A Teaching Model Application in the Course of Information Security

Chunyan Qiu, Wei Zhao, Jianhua Jiang, Jialing HanInternational Journal of Education and Management Engineering 2013 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores how Schema Theory—a psychological framework for how the brain organizes knowledge—can be applied to improve Information Security education. By structuring the curriculum into a four-stage cycle of knowledge collection, teaching, practice, and reorganization, the authors demonstrated a statistically significant boost in both theoretical exam scores and practical lab performance compared to traditional teaching methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Information Security (IS) is a notoriously difficult subject to teach because it is inherently multidisciplinary, requiring a grasp of mathematics, computer science, cryptography, and communication protocols. For students in non-technical majors, such as finance or economics, the barrier to entry is even higher.

The authors argue that traditional teaching often fails because it treats knowledge as a linear list of facts rather than a complex web of interconnected ideas. The challenge is: how do we help students build a robust mental "map" of security concepts that allows them to solve real-world problems rather than just memorizing definitions?

Methods

The authors propose a teaching model based on Schema Theory. In psychology, a "schema" is an internal data structure in the memory that organizes an individual’s experiences. To leverage this, the authors developed a four-stage pedagogical cycle:

  1. Schemata Collection: Before diving into new material, the teacher uses quizzes and discussions to identify the students' existing background knowledge (their current "schemata").
  2. Teaching Process: The instructor introduces new concepts by explicitly linking them to the students' existing knowledge. If new information contradicts a student's previous assumptions, the teacher helps them resolve this "internal conflict" to build a more accurate mental model.
  3. Practice Process: Students engage in lab work to apply theoretical knowledge. This stage is designed to "update" their old schemata through hands-on experience.
  4. Schemata Reorganization: After the lab, students participate in discussions (e.g., "Why are computers not secure?") and write detailed reports. This forces them to reflect on and restructure their mental models, preparing them for the next cycle of learning.

To test this, the authors conducted a controlled experiment with 68 students divided into two groups: a control group (Class y1) using traditional methods and an experimental group (Class y2) using the schema-based model.

Datasets

The "data" in this study consists of the academic performance metrics of 68 undergraduate students majoring in Information Management and Systems at Jilin University of Finance and Economics.

  • Sample Size: Two classes of 34 students each.
  • Metrics: Final examination scores (out of 100) and practical/experiment exam scores (out of 50).
  • Context: The study was conducted during the sixth semester of the degree program.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Learning as "Data Restructuring": The core "aha moment" is viewing the student's brain not as an empty vessel, but as a database with an existing schema. Effective teaching isn't just about "inserting" data; it’s about performing a "schema migration" where old, incomplete structures are reorganized into more complex, accurate ones.
  • The Importance of the "Pre-check": The "Collection" phase is vital. By understanding what students think they know before the lecture starts, teachers can tailor their delivery to bridge specific gaps.
  • Strong Theory-Practice Link: The study found an extremely high Pearson correlation (0.976) between lab performance and exam scores. This suggests that in Information Security, practical "doing" is the primary engine that drives theoretical "understanding."

Key Results

The schema-based model outperformed the traditional model across the board with high statistical significance:

  • Final Exam Performance: The experimental group (y2) achieved a mean score of 80.97, while the control group (y1) averaged 73.85. A t-test confirmed this difference was significant ($p < 0.001$).
  • Practical Exam Performance: The experimental group averaged 40.82 (out of 50), compared to the control group's 38.15. This was also statistically significant ($p < 0.05$).
  • Consistency: The scores in the experimental group followed a normal distribution, suggesting the model helped the majority of students reach a baseline of mastery rather than just benefiting the top performers.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several hurdles in implementing this model:

  • The "Invisible" Schema: It is inherently difficult for a teacher to perfectly "collect" or see a student's internal mental schemata. Misinterpreting a student's starting point can lead to "wrong schemata" being reinforced.
  • Asymmetric Capacities: The authors noted that students' capacities for experiments versus theoretical exams are often asymmetric. Future work needs to focus on how to better balance these two sides of the coin.
  • Scalability: While effective for a class of 34, the paper does not discuss how this high-touch, discussion-heavy model would scale to large lecture halls or MOOCs.

Summary updated

Abstract

With the rapid development of economy, information Security is becoming more and more important for any modern organization in recent years. Therefore, How to teach information security is a challenge to universities. This paper aims to apply schema theory to information security curriculum. The teaching result shows that there is a significant difference in final exam and practice exam between the proposed model and a regular teaching model.
BibTeX
@article{qiu2013teaching,
  author = {Chunyan Qiu and Wei Zhao and Jianhua Jiang and Jialing Han},
  title = {{A Teaching Model Application in the Course of Information Security}},
  journal = {International Journal of Education and Management Engineering},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.5815/ijeme.2013.01.03},
}
Figure