A Systematic Nomenclature for the Drosophila Ventral Nervous System

Robert Court, Shigehiro Namiki, J. Douglas Armstrong, Jana Börner, Gwyneth M Card, Marta Costa, Michael H. Dickinson, Carsten Duch, Wyatt Korff, Richard S. Mann, David J. Merritt, Rod K Murphey, Andrew M. Seeds, Troy R. Shirangi, J. Simpson, James W. Truman, John C Tuthill, Darren W. Williams, D.p. ShepherdbioRxiv 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a standardized naming system for the Drosophila ventral nervous system (VNS), building upon previous work on the brain. This comprehensive nomenclature provides a much-needed common language for describing the VNS's complex anatomy, facilitating data sharing and accelerating neuroscience research in this crucial model organism.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The fruit fly, Drosophila melanogaster, is a powerhouse in neuroscience research due to its genetic tractability and well-characterized nervous system. However, until recently, a significant hurdle in studying the Drosophila brain was the lack of a unified and systematic nomenclature. While a comprehensive system for the brain was established, the ventral nervous system (VNS) – responsible for motor control and essential behaviors like walking, flying, and courtship – remained a patchwork of inconsistent terminology. This ambiguity made it difficult to integrate findings from different labs, compare datasets, and build a cohesive understanding of VNS circuitry. This paper aims to resolve this by extending the established brain nomenclature to the VNS, providing a systematic anatomical description.

Methods

The development of this nomenclature followed a collaborative approach, mirroring the process used for the Drosophila brain. A working group, the Drosophila Anatomy of the Ventral nervous system Working Group (DAVWG), was formed, bringing together experts in VNS anatomy, development, and physiology. They convened a workshop to systematically review existing literature and anatomical data, including images and the existing Drosophila anatomy ontology.

Key to establishing the anatomical framework was the use of advanced imaging techniques and molecular markers. Confocal microscopy datasets were generated using antibodies against neuroglian (to visualize axon tracts and define neuromere boundaries), N-cadherin (to highlight synapse-rich neuropil regions), and alpha-tubulin (to reveal longitudinal tracts and commissures). These techniques allowed for the precise definition of structures and their boundaries, forming the basis for the new nomenclature. The naming scheme itself prioritized integrating existing terminology where possible, making changes only to resolve ambiguity and relying primarily on morphological features.

Datasets

The study utilized existing anatomical datasets and generated new ones through confocal microscopy. Specifically, they used:

  • Confocal datasets: Generated using antibodies for neuroglian, N-cadherin, and alpha-tubulin to visualize axon tracts, neuropil structures, and longitudinal tracts/commissures.
  • Published literature and existing Drosophila anatomy ontology: These served as the foundation for identifying named regions and their descriptions.
  • Representative anatomical images: Assembled by the authors to aid in the systematic review process.

The generated image data is made available on the Virtual Fly Brain platform.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bridging the nomenclature gap: The primary insight is the successful extension of a systematic nomenclature to the Drosophila VNS, creating a much-needed common language for researchers.
  • Developmental origin as an organizational principle: Neuronal hemilineages, derived from neuroblast divisions, provide a consistent organizational principle for defining neuropil substructure, as neurons within a hemilineage often share properties.
  • Neuroglian as a key marker for neuromere boundaries: Axon bundles revealed by neuroglian expression serve as reliable anatomical markers to define the boundaries of the major neuromeres (ProNm, MesoNm, MetaNm, ANm).
  • Distinguishing neuropil types: N-cadherin and nc82 staining effectively differentiate between synapse-poor (axons, primary neurites) and synapse-rich (sensory neuropils) regions.
  • Harmonizing terminology: The nomenclature aims to integrate existing terms, making changes only when necessary to remove ambiguity, thus preserving historical context while improving clarity.
  • Evolutionary conservation as a future direction: The paper highlights the potential for this nomenclature to serve as a template for comparative studies across different insect species, exploring the deep evolutionary conservation of VNS structures.

Key Results

The paper successfully established a comprehensive and systematic nomenclature for the adult Drosophila ventral nervous system. This includes:

  • Defined neuromere boundaries: The prothoracic (ProNm), mesothoracic (MesoNm), and metathoracic (MetaNm) neuromeres, as well as the abdominal neuromeres (ANm), are clearly delineated.
  • Identified major neuropil regions: Key neuropils such as the accessory mesothoracic neuropil (AMNp), tectulum (with proposed subdivisions: Central Association Center, Intermediate Tectulum, Upper Tectulum), and leg neuropils (Ventral Association Center (VAC), medial Ventral Association Center (mVAC), intermediate neuropil (IntNp)) are named and described.
  • Cataloged commissures and tracts: The nomenclature includes detailed descriptions and naming conventions for numerous commissures (e.g., aaV, paV, al, val, dal, apl, ppl, pD) and longitudinal tracts (e.g., DLT, ITD, HT, DMT, DLV, VTV, MDT).
  • Provided a foundation for future research: The established nomenclature serves as a robust framework for integrating existing and future data, promoting consistency in anatomical descriptions and facilitating cross-laboratory communication.

Limitations and Future Work

  • "Living" nomenclature: The authors acknowledge that the nomenclature is an initial standard and must be maintained as a "living" process, evolving as understanding of the VNS grows. Future revisions and additions will be handled through online systems.
  • Cross-species applicability: While the nomenclature is designed for Drosophila, the paper suggests it can serve as a template for adapting to other insect model organisms. However, confirming homology across species will require further work to establish a truly consistent cross-species terminology.
  • Diversity of insect VNS: The paper notes the significant diversity in VNS organization across insects, which can lead to superficial differences despite underlying conserved patterns of tracts and commissures. This highlights the need for careful comparative studies.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract The fruit fly, Drosophila melanogaster , is an established and powerful model system for neuroscience research with wide relevance in biology and medicine. Until recently, research on the Drosophila brain was hindered by the lack of a complete and uniform nomenclature. Recognising this problem, the Insect Brain Name Working Group produced an authoritative hierarchical nomenclature system for the adult insect brain, using Drosophila melanogaster as the reference framework, with other taxa considered to ensure greater consistency and expandability (Ito et al., 2014). Here, we extend this nomenclature system to the sub-gnathal regions of the adult Drosophila nervous system, thus providing a systematic anatomical description of the ventral nervous system (VNS). This portion of the nervous system includes the thoracic and abdominal neuromeres that were not included in the original work and contains the motor circuits that play essential roles in most fly behaviours.
BibTeX
@misc{court2017systematic,
  author = {Robert Court and Shigehiro Namiki and J. Douglas Armstrong and Jana Börner and Gwyneth M Card and Marta Costa and Michael H. Dickinson and Carsten Duch and Wyatt Korff and Richard S. Mann and David J. Merritt and Rod K Murphey and Andrew M. Seeds and Troy R. Shirangi and J. Simpson and James W. Truman and John C Tuthill and Darren W. Williams and D.P. Shepherd},
  title = {{A Systematic Nomenclature for the <i>Drosophila</i> Ventral Nervous System}},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1101/122952},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}

Loading related content...

Figure