A Study on Supercooled Storage of Leaf Lettuces Produced in Plant Factory

Thinh Nguyen Quang, Koji Iwamura, Rajesh Shrestha, Nobuhiro SugimuraJapan 2017 · DOI

Abstract

Plant factories produce large quantities of high-quality vegetables under artificially controlled environments. A critical challenge is establishing storage systems that extend shelf life while minimizing foodborne illness risks. This study investigates the application of supercooling technology—cooling below the freezing point without phase change—to extend the shelf life of leaf lettuce. Findings indicate that the freezing point of plant-factory lettuce is approximately -0.2°C, with nucleation occurring between -1.0°C and -6.1°C. The study demonstrates that double-layered packaging stabilizes the supercooled state by controlling cooling rates. Results show that supercooled lettuce maintains initial water and sugar content by reducing respiration rates and suppresses bacterial growth, remaining safe for consumption after three weeks of storage.

Introduction

Food waste remains a significant global challenge, with 25–30% of perishable food wasted post-harvest. Plant factories, such as the one at Osaka Prefecture University (OPU), produce high-quality greens but face a bottleneck: standard refrigeration typically preserves lettuce for only about a week. While freezing extends storage, it often compromises the cellular structure of delicate greens, leading to poor texture. This research explores supercooling as a middle-ground solution, maintaining the liquid state below the freezing point to preserve quality without structural damage.

Methodology

The researchers utilized leaf lettuce harvested from the OPU plant factory (mean weight ~101.5g, 3.4 Brix% sugar, 92% water). The experimental approach focused on three pillars:

  1. Thermal Characterization: Identifying the freezing point and nucleation temperature using high-precision sensors in an incubator refrigerator.
  2. Packaging Dynamics: Testing three configurations—non-packed, single-packed (polypropylene/PP bags), and double-layer packed (PP bag inside a larger PP bag)—to evaluate their influence on cooling stability.
  3. Long-term Storage Trials: Comparing standard refrigeration (5°C) with supercooled storage (-3°C) over 21 days, measuring weight loss, sugar content, and Aerobic Plate Count (AOAC Official Method).
Experimental setup for monitoring supercooled storage conditions, featuring the incubator, thermal sensors, and data logging system.

Results and Discussion

The Supercooling Window

The lettuce's freezing point was identified at approximately -0.2°C, while nucleation (ice formation) occurred between -1.0°C and -6.1°C. This narrow window requires precise temperature control to maintain the metastable supercooled state.

Packaging as a Thermal Buffer

A key finding was that the cooling rate is as vital as the target temperature. Double-layer packaging acted as an insulator against turbulent cold air, preventing "flash freezing" and allowing the lettuce to remain stable at -3°C for the duration of the study. In contrast, non-packed samples froze almost immediately.

The double-layered polypropylene packaging configuration used to insulate samples and stabilize the supercooled state.

Preservation of Quality and Safety

  • Weight and Sugar: After three weeks, refrigerated lettuce lost over 8% of its weight, while supercooled samples lost less than 3%. Sugar content remained stable in supercooled samples, whereas refrigerated samples showed significant fluctuations due to higher respiration rates.
  • Microbial Control: Supercooling effectively inhibited bacterial growth. By week three, refrigerated lettuce reached $10^{6.2}$ CFU/g, exceeding common safety thresholds, while supercooled lettuce remained at a safer $10^{5.1}$ CFU/g.

Conclusion and Future Work

Supercooled storage at -3°C significantly extends the shelf life of leaf lettuce while maintaining nutritional and safety standards. However, scaling this technology requires addressing the environmental impact of double-layered plastic packaging and ensuring stability against vibrations during transport, which can trigger unwanted freezing. Future research should also evaluate the energy efficiency of maintaining sub-zero temperatures compared to standard refrigeration systems.

Summary updated

Abstract

Plant factories daily produce large amount of high quality vegetables under artificially controlled environments. One of the important issues to be considered is to establish suitable storage systems to achieve an acceptable length of shelf life and to minimize the risk to foodborne illnesses. This study deals with the application of the supercooling technologies (cooling below the freezing point without phase change) to the extension of the shelf life of the high quality leaf lettuces produced by the plant factories. The followings were found through the experimental study. The freezing temperature of the leaf lettuces of the plant factories is around -0.2℃ and the nucleation temperature of the leaf lettuces is between -1.0℃ and -6.1℃. The type of packages affects the characteristics of the supercooled lettuce by controlling the cooling rates and to reduce the risk of being frozen in the supercooled state. It was also shown that the lettuces under supercooled conditions keep the initial state of the water and sugar contents by reducing the respiration rate, and that the risk of foodborne illness is improved by keeping the number of the bacteria in low level even after the supercooled storages for three weeks.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{quang2017study,
  author = {Thinh Nguyen Quang and Koji IWAMURA and Rajesh Shrestha and Nobuhiro Sugimura},
  title = {{A Study on Supercooled Storage of Leaf Lettuces Produced in Plant Factory}},
  booktitle = {Japan},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.11301/jsfe.16473},
}
Figure