A Study on the Evaluation Index of Public Design of Historical and Cultural Streetscape

Bo Jiang, Kwan-Seon HongThe Journal of the Korea Contents Association 2021 · DOI

Introduction

As public design becomes a central pillar of urban policy in South Korea, local governments have rushed to implement "streetscape improvement" projects. However, a significant gap persists: while general public design guidelines exist, there is no standardized, objective tool to evaluate the unique requirements of Historical and Cultural Streetscapes.

Without specific metrics, projects often suffer from a "lack of context," where local identity is erased by generic designs, or "bureaucratic stagnation," where administrative convenience takes precedence over resident needs and historical preservation. This research seeks to move beyond subjective "pretty vs. ugly" debates by creating a scientifically validated evaluation index.

Conceptual Framework of Public Design

To establish a rigorous index, it is first necessary to define the scope of public design. The researchers view public design as a nested hierarchy that begins with the broad concept of "publicness" and narrows down to specific physical interventions.

Conceptual hierarchy of public design elements, illustrating the relationship between publicness, public domain, and specific facilities.

As shown in the conceptual model, public design encompasses the public domain, spaces, and architecture, ultimately manifesting in the public facilities that citizens interact with daily. In historical contexts, these layers must be evaluated through the lens of heritage preservation.

Methodology

The researchers employed a robust, three-phase methodology to ensure both the validity and the practical weight of their index:

  1. Delphi Method: A panel of 16 experts (professors, researchers, and public officials) participated in two rounds of surveys. They used the Content Validity Ratio (CVR) to filter 23 initial items down to 19 refined sub-indicators across 6 major categories.
  2. Exploratory Factor Analysis (EFA): To verify the reliability of these indicators, a survey was conducted with 238 design-related professionals and graduate students. Statistical tests (KMO and Bartlett’s) confirmed that the 19 items were grouped logically and reliably (Cronbach's $\alpha$ > 0.7).
  3. Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP): Finally, 20 experts performed pairwise comparisons to determine the relative importance of each factor. This transformed the list of indicators into a weighted hierarchy, showing exactly which elements should be prioritized during a project's budget and design phases.

Defining the Historical Streetscape

The evaluation index distinguishes between physical and non-physical elements of the landscape. This distinction is crucial for historical streetscapes, where the "non-physical" historical sites provide the essential context for "physical" interventions like signage and street furniture.

Classification of physical and non-physical landscape elements used to define the components of historical and cultural streetscapes.

Key Insights and Prioritization

The final evaluation index consists of 6 major categories and 19 sub-items, prioritized through AHP analysis. The results challenge common assumptions about urban design:

  • Identity Over Aesthetics: While "Aesthetic Harmony" is often the primary focus of design projects, the AHP analysis ranked it last (0.1290) among the six major categories.
  • The Primacy of History: The "Historical and Cultural Related" factor was the clear winner (0.1877). The highest-ranked individual sub-item was "Protection and utilization of existing historical and cultural assets," suggesting that authenticity and storytelling are the primary drivers of urban competitiveness.
  • The "Public" in Public Design: The second highest priority was "Public Related" factors (0.1778). Specifically, the sub-item "Inclusive design for multicultural awareness and diverse social groups" ranked very high, indicating that modern heritage streets are viewed as living, inclusive social hubs rather than static museums.

Final Weighted Hierarchy:

  1. Historical & Cultural Related (0.1877): Identity, asset protection, and cultural activation.
  2. Public Related (0.1778): Inclusivity, social interaction, and facility utility.
  3. Safety Related (0.1761): Crime prevention (CPTED) and pedestrian safety.
  4. Accessibility Related (0.1753): Barrier-free environments for the elderly and disabled.
  5. Sustainability Related (0.1551): Durable materials and eco-friendly maintenance.
  6. Aesthetic Harmony Related (0.1290): Visual scale and color coordination.

Conclusion

This study provides a scientifically validated framework for local governments to move beyond generic streetscape improvements. By prioritizing historical authenticity and public inclusivity over mere aesthetics, urban planners can ensure that heritage districts remain both culturally significant and socially functional. Future work will involve applying this index to real-world "before and after" case studies to further refine the weights for different types of urban heritage environments.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{jiang2021study,
  author = {Bo Jiang and Kwan-Seon Hong},
  title = {{A Study on the Evaluation Index of Public Design of Historical and Cultural Streetscape}},
  journal = {The Journal of the Korea Contents Association},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.5392/jkca.2021.21.10.240},
}
Figure