A Study on the Korean ETF Market : Systemic Risk and the Optimal ETF Introduction Sequence

Beomhyeon Kim, Yongjae Lee, Do-Gyun Kwon, Woo Chang KimJournal of Korean Institute of Industrial Engineers 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the systemic risk of the Korean ETF market compared to the U.S. market, finding that Korea's market is significantly more vulnerable due to a lack of diversity. It then proposes an optimal introduction sequence of U.S. ETFs into Korea to enhance market efficiency and reduce risk, suggesting that introducing corporate bonds, communications, and short-term government bonds would be most impactful.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The rise of robo-advisors, driven by FinTech, is democratizing wealth management, making it accessible to a broader population. Robo-advisors heavily rely on Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs) for portfolio construction due to their low costs and efficiency. For robo-advisors to thrive in Korea, the Korean ETF market needs to mature in both quantity and quality. This paper addresses two key issues: first, the vulnerability of the Korean ETF market to systemic risks compared to the more developed U.S. market, and second, how to strategically introduce new ETFs to improve the Korean market's efficiency and resilience.

Methods

The study employs two primary analytical approaches:

  • Systemic Risk Analysis: Principal Component Analysis (PCA) is used to measure systemic risk. Specifically, the "Absorption Ratio" is calculated, which quantifies how much of an asset market's return movements can be explained by a few principal components. A higher absorption ratio indicates greater interdependence among assets and thus higher systemic risk. To handle the large number of U.S. ETFs, k-means clustering was used to group similar ETFs before applying PCA.
  • Optimal ETF Introduction Sequence: Modern Portfolio Theory, specifically maximizing the Sharpe Ratio, is used to determine the optimal sequence for introducing U.S. ETFs into the Korean market. The Sharpe Ratio measures risk-adjusted returns. The study iteratively adds U.S. ETF categories to the Korean market and observes the impact on the maximum achievable Sharpe Ratio, identifying categories that provide the greatest improvement.

Datasets

  • ETF Return Data: Daily return data for ETFs in both the Korean and U.S. markets were collected from Thomson Reuters Datastream.
  • Time Period: The analysis for systemic risk spanned from 2008 to 2015, while the Sharpe Ratio maximization analysis focused on a more recent period from January 2015 to June 2016.
  • U.S. ETF Classification: U.S. ETFs were classified into various categories (e.g., Bond/Fixed Income, Commodity, Equity, Volatility) based on their underlying assets, drawing from ETFDB.com classifications.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Korean ETF Market's Vulnerability: The Korean ETF market exhibits significantly higher systemic risk than the U.S. market. This is attributed to a lack of diversity in underlying assets, leading to a higher degree of correlation among existing ETFs.
  • Robo-Advisors' Dependence on ETF Market Quality: The success of robo-advisors in Korea is directly tied to the maturity and efficiency of its ETF market. A less risky and more diverse ETF landscape is crucial for providing robust automated investment services.
  • Strategic ETF Introduction is Key: Simply increasing the number of ETFs isn't enough; introducing ETFs with diverse underlying assets that are currently underrepresented in Korea is essential for improving market efficiency and reducing systemic risk.
  • The Power of Diversification: The study highlights that even a few well-chosen U.S. ETF categories can dramatically improve the risk-adjusted returns (Sharpe Ratio) of the Korean market.

Key Results

  • Systemic Risk: The absorption ratio for the Korean ETF market was consistently higher than that of the U.S. market across all analyzed years (2008-2015), indicating greater systemic risk. For instance, in 2015, the difference in absorption ratio was still significant. Furthermore, the minimum number of principal components required to explain a certain level of market movement (0.8 and 0.9 absorption ratios) was considerably lower for the Korean market, reinforcing its higher vulnerability.
  • Optimal Introduction Sequence: The study identified a sequence of U.S. ETF categories that would most effectively enhance the Korean ETF market's Sharpe Ratio:
  • Corporate Bonds (U.S.): This category showed the largest increase in Sharpe Ratio, jumping from 0.131 to 0.7211.
  • Communications (U.S. Equity): Further increased the Sharpe Ratio to 0.9355.
  • Government Bonds (Short-term, U.S.): Raised the Sharpe Ratio to 1.0364.
  • Commodity Producers (U.S. Equity)

    1. Consumer Staples (U.S. Equity)
    2. Volatility (VIX) Introducing all these categories would bring the Korean market's Sharpe Ratio close to that of the U.S. market.
  • Efficient Frontier Expansion: The introduction of these key ETF categories significantly expands the efficient frontier of the Korean ETF market, offering investors better risk-return trade-offs. Even ETFs that didn't dramatically boost the Sharpe Ratio still contributed to reducing risk for a given level of return.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Investor Demand: The study's recommendations are based purely on quantitative efficiency metrics. The authors acknowledge that actual ETF introduction should also consider investor demand and practical implementation challenges.
  • Short-Term Focus: The analysis for the optimal introduction sequence used a relatively short time frame (January 2015 - June 2016). While this captures recent market conditions, longer-term data might reveal different optimal sequences.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that financial authorities and ETF providers should consider these findings for long-term strategic planning, focusing on diversifying the ETF market to support the growth of robo-advisors. Further research could explore the impact of specific investor preferences and the practicalities of introducing these new ETF categories.

Summary updated

Abstract

Traditionally, the private wealth management industry has been dedicated to high-net-worth individuals due to expensive service costs. However, robo-advisors are making sudden rises during the on-going FinTech revolution. Robo-advisors aim to provide personalized wealth management services for everyone by using automated investment management algorithms and online distribution channels. To reduce service costs, robo-advisors mainly use ETFs to construct investment portfolios. Therefore, Korean ETF market should grow in both quantity and quality, in order for robo-advisors to succeed in Korea. In this study, we first analyze how vulnerable the Korean ETF market is to external or internal shocks in comparison with the U.S. ETF market. Then, we derive the optimal introduction sequence of ETFs in the Korean ETF market based on the modern portfolio theory.
BibTeX
@article{kim2017study,
  author = {Beomhyeon Kim and Yongjae Lee and Do-Gyun Kwon and Woo Chang Kim},
  title = {{A Study on the Korean ETF Market : Systemic Risk and the Optimal ETF Introduction Sequence}},
  journal = {Journal of Korean Institute of Industrial Engineers},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.7232/jkiie.2017.43.6.482},
}
Figure