A Study on the Influence of the Income Structure on the Consumption Structure of Rural Residents in China

Yan Lü, Yuqi Zhou, Pengling Liu, Shiyun ZhangSustainability 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how the structure of income (different sources like wages, property, etc.) influences the spending patterns of rural Chinese residents. It finds that distinct income sources have varying impacts on consumption, aligning with the "mental accounting" hypothesis, and predicts shifts in future spending towards healthcare and housing.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

China's economic growth has slowed, making domestic consumption a crucial driver. Rural consumption, in particular, holds significant untapped potential. However, understanding how different types of income affect how rural residents spend their money is key to unlocking this potential and fostering sustainable economic development. This paper addresses the question of how the structure of rural residents' income (i.e., the proportion of income from wages, operations, property, and transfers) influences their consumption patterns and structure.

Methods

The study employs an improved Extended Linear Expenditure System (ELES) model. The standard ELES model, originally developed by Stone and later extended by Lluch, is adapted to incorporate the "mental accounting" hypothesis. This hypothesis, proposed by Richard Thaler, suggests that individuals treat money from different sources differently, leading to varied spending behaviors. The improved model breaks down disposable income into four categories: wage income, net operating income, net property income, and net transfer income. This allows for a more nuanced analysis of how each income source impacts the consumption of eight different expenditure categories (e.g., food, housing, healthcare). The model uses time-series data from 2000-2020 for its analysis.

Datasets

The study utilizes time-series data on disposable income and consumption expenditures of Chinese rural residents from 2000 to 2020. The data are sourced from the China Statistical Yearbook (2001–2021). Disposable income is broken down into four types: wage income, net operating income, net property income, and net transfer income. Consumption is categorized into eight types: food, tobacco, and alcohol; clothing; housing; daily necessities and services; transportation and communication; education, culture, and entertainment; medical care; and other supplies and services.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • "Mental Accounting" in Action: The study strongly supports the "mental accounting" hypothesis. Rural residents don't treat all income equally; money earned through hard work (wages, operating income) is spent more cautiously, while "easier" money (property income, transfers) is spent more readily. This explains why different income sources have distinct marginal propensities to consume (MPC).
  • Disparate MPCs: While net property and net transfer income constitute a smaller portion of total income, they have a relatively high MPC. Conversely, wage and net operating income, which form the bulk of disposable income, have a lower MPC. This suggests that even small increases in property and transfer income can have a disproportionately larger impact on consumption.
  • Shifting Consumption Priorities: The future consumption landscape for rural residents is predicted to change. Spending on food, tobacco, and alcohol is expected to slow down, while expenditures on healthcare, transportation, communication, and housing will likely increase, forming a larger share of their total spending.

Key Results

  • Model Fit: The improved ELES model demonstrated an excellent fit to the data, with an R² value above 0.99 and a significant F-test, indicating that the model effectively explains the observed consumption patterns.
  • Income Source Impact:
    • Wage Income: Positively correlated with most consumption categories (clothing, housing, daily necessities, transport, education, medical care, other services) but negatively with food, tobacco, and alcohol.
  • Net Operating Income: Positively correlated with food, tobacco, and alcohol, clothing, housing, and daily necessities, but negatively with transportation, medical care, education, and other services.
  • Net Property Income: Positively correlated with food, tobacco, and alcohol, and medical care, but negatively with most other categories. Its impact on consumption is limited due to its small proportion.
  • Net Transfer Income: Positively correlated with food, tobacco, and alcohol, housing, transportation, education, and medical care. It primarily supports basic living and medical needs, with a limited role in stimulating broader consumption.
  • Significant Coefficients: Notably, wage income significantly negatively affects food, tobacco, and alcohol consumption. Net operating income and net property income significantly positively impact food, tobacco, and alcohol consumption.

Limitations and Future Work

  • ELES Model Suitability: The paper acknowledges that some scholars have questioned the suitability of the ELES model for analyzing Chinese consumption cross-sectional data, suggesting it should be used with caution. This study attempts to mitigate this by using time-series data and an improved model.
  • Policy Focus: The study's findings are directly translated into policy recommendations. Future work could explore the effectiveness of these proposed policies in practice.
  • Data Granularity: While the study breaks down income and consumption, further granularity in data (e.g., more specific sub-categories of income or expenditure) could yield even deeper insights.
  • External Factors: While the model accounts for some random disturbances, a more explicit modeling of external economic and policy factors could enhance predictive power.

Summary updated

Abstract

The gentle development of the economy is an important link to realize sustainable development in a holistic way. In recent years, due to the notable decline in the scale of exports and investment, China’s economic growth has decreased significantly, and consumption has become the main force driving economic growth. Promoting sustainable economic development is an important problem in the current development of China. In this study, the ELES model was adopted to analyze how the consumption structure is affected by the income structure among rural residents in China. The results show the following: (1) The income structure of rural residents has a significant impact on the consumption structure, and their consumption behaviors conform to the “mental accounting” hypothesis. (2) Net property income and net transfer income account for a small proportion, but marginal propensity to consume (referred to as MPC) is relatively large. Net operating income and wage income form a large proportion of disposable income with low MPC. (3) In the future, expenditures on food, tobacco, and alcohol will slow down remarkably, and more money will be spent on healthcare, transportation and communication, and housing, forming an increasing proportion of expenditures. In summary, this study suggests that scientific and effective policy measures should be issued to boost the income level of rural residents in a targeted manner, optimize the income structure, and improve the rural consumption environment, so as to comprehensively promote rural consumption.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lu2022study,
  author = {Yan Lü and Yuqi Zhou and Pengling Liu and Shiyun Zhang},
  title = {{A Study on the Influence of the Income Structure on the Consumption Structure of Rural Residents in China}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/su141610380},
}
Figure