TL;DR
This paper introduces a three-dimensional framework for systematically managing schedule risks in power grid engineering projects (PGEPs). By integrating personnel, methods, and time dimensions, the framework aims to improve project efficiency and promote sustainable development in the power sector.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Power grid engineering projects (PGEPs) are complex, high-cost endeavors with tight schedules and challenging environments, making them highly susceptible to schedule risks. These risks can lead to project delays, increased costs, and compromised management efficiency, ultimately hindering sustainable development. While general project risk management exists, there's a need for a systematic approach specifically tailored to the unique characteristics of PGEPs, considering organizational structure, construction phases, and workflows. Existing risk management practices in China are often scattered, leading to missed risks and potential losses.
Methods
The authors propose a three-dimensional framework for schedule risk management, encompassing:
- Supervisory Personnel: Defining the roles and responsibilities of various stakeholders (proprietors, designers, contractors, supervisors).
- Construction Process: Dividing the project lifecycle into six stages and identifying 40 key works within these stages.
- Management Methods: Implementing a four-phase risk management cycle: risk identification, analysis, evaluation, and prevention.
For risk analysis, they employ the Interpretative Structure Model (ISM) to understand the interrelationships between identified risks. Risk evaluation is conducted using an Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP)-based system, considering indicators like probability, delay, uncontrollability, risk category, and responsibility party.
Datasets
The study utilized questionnaires and expert interviews with project managers, supervisors, designers, and construction personnel involved in PGEPs. This data was used to identify 222 schedule risks and their attributes. The paper also references existing literature for risk identification and classification.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Interconnectedness of Risks: The ISM analysis reveals that risks are not isolated events. Policy-legal and natural risks, often external, act as foundational drivers that can trigger a cascade of other risks. Conversely, management and environmental risks are more susceptible to external influences.
- Holistic Framework is Crucial: A systematic, three-dimensional approach that considers people, processes, and methods is essential for effective schedule risk management in PGEPs, moving beyond scattered, ad-hoc practices.
- Risk Drivers in Feasibility Stage: In the feasibility study stage, risks related to obtaining professional assessment reports and agreements, along with unclear infrastructure information and power planning changes, pose the greatest hazards.
- Responsibility Matters in Evaluation: Beyond traditional risk factors, the authors highlight the importance of considering the risk category and the responsible party in risk evaluation, as the impact can vary significantly depending on who bears the responsibility.
Key Results
The study identified 222 schedule risks across the entire PGEP process. The ISM analysis provided a multilevel structure of these risks, illustrating their interdependencies. The AHP-based risk evaluation system was established, and the authors demonstrated its application through a case study of the feasibility study stage. The results indicated that risks related to obtaining departmental reports and agreements were the most significant hazards during this stage. The proposed framework was found to be meaningful for improving project management efficiency by enabling managers to better understand risk severity, responsibilities, and take proactive actions.
Limitations and Future Work
The paper acknowledges that the risk impact value is partly dependent on the inherent attributes of risks as determined by ISM analysis. While the framework is verified through the feasibility study stage, further application and validation across other stages of PGEPs would strengthen its practical utility. The authors suggest that this framework can provide valuable inspiration and reference for participants in PGEPs, implying potential for broader adoption and refinement.
Summary updated