A Study on the GIS Professional (GISP) Certification Program in the U.S

Dapeng Li, Yingru Li, Quynh C. Nguyen, Laura K. SiebeneckISPRS Int. J. Geo Inf 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This study provides a comprehensive analysis of the GIS Professional (GISP) certification program in the U.S., revealing key demographic and spatial patterns of certified professionals. The findings highlight the program's current state and offer insights for its future development and promotion, particularly in addressing underrepresentation and bridging the education-workforce gap.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The growing importance of Geographic Information Systems (GIS) in various sectors has led to discussions about its professionalization, with certification programs emerging as a key aspect. While the GISP certification is the most popular in the U.S., there's a lack of detailed understanding regarding the characteristics of its holders and the spatial distribution of GIS professionals. This paper aims to fill this gap by analyzing the GISP registry data to understand who is certified, in what roles they operate, and where they are geographically concentrated, thereby informing educators, practitioners, and the certifying body (GISCI) on how to improve the program and the profession.

Methods

The study employed a multi-faceted approach:

  • Data Compilation and Processing: The core dataset was the GISP registry data from the GIS Certification Institute (GISCI), containing information on certified professionals. This data was filtered for U.S. professionals and processed to extract relevant fields.
  • Gender Classification: The genderize.io API was used to classify GISPs by gender based on their first names, with a focus on English names.
  • Job Title and Employer Analysis: A natural language processing (NLP) approach using the Natural Language Toolkit (NLTK) and FuzzyWuzzy library was used to categorize job titles into administrative and non-administrative roles, and further sub-categorize non-administrative roles into GIS Developer, GIS Analyst, and Others. Employers were also categorized into academic institutions, government agencies, and other organizations.
  • Spatial Analysis:
    • GISP Density Mapping: GISP counts were aggregated at the state level and normalized by population to create maps of GISP density.
  • Spatial Autocorrelation: Global Moran's I was used to assess whether the spatial distribution of GISPs is clustered, random, or dispersed.
  • Hotspot and Coldspot Identification: The Getis-Ord Gi* statistic was employed to identify statistically significant hotspots (areas with high GISP density) and coldspots (areas with low GISP density).

Datasets

  • GISP Registry Data: Obtained from the GIS Certification Institute (GISCI) in February 2019, containing records of GISPs certified prior to January 2019. This dataset includes personal and certification details.
  • Zip Code Polygon Data: From ESRI, used to join GISP data to geographic areas.
  • U.S. County and State Boundary Datasets: From U.S. Census TIGER and ESRI, used for spatial aggregation.
  • Urbanized Areas and Urban Clusters Boundary Data: From U.S. Census TIGER, used to classify GISP locations as urban or rural.
  • U.S. Census Population Data: Used for normalizing GISP counts to calculate density per capita.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Urban Concentration: The overwhelming majority of GISPs are located in urban areas, suggesting that GIS job opportunities are heavily concentrated in these regions.
  • Gender Imbalance: A significant gender imbalance exists, with approximately 75% of GISPs being male. This highlights a potential area for targeted outreach and support for female professionals.
  • Dominance of Analysts: The GISP certification program is heavily dominated by GIS Analysts, with a much smaller proportion of GIS Developers. This suggests a potential disconnect between the skills emphasized in GIS education and the broader needs of the GIS workforce, particularly in software development.
  • Geographic Hotspots and Coldspots: The identification of specific geographic clusters of GISPs (hotspots) and areas with fewer GISPs (coldspots) provides valuable insights for strategic promotion and resource allocation for the GISP program.

Key Results

  • Demographics:
    • 97.3% of GISPs are located in urban areas.
  • Approximately 75% of GISPs are male.
  • 43.3% of GISPs hold managerial roles, while 54.5% are in non-administrative roles.
  • Within non-administrative roles, 7% are GIS Developers, 68% are GIS Analysts, and 25% fall into other categories.
  • Geographic Distribution:
    • Florida, California, and Texas have the highest number of GISPs.
  • Hotspots for GISP density were identified around Idaho/Wyoming and Virginia/Washington D.C./Maryland.
  • Coldspots were found in Iowa/Missouri/Arkansas/Louisiana and Connecticut/New Jersey/New York.
  • Employer Types: GISPs are predominantly employed by government agencies (41%) and companies/non-profit organizations (47%), with a smaller percentage in academic institutions (5%).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Descriptive Nature: The study is primarily descriptive and exploratory, providing a snapshot of the current state rather than in-depth causal explanations.
  • Data Source Limitations: Reliance on the GISP registry data means the analysis is limited to the characteristics captured in that dataset (job title, gender, employer).
  • Potential for Bias: The GISP registry data might not perfectly represent all GIS professionals, as certification is voluntary.
  • Future Research Directions:
    • Investigate reasons for non-renewal of certifications.
  • Leverage big data (e.g., GIS job advertisements) to analyze job market trends and employer needs.
  • Examine the representation of females in GIS certification and identify barriers.
  • Explore how GIS professionals globally perceive the GISP and opportunities for international engagement.
  • Conduct research on employer perceptions of GIS certification.
  • Further examine the relationship between GIS higher education and professional certification.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{li2020study,
  author = {Dapeng Li and Yingru Li and Quynh C. Nguyen and Laura K. Siebeneck},
  title = {{A Study on the GIS Professional (GISP) Certification Program in the U.S}},
  journal = {ISPRS Int. J. Geo Inf.},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3390/ijgi9090523},
}
Figure