A Study on the Effects of Gender Differences between the Importance of Basic Psychological Needs and the Components of Love: Focusing on lovers

Byung-Hoon Kim, Mee-Sook CheongThe Journal of the Korea Contents Association 2021 · DOI

Abstract

This study investigates how gender influences the relationship between basic psychological needs—autonomy, competence, and relatedness—and the core components of romantic love: intimacy, passion, and commitment. Analyzing data from 193 unmarried couples, the findings reveal a "passion paradox": while relatedness fuels love for both genders, a high need for autonomy in men correlates with lower passion and commitment, a dynamic not observed in women. These nuances are vital for developing better conflict resolution strategies and relationship counseling frameworks.

Introduction: The Psychological Fuel of Love

While love is a universal human experience, the psychological "fuel" that sustains it often differs between individuals. Psychologists have long studied Basic Psychological Needs (BPN)—the idea that humans require autonomy, competence, and relatedness to thrive. However, there is a gap in understanding how the importance one places on these needs translates into the three pillars of love defined by Sternberg: intimacy, passion, and commitment.

The authors tackle this by asking: Do men and women prioritize these needs differently? And more importantly, how does prioritizing independence (autonomy) or connection (relatedness) affect the quality of their romantic relationships?

Methods and Data

The researchers employed a quantitative survey-based approach using two primary validated instruments:

  • Basic Psychological Needs Importance Scale (BPNIS-couple): Measures the value placed on autonomy, competence, and relatedness within a relationship.
  • Sternberg’s Triangular Love Scale (STLS): Assesses levels of intimacy, passion, and commitment.

The study utilized a primary dataset consisting of 193 unmarried couples (386 individuals) residing in the Seoul and Gyeonggi metropolitan areas of South Korea. The majority of participants were in their 20s (77%), with relationship lengths typically between 3 months and 3 years. Data was analyzed using t-tests for gender differences, Pearson correlation for associations, and multiple regression analysis to identify predictors of love components.

Key Results: Gendered Priorities

Analysis revealed significant differences in how men and women value psychological needs and experience love. Women significantly prioritize "relatedness" (the need to feel connected and cared for) more than men. Interestingly, men in this study reported higher baseline levels of passion and commitment than women.

Table 1: Gender differences in Basic Psychological Needs and Love Components

As shown in Table 1, the difference in relatedness importance was statistically significant ($t = -3.528, p < .01$), while men scored significantly higher in passion ($t = 3.588, p < .001$) and commitment ($t = 4.099, p < .001$).

The Passion Paradox and Autonomy

The study's most striking finding is the "Passion Paradox" related to autonomy. While relatedness is a positive predictor of love for both genders, a man's desire for autonomy acts as a "brake" on these feelings.

Table 4: Regression analysis of Basic Psychological Needs on Passion

For men, a high desire for autonomy has a significant negative influence on passion ($\beta = -.220, p = .001$) and commitment. The authors suggest that when men feel their independence is threatened by the demands of a relationship, their romantic drive decreases. In contrast, a woman's desire for autonomy had no significant impact on her feelings of love, which remained primarily tied to relatedness and competence.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Geographic Homogeneity: The study focused exclusively on the Seoul/Gyeonggi metropolitan area; future research should include more diverse cultural samples.
  • Need for Qualitative Data: While quantitative data shows that these differences exist, future interviews are needed to understand why men perceive autonomy as being in conflict with commitment.
  • Longitudinal Perspective: Following couples over several years would reveal how the importance of these needs shifts as a relationship matures from "passion" to "companionate" love.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{kim2021study,
  author = {Byung-Hoon Kim and Mee-Sook Cheong},
  title = {{A Study on the Effects of Gender Differences between the Importance of Basic Psychological Needs and the Components of Love: Focusing on lovers}},
  journal = {The Journal of the Korea Contents Association},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.5392/jkca.2021.21.03.529},
}
Figure