpenoids are the most abundant class (44.74%), followed by diterpenoids (21.17%), sesquiterpenoids (21.09%), and monoterpenoids (13.00%).
- Asteraceae is the most represented plant family, contributing a significant portion of the terpenoids.
- The root is the most common extraction part for terpenoids.
- The majority of terpenoids fall within the 10⁻⁴% to 10⁻³% content range.
- Analysis revealed 6,512 pairs of terpenoids with structural similarity exceeding 99%, and notably, eight pairs exhibited a content variation exceeding 100,000-fold.
- A positive correlation was observed between terpenoid content and glycosylation levels.
Limitations and Future Work
- Manual Curation Limitations: While meticulous, manual data extraction is inherently time-consuming and prone to human error. The authors acknowledge the need for continuous updates and expansion of the database.
- Data Gaps: Despite extensive searching, there are likely still terpenoids and their content data that remain undiscovered or unpublished.
- Environmental Factors: The paper notes that environmental factors significantly influence terpenoid content, but the database primarily focuses on intrinsic genetic and plant-specific variations. Future work could integrate more environmental data.
- Future Directions: The authors suggest that TPCN can be a valuable tool for breeding high-yield germplasm, identifying novel drug alternatives, and advancing our understanding of terpenoid biosynthesis and its regulation. They also highlight the potential for using the database to explore the relationship between chemical content and ecological roles of terpenoids.
Summary updated