A Study on the Effects of Autonomy of Cabin Crew’s Image Making Standards on Job Enthusiasm, Service Performance and Organizational Performance

Ha Young KimJournal of the Korean Society for Aviation and Aeronautics 2020 · DOI

Abstract

In this study, an analysis is conducted to understand the effect of the cabin crew’s image-making autonomy on job enthusiasm, service performance and organizational performance. And this is conducted on cabin crew members in airlines with autonomy based on image making standards and a total of 109 copies are used for final analysis. First, the image-making autonomy show significant positive (+) influence on all of the sub-factors of job enthusiasm such as job vitality, job commitment, and job commitment. Second, all sub-factors of job enthusiasm, job vitality, job commitment and job commitment show a significant positive (+) influence on service performance. Third, service performance show a significant positive (+) influence relationship on organizational performance. As a result, it is expected that airlines will be used as a basis for easing the regulations for image making of cabin crew and introducing an autonomous management system in the future.

Introduction

For decades, the airline industry has been synonymous with rigid, uncompromising grooming standards for cabin crew—prescribing everything from the exact shade of lipstick to the specific height of a hair bun. While intended to ensure brand consistency, these "look books" can act as stressors that stifle individuality and reduce job satisfaction. This paper addresses a fundamental question in organizational psychology: Does "image-making autonomy"—the freedom for employees to manage their own professional appearance—actually improve the bottom line? By applying Self-Determination Theory (SDT) to the aviation context, the study explores whether moving from a culture of compliance to a culture of autonomy can turn a "uniform" workforce into a more enthusiastic and productive one.

Methodology

The researcher employed a quantitative approach using Structural Equation Modeling (SEM) to test the causal relationships between autonomy, enthusiasm, and performance. The study utilized a primary dataset consisting of 109 valid survey responses collected in October 2019 from cabin crew members at "T Airline" (a Korean carrier that has introduced autonomous grooming standards).

Measurement was conducted using a 5-point Likert scale across five key constructs: Image-making Autonomy, Job Enthusiasm (sub-divided into vitality, commitment, and dedication), Service Performance, and Organizational Performance. The analysis pipeline included Exploratory Factor Analysis (EFA) and Confirmatory Factor Analysis (CFA) to ensure the validity and reliability of the survey items, followed by Path Analysis via AMOS 21.

Reliability and validity analysis of the measurement model, showing Cronbach's alpha and factor loadings.

Results

The structural model supported all primary hypotheses with statistically significant positive (+) influences. The model demonstrated high statistical reliability, with a Comparative Fit Index (CFI) of 0.962 and an Incremental Fit Index (IFI) of 0.963.

  • Autonomy → Enthusiasm: Image-making autonomy showed a significant positive influence on all sub-factors of job enthusiasm (vitality, commitment, and dedication).
  • Enthusiasm → Service: Higher job enthusiasm directly led to improved service performance, such as better responsiveness to passengers and problem-solving.
  • Service → Organization: Service performance showed a strong positive relationship with organizational performance.
Path analysis results illustrating the significant positive relationships between autonomy, job enthusiasm, service performance, and organizational performance.

Discussion and Conclusion

The findings suggest a psychological chain reaction: autonomy leads to higher vitality and commitment, which are core components of job enthusiasm. When crew members feel they have control over their image, they experience less "emotional labor" and fatigue, allowing for more authentic and effective customer service.

This study argues that "uniformity" should not be confused with "brand quality." A crew that looks slightly different but feels empowered may represent the brand better than a perfectly uniform but exhausted crew. While limited by a sample size of 109 from a single airline, the results provide a basis for airlines to consider easing image-making regulations and introducing autonomous management systems to boost overall organizational performance.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this study, an analysis is conducted to understand the effect of the cabin crew’s image-making autonomy on job enthusiasm, service performance and organizational performance. And this is conducted on cabin crew members in airlines with autonomy based on image making standards and a total of 109 copies are used for final analysis. First, the image-making autonomy show significant positive (+) influence on all of the sub-factors of job enthusiasm such as job vitality, job commitment, and job commitment. Second, all sub-factors of job enthusiasm, job vitality, job commitment and job commitment show a significant positive (+) influence on service performance. Third, service performance show a significant positive (+) influence relationship on organizational performance. As a result, it is expected that airlines will be used as a basis for easing the regulations for image making of cabin crew and introducing an autonomous management system in the future.
BibTeX
@article{kim2020study,
  author = {Ha Young Kim},
  title = {{A Study on the Effects of Autonomy of Cabin Crew’s Image Making Standards on Job Enthusiasm, Service Performance and Organizational Performance}},
  journal = {Journal of the Korean Society for Aviation and Aeronautics},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.12985/ksaa.2020.28.4.032},
}
Figure