A Systematic Literature Review of Fashion, Sustainability, and Consumption Using a Mixed Methods Approach

Osmud Rahman, Dingtao Hu, Benjamin C. M. FungSustainability 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper systematically reviews the burgeoning field of "fashion sustainability" from 2010-2021, using text mining and bibliometric analysis to map research trends, key themes, and geographical distribution. It highlights a significant increase in publications, a focus on non-sustainable cues over sustainable ones, and a strong emphasis on female consumers, suggesting critical gaps for future research.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The fashion industry's environmental impact is a growing concern, leading to a surge in research on "fashion sustainability." However, this research is often fragmented, with varying objectives and approaches, making it difficult to grasp the overall landscape. This paper addresses this by conducting a comprehensive, mixed-methods systematic literature review to identify key research themes, trends, and developmental patterns, aiming to provide a clearer understanding of the complex interplay between fashion, sustainability, and consumption.

Methods

The authors employed a mixed-methods approach combining systematic literature review with text mining and bibliometric visualization tools.

  • Systematic Literature Review: Followed PRISMA guidelines, involving identification, screening, eligibility, and inclusion phases.
  • Text Mining: Utilized RAKE (Rapid Automatic Keyword Extraction) to identify keywords from paper titles, author keywords, and abstracts.
  • Bibliometric Analysis: Employed VOSviewer and CitNetExplorer for visualization and analysis of:
  • Keyword co-occurrence
    • Co-authorship networks (academic organizations)
    • Co-citation analysis (key publications)
    • Chronological citation charts (development trends)
  • Content Analysis: Used for data classification and interpretation, with two independent coders to ensure reliability.

Datasets

The primary dataset for this study consisted of academic articles related to "fashion and sustainability" published between 2010 and 2021, retrieved from the Web of Science (WoS) database.

  • Initial Search: Identified 4,971 papers.
  • Stage 1 Screening: Narrowed down to 860 relevant articles.
  • Stage 2 Screening: Further refined to 280 articles based on keywords like "consumer," "shopper," and "customer."

No new datasets were introduced; the study focused on analyzing existing literature.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Explosion of Research: The field of "fashion sustainability" has seen a dramatic increase in publications, with a nearly 28% jump from 2020 to 2021 alone, indicating sustained academic interest.
  • Dominance of Non-Sustainable Cues: Surprisingly, research tends to focus more on non-sustainable product cues (like style, price, quality, fabric) than on explicitly sustainable ones (like recycled materials, eco-labels). This suggests a gap in understanding how consumers perceive and value sustainable attributes.
  • Female Consumer Focus: The vast majority of studies concentrate on female consumers, reflecting a potential under-exploration of male consumers' attitudes and behaviors towards sustainable fashion.
  • Geographic Imbalance: While North America and Europe lead in research output, Asia (despite its large consumer base) and Africa remain significantly under-researched in cross-national studies.
  • Fast Fashion Dominance in Case Studies: H&M, Zara, and Gap Inc. are the most frequently studied companies, highlighting a focus on large Western fast-fashion brands and potentially overlooking the role of SMEs.
  • Interdisciplinary Nature: Research in this area is increasingly interdisciplinary, appearing in journals beyond fashion and sustainability, suggesting a growing recognition of fashion's broader societal and environmental implications.

Key Results

  • Publication Trends: A significant upward trend in publications from 2010 to 2021, with a notable surge after 2013.
  • Top Journals: Sustainability, Journal of Fashion Marketing and Management, and Journal of Cleaner Production published the highest number of relevant papers.
  • Product Cues: Style (71 occurrences), price (63), quality (58), and fabric (56) were the most frequently studied non-sustainable cues. For sustainable cues, energy usage (47), water usage (41), and certified labels (41) were prominent.
  • Research Approaches: Quantitative methods were most common (346 papers), followed by qualitative (228) and mixed methods (27). Case studies (93) and systematic literature reviews (34) were the dominant paper types.
  • Geographic Distribution: United States (254 studies) and United Kingdom (90) led in research output. Europe (328) and North America (262) were the most researched regions.
  • Gender Focus: 217 papers focused more on females, with 81 exclusively on females, indicating a strong gender bias in the research.
  • Cross-National Studies: 79 cross-national studies were identified, with the US, China, and South Korea being frequently investigated.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Timeframe Limitation: The study's focus on 2010-2021 limits understanding of longer-term research evolution. Future research could expand this timeframe.
  • Product Scope: The study exclusively focused on apparel. Future work could explore sustainable consumption in other product categories (e.g., electric vehicles, electronics).
  • Practitioner Perspective: The study did not explore the perspectives of fashion practitioners (designers, manufacturers, retailers). Future research should investigate how these stakeholders use product cues in their decision-making.
  • Under-Researched Regions: Middle Eastern, South American, and African regions, as well as male consumers and other gender identities, are under-researched and require further investigation.
  • Focus on SMEs: While large corporations are studied, more research is needed on the role and challenges of Small and Medium Enterprises (SMEs) in sustainable fashion.

Summary updated

Abstract

With the growing global awareness of the environmental impact of clothing consumption, there has been a notable surge in the publication of journal articles dedicated to “fashion sustainability” in the past decade, specifically from 2010 to 2020. However, despite this wealth of research, many studies remain disconnected and fragmented due to varying research objectives, focuses, and approaches. Conducting a systematic literature review with a mixed methods research approach can help identify key research themes, trends, and developmental patterns, while also shedding light on the complexity of fashion, sustainability, and consumption. To enhance the literature review and analytical process, the current systematic literature review employed text mining techniques and bibliometric visualization tools, including RAKE, VOSviewer, and CitNetExplorer. The findings revealed an increase in the number of publications focusing on “fashion and sustainability” between 2010 and 2021. Most studies were predominantly conducted in the United States, with a specific focus on female consumers. Moreover, a greater emphasis was placed on non-sustainable cues rather than the sustainable cues. Additionally, a higher number of case studies was undertaken to investigate three fast-fashion companies. To enhance our knowledge and understanding of this subject, this article highlights several valuable contributions and provides recommendations for future research.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{rahman2023systematic,
  author = {Osmud Rahman and Dingtao Hu and Benjamin C. M. Fung},
  title = {{A Systematic Literature Review of Fashion, Sustainability, and Consumption Using a Mixed Methods Approach}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/su151612213},
}
Figure