A Study on the Influence of Personal Characteristics of Youth Employment on the Preparation for Turnover: Focused on the adjustment effect of experience in failing to get jobs

Jong-Jin Kim, Kyung-Ho UmJournal of Industrial Distribution & Business 2020 · DOI

Abstract

This study investigates the drivers of turnover preparation among young workers in South Korea, moving beyond simple economic motivations to explore internal job satisfaction and professional identity. By analyzing longitudinal data, the research identifies how personal characteristics and job-related factors—such as business type, employment status, debt, and skill mismatch—influence the intent to leave. The study also examines the moderating effect of past job-seeking failures. Results indicate that turnover is often a developmental process aimed at increasing internal satisfaction and finding a better fit between a worker's skills and their daily tasks, rather than just a search for higher pay.

Introduction

Youth unemployment is a persistent social issue in South Korea, yet even those who secure employment often leave quickly; the average tenure for a first job is just 14.8 months. Traditional "eye-point theory" suggests workers move primarily for better wages or status. However, this study argues that turnover preparation is more qualitative, driven by a quest for professional identity and a match between education and daily work. Crucially, it explores the "scarring effect" of past job-seeking failures on current workplace behavior.

Methodology

The researchers utilized the Youth Panel Survey (YP2007), a longitudinal dataset spanning 2007 to 2018. The sample included 4,230 individuals aged 15 to 34 who were currently employed. A Hierarchical Regression approach was used to analyze the data:

  • Model 1: Focused on demographic and sociological control variables (age, education, marital status, religion).
  • Model 2: Introduced job-related variables, including employment type (regular vs. non-regular), job satisfaction, and mismatch variables (difficulty relative to education/technology levels).

Key Results

The inclusion of job-related factors significantly enhanced the model's explanatory power. As shown in Figure 1, the variance explained (R²) increased from 15.5% in Model 1 to 21.2% in Model 2 ($p < .01$).

Model Fit Statistics for Turnover Preparation Models

Detailed regression analysis (Figure 2) identified several critical predictors of turnover preparation. Job satisfaction was the strongest negative predictor ($t = 9.583$), confirming that internal fulfillment is the primary deterrent to leaving. Conversely, debt status ($t = 6.326$) and higher education levels ($t = -4.045$) were significant positive predictors, suggesting that financial pressure and high expectations drive the search for better-optimized roles.

Regression Coefficients for Demographic and Job-Related Factors

Skill mismatches also played a major role. When job difficulty was perceived as mismatched with education level ($t = 3.335$) or technology level ($t = 2.831$), the likelihood of preparing for turnover increased significantly.

Discussion and Conclusion

For young people, a job is a developmental milestone representing their identity. Turnover is often a "voluntary job search process" to find a role that matches their training and internal needs. The study also found that the "experience of failing to get jobs" acts as a significant psychological moderator, altering how factors like employment type and job satisfaction influence the decision to leave.

Ultimately, the study concludes that turnover should be approached from a life-cycle perspective. Policy should focus not just on job quantity, but on the quality and alignment of roles to ensure long-term satisfaction and professional development for the youth workforce.

Summary updated

Abstract

Purpose: In this study, we would like to confirm that the transfer of young workers may be a means of enhancing their internal satisfaction, not to get a better job, by setting work-related characteristics that are highly relevant to job-related factors. Research design, data, and methodology: In this study, preparation for turnover was set as dependent variables to identify factors related to the turnover of young people, and the type of business, employment type, debt status, job satisfaction, job difficulty compared to education level, job difficulty, job degree, job major agreement, debt status, and other demographic social characteristics were selected as independent variables. Results: The characteristics related to personal criteria in job-seeking process were significant in the form of business, employment type, job satisfaction, work difficulty compared to the level of education, work difficulty compared to the level of technology, job major matching, and debt status. Conclusions: This study confirmed that young people's turnover may not simply be a means to get a better job, but to increase satisfaction in the internal aspects of their jobs, and that for young people, a job is an important development process that represents their identity and needs to be approached from a life-cycle perspective.
BibTeX
@article{kim2020study,
  author = {Jong-Jin Kim and Kyung-Ho UM and Kyung-Ho UM},
  title = {{A Study on the Influence of Personal Characteristics of Youth Employment on the Preparation for Turnover: Focused on the adjustment effect of experience in failing to get jobs}},
  journal = {Journal of Industrial Distribution \& Business},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.13106/jidb.2020.vol11.no7.19},
}
Figure