Abstract
Against the backdrop of the global green transition and China's dual carbon strategy, the governance role of institutional investors has become increasingly prominent. Existing research predominantly focuses on their shareholding ratios while overlooking the impact of specific environmental governance behaviours. Drawing upon agency theory, resource dependence, and the attention-based perspective, this study constructs an ‘institutional investor green attention’ indicator using Shanghai and Shenzhen A-share companies from 2012 to 2023 as its sample. It empirically examines the influence mechanism of this indicator on ESG ratings. Results indicate that green attention conveyed through site research by institutional investors significantly elevates corporate ESG ratings, with findings holding up under multiple robustness tests. Mechanism analysis reveals that green attention indirectly drives ESG performance by enhancing ‘management environmental awareness,’ forming a transmission pathway of ‘external pressure – internal cognition – substantive response.’ This study reveals the micro-level mechanism through which institutional investors influence corporate sustainability from a behavioural perspective, offering significant insights for deepening active ownership practices and advancing capital markets' role in serving green development strategies.
Introduction
While Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) principles are becoming central to global investment, corporate performance remains uneven. In China, despite the "dual carbon" strategy (peaking carbon emissions by 2030 and achieving neutrality by 2060), many firms still engage in "greenwashing"—symbolic disclosures without substantive action.
Existing research often treats institutional investors as a monolith, focusing on their shareholding ratios. However, a high ownership stake doesn't necessarily mean active governance. This paper shifts the focus of corporate governance from how much stock institutional investors own to how they behave. By analyzing site research reports of Chinese A-share companies, the study finds that institutional investors' "green attention"—specifically asking environmental questions during site visits—significantly boosts corporate ESG ratings by "awakening" management's environmental awareness.
Methodology
The researchers employed a multi-step econometric approach using a sample of Shanghai and Shenzhen A-share companies from 2012 to 2023.
Indicator Construction
To measure "green attention" (GreAttn), the authors used text analysis on site research records from the CSMAR database. They built an "Environmental Protection Keyword Dictionary" using a pre-trained word vector model from Tencent AI Lab, then used RStudio to flag research reports where investors asked at least one environmental question.
Mediation Analysis
They introduced "Management Environmental Awareness" (MEA) as a mediating variable. This was scored (0–8) based on whether a firm disclosed specific items like environmental philosophy, objectives, or emergency response mechanisms in its annual reports.
Econometric Modeling
A benchmark regression model was established, controlling for firm-level variables (size, age, leverage, etc.) and incorporating year and industry fixed effects to mitigate bias.
Data and Sample
The study utilized a final dataset of 9,904 firm-year observations. Primary sources included Guotai An (CSMAR) for financial and research activity data and the China Research Data Service Platform (CNRDS) for supplemental data. The primary dependent variable was the Bloomberg ESG Disclosure Score, which quantifies performance across 120+ indicators. For robustness, the authors also tested the SynTao Green Finance ESG Rating, a domestically influential metric in China.
Key Insights and Empirical Results
The empirical findings strongly support the hypothesis that green attention improves ESG outcomes.
"Voting with their Mouths"
The study confirms that site research is a vital informal governance mechanism. Unlike "voting with their feet" (selling stock), "voting with their mouths" (asking tough questions) provides a direct channel for investors to exercise "active ownership." The coefficient for GreAttn was 0.465, significant at the 5% level, indicating that as investors ask more environmental questions, the firm's ESG rating systematically rises.
The Transmission Pathway
The authors identify a clear three-step process: External Pressure (investor questions) $\rightarrow$ Internal Cognition (management "awakens" to environmental risks) $\rightarrow$ Substantive Response (improved ESG practices and disclosure). Mediation analysis confirmed that GreAttn significantly increased management's environmental awareness (coefficient 0.039), which in turn drove higher ESG scores.
Descriptive Statistics
Table 2: Descriptive statistics showing the distribution of ESG scores and investor attention across the sample. Source, p. 7
As shown in the descriptive statistics, the mean ESG score was 31.29 (out of 100), indicating significant room for improvement in the Chinese market and highlighting why active investor engagement is so critical.
Discussion and Conclusion
Investor inquiries don't just apply pressure; they act as an educational tool. Professional inquiries help management identify gaps in their environmental strategy and learn best practices from the questions themselves. Even occasional, one-off instances of green attention were found to be effective, suggesting that management is highly sensitive to the type of interest shown by institutional capital.
Limitations and Future Work
While the paper provides a robust framework for behavioral governance, it has some limitations. The study is limited to the Chinese A-share market; the "transmission pathway" might function differently in markets with different regulatory environments. Additionally, the mediator (MEA) is based on public disclosures, which carries a risk of firms simply improving their rhetoric without substantive change. Future research could distinguish between different types of institutional investors (e.g., "green" funds vs. traditional funds) and explore long-term financial performance resulting from this "awakened" awareness.
Summary updated