A Study on the process for Managing the Reliability of Conceptual cost estimates in Building Projects

Sung-Hoon An, Dae‐Won Kim, U-Yeol ParkJournal of the Korea Institute of Building Construction 2010 · DOI

Abstract

Conceptual cost is estimated with insufficient information at an early stage of a building construction project, resulting in an inevitable gap between conceptual estimated cost and real constructed cost. For a project to be successful, this gap must be managed to be lower than a reliable level. Therefore, the purpose of this study is to propose a structural process for managing the reliability of conceptual cost estimates at an early stage of a building construction project. In researching this study, conceptual cost estimate experts were interviewed, and a risk management process was studied. Reliability assessment and a review process for improving the quality of conceptual cost estimate and the planning strategy of reliability management based on previous similar projects were added to the present estimate process. The proposed reliability management process will improve the chances of a successful project, by helping to decrease the risk of conceptual estimated cost.

Introduction

In the early stages of building projects, stakeholders rely on conceptual cost estimates to make critical financial and strategic decisions. However, because many project details—such as specific material choices or site conditions—are not yet finalized, these estimates are notoriously prone to inaccuracy. This research addresses the gap between conceptual estimates and actual construction costs by proposing a systematic "Reliability Management Process."

Conceptualizing reliability as an acceptable error range around actual costs

The study defines reliability not as a single perfect figure, but as the probability that the final cost will fall within a predefined, acceptable "error range." The goal is to move beyond simple calculation and create a framework that keeps cost deviations within a predictable threshold.

Methodology

The researchers developed the proposed process through a multi-step qualitative approach:

  1. Literature Review: Analysis of existing estimation standards (AACE) and risk management frameworks (IPRA).
  2. Expert Interviews: Qualitative insights from industry professionals to identify real-world pain points.
  3. Process Integration: Synthesizing findings to insert a "Reliability Assessment" loop and a "Reliability Management Strategy" phase into standard workflows.
  4. Case-Based Strategy: Using "Key-points"—critical risk factors identified from similar past projects—to monitor and mitigate potential cost overruns.

The Proposed Reliability Management Process

The primary result of this study is the Conceptual Cost Estimate Reliability Management Process. Unlike traditional linear processes, this model introduces a formal feedback loop and strategic risk tracking.

The proposed Conceptual Cost Estimate Reliability Management Process

Key Components of the Process:

  • Reliability Assessment Step: A formal check to determine if the estimate meets the "acceptable risk level." If reliability is deemed too low, the estimator must identify the factors causing uncertainty and improve the estimate before proceeding.
  • Improvement Measures: When reliability is low, the process mandates identifying "weighted" factors that are degrading the estimate's quality.
  • Management Strategy Table: A living document that tracks the probability and cost impact of specific risks (e.g., insufficient soil investigation or regulatory changes) and assigns specific response plans and cost buffers to them.
  • Benchmarking: A core pillar involves selecting a "most similar project" from historical databases to act as a benchmark for identifying hidden risks that might not be obvious in early documentation.

Conclusion and Future Work

This study provides a structured framework for managing the inherent uncertainty in early-stage construction costs. By integrating reliability assessments and historical project data, stakeholders can significantly reduce financial risk.

However, the authors acknowledge limitations: the framework currently lacks specific automated algorithms for calculating reliability scores, and the assessment of risk probability still relies heavily on expert judgment. Future research should focus on developing computerized systems to store and retrieve historical "Key-points" and creating more objective, data-driven tools for populating management strategy tables.

Summary updated

Abstract

건축 프로젝트에서 개산견적은 많은 부분들이 확정되지 않은 상태에서 수행되기 때문에 개산견적으로 산출된 공사비와 실제 시공 공사비는 차이가 발생할 수밖에 없다. 이러한 공사비의 차이를 신뢰할 수 있는 수준 이하로 관리할 필요가 있다. 따라서 본 연구에서는 건축 프로젝트 초기단계에서 실시하는 개산견적의 신뢰도를 관리할 수 있는 체계적인 프로세스를 구축하는 것을 목적으로 한다. 본 연구를 수행하기 위하여 개산견적 전문가와 면담조사를 실시하였으며, 리스크 관리 프로세스에 대한 고찰도 실시하였다. 연구결과 개산견적 신뢰도 관리를 위해서는 기존의 개산견적 프로세스에 신뢰도를 평가와 향상 방안 도출 과정이 필요하며, 유사 프로젝트를 토대로 신뢰도 관리 전략 수립 과정이 필요하다. 이러한 과정을 통해서 개산견적의 신뢰도를 당초에 설정된 허용가능한 수준 이하로 관리하여 프로젝트 공사비에 대한 리스크를 감소시켜 프로젝트를 성공적으로 수행할 수 있게 도움을 줄 수있다. Conceptual cost is estimated with insufficient information at an early stage of a building construction project, resulting in an inevitable gap between conceptual estimated cost and real constructed cost. For a project to be successful, this gap must be managed to be lower than a reliable level. Therefore, the purpose of this study is to propose a structural process for managing the reliability of conceptual cost estimates at an early stage of a building construction project. In researching this study, conceptual cost estimate experts were interviewed,and a risk management process was studied. Reliability assessment and a review process for improving the quality of conceptual cost estimate and the planning strategy of reliability management based on previous similar projects were added to the present estimate process. The proposed reliability management process will improve the chances of a successful project, by helping to decrease the risk of conceptual estimated cost.
BibTeX
@article{an2010study,
  author = {Sung-Hoon An and Dae‐Won Kim and U-Yeol Park},
  title = {{A Study on the process for Managing the Reliability of Conceptual cost estimates in Building Projects}},
  journal = {Journal of the Korea Institute of Building Construction},
  year = {2010},
  doi = {10.5345/jkic.2010.10.2.133},
}
Figure