A target-fixed immersed-boundary formulation for rigid bodies interacting with fluid flow

Tzu-Yuan Lin, Hsin-Yu Hsieh, Hsieh-Chen TsaiJournal of Computational Physics 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel immersed boundary (IB) method that significantly improves the accuracy of simulating rigid bodies interacting with fluid flow. By fixing the computational frame of reference to the rigid body of interest, the method achieves more precise surface stress calculations and stable dynamics, even for low solid-to-fluid mass ratios, which are notoriously challenging.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Simulating the complex interplay between rigid bodies and fluid flow (flow-structure interaction, or FSI) is crucial in many engineering applications, from designing aircraft to understanding biological systems. Traditional methods often struggle with accurately capturing the forces exerted by the fluid on the body's surface, especially when dealing with complex geometries or when the body's mass is much smaller than the surrounding fluid. This inaccuracy can lead to unstable simulations and unreliable predictions of the body's motion. Existing immersed boundary methods, while offering computational advantages by avoiding complex mesh redefinitions, often suffer from spurious oscillations in surface stresses, particularly in scenarios with low density ratios. This paper aims to address these limitations by developing a more robust and accurate IB formulation.

Methods

The core innovation of this work lies in adopting a body-fixed frame of reference for the primary immersed body (the "target"). This means the computational grid moves with the body of interest, simplifying the treatment of its boundary. Key techniques employed include:

  • Implicit Coupling: The fluid and rigid body dynamics are coupled implicitly, which enhances numerical stability, especially for low solid-to-fluid mass ratios. This contrasts with "weak coupling" methods that can become unstable.
  • Null-Space Approach: The fluid solver utilizes a null-space approach, building upon the work of Colonius and Taira, to efficiently handle the incompressible flow equations.
  • Added Mass Inclusion: The method explicitly incorporates the "added mass" effect of the fictitious fluid within the rigid body, a known contributor to stability issues in some IB methods. This is based on prior work by Lācis et al.
  • Accurate Stress Filter: A crucial component is the use of an accurate stress filter, introduced by Goza et al., to mitigate spurious oscillations in the computed surface stresses, ensuring physically correct forces and torques.
  • Block-LU Decomposition: The fully discretized algebraic system is solved efficiently and non-iteratively using a block-LU decomposition, a standard technique for speeding up linear system solves.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on validating its method through numerical simulations of well-defined fluid dynamics problems.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Body-Fixed Frame Advantage: Shifting the computational frame to the target body dramatically simplifies the treatment of its boundary and allows for more accurate surface stress calculations by avoiding the need to iterate the body's position.
  • Stability at Low Density Ratios: The combination of implicit coupling, added mass inclusion, and the stress filter is key to achieving stable simulations across a wide range of solid-to-fluid mass ratios, a significant challenge in FSI.
  • Stress Accuracy is Paramount: The paper highlights that spurious oscillations in surface stresses are a major source of error in FSI simulations and demonstrates that a dedicated filtering technique can effectively resolve this.

Key Results

The method was validated using two benchmark problems:

  1. Neutrally Buoyant Cylinder in Planar Couette Flow: The simulations showed good agreement with existing literature for the cylinder's vertical displacement and angular velocity, demonstrating the method's ability to capture complex migration behavior. Temporal and spatial convergence rates were analyzed, showing rates around 1 in L∞ and 1.5-1.6 in L2 norms.
  2. Freely Falling/Rising Circular Cylinder: The method accurately reproduced the vertical and transversal velocities of falling and rising cylinders, showing good agreement with results from finite element and other IB methods. The computed Strouhal number, drag coefficient, and lift coefficient also matched well with previous studies.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations: The paper focuses on 2D simulations. While the method is presented as generalizable to 3D, the current validation is limited to two dimensions. The "grid-locking oscillations" are mentioned as a potential issue in some IB methods, though the authors suggest their target-fixed approach avoids this.
  • Future Work: The authors state that the developed method can be extended to general 3D rigid bodies and efficiently solved using the block-LU decomposition. This suggests that extending the current 2D validation to 3D cases would be a natural next step.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{lin2021target,
  author = {Tzu-Yuan Lin and Hsin-Yu Hsieh and Hsieh-Chen Tsai},
  title = {{A target-fixed immersed-boundary formulation for rigid bodies interacting with fluid flow}},
  journal = {Journal of Computational Physics},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1016/j.jcp.2020.110003},
}
Figure