TL;DR
This study investigates how Chinese audiences perceive intangible cultural heritage (ICH) through short videos on platforms like TikTok. By analyzing user comments, the research reveals that while audiences generally exhibit positive emotions towards these videos, their understanding of ICH often remains superficial, influenced heavily by visual appeal and novelty. The findings highlight the need for richer content to foster deeper engagement and preservation.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Intangible cultural heritage (ICH) in China faces a dual challenge: preservation and inheritance. While official directives emphasize "dissemination" as a key to its survival, the rise of new media, particularly short video platforms like TikTok, presents both opportunities and challenges. These platforms have become crucial for the "living transmission" of ICH, but it's unclear how effectively they foster genuine understanding and appreciation among a broad audience, especially younger demographics. This paper addresses the gap in understanding audience perception of ICH presented through short videos, aiming to uncover the depth of engagement and identify areas for improvement in dissemination strategies.
Methods
The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach to analyze audience perception:
- Web Crawler Technology: A Python web crawler was used to collect a substantial dataset of online comments from short videos on the "Artisan Collection" TikTok account.
- Text Sentiment Analysis: This technique, implemented using ROST-CM6 software, was crucial for classifying comments into positive, neutral, and negative emotional categories. It further allowed for a granular analysis of sentiment strength (general, moderate, high).
- Word Frequency Analysis: This method helped identify recurring themes and keywords within the comments, providing insights into what aspects of ICH resonate most with the audience.
- Semantic Network Analysis: This advanced technique was used to visualize the relationships between high-frequency words, revealing the structure of public cognition and attention towards ICH as presented in the videos. It mapped out core concepts, inner layers of understanding, and marginal connections to modern society.
Datasets
The primary dataset for this study consisted of 14,281 online comments collected from short videos on the TikTok account "Artisan Collection." This data was further refined by filtering for videos with similar themes, ultimately focusing on 389 short videos that had garnered over 1,000 likes. Additionally, a dataset of over 1,000 short videos from the "Artisan Collection" account was used to collect themes, likes, comments, and forwards. No new benchmarks were introduced; rather, existing comment data from a popular ICH-focused account was utilized.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Surface-Level Understanding: A significant finding is that audience perception of ICH through short videos tends to remain on the surface. While users express admiration, their comments often lack deep engagement with the historical context or intricate details of the heritage.
- Positive Emotional Tendency, Limited Depth: The majority of audience comments are positive, indicating a general appreciation for ICH content. However, this positive sentiment doesn't necessarily translate to a profound understanding or a strong desire for deeper engagement.
- Visuals and Novelty Reign Supreme: Audience perception is heavily influenced by the visual appeal and novelty of the short videos. Videos with high production quality, striking visuals, and unique content are more likely to garner likes and shares, even if the ICH itself is less visually dynamic.
- "Luxury Goods" Perception: The semantic network analysis revealed that many users perceive ICH products as expensive and inaccessible, akin to "luxury goods," which limits their personal experience and connection.
- Bridging Tradition and Modernity: The study suggests that while ICH is rooted in tradition, its successful dissemination in contemporary society requires innovation and technical integration, making it more relatable and applicable to modern life.
Key Results
- Sentiment Distribution: 45.20% of comments were positive, 37.32% were neutral, and 17.48% were negative.
- Positive Emotion Breakdown: Within positive emotions, "general positive" (0-15) constituted 26.18%, and "moderate positive" (15-25) was 10.95%.
- Negative Comments: A total of 2023 negative comments were analyzed, highlighting issues like improper comparisons, monotonous products, lack of practical application, high cost, and the risk of extinction.
- Visual Impact: Videos showcasing visually rich crafts like velvet flower production and molten iron flower received over 100,000 likes, while those with less visual appeal, like calligraphy and suona, had fewer than 1,000 likes.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge that the perception of ICH through short videos often remains superficial, with audiences primarily engaging with visual effects and novelty rather than deep content. This limits the audience's understanding of the historical background and intricate details of ICH.
Future work should focus on:
- Deeper Exploration: Encouraging creators to provide more thorough explanations and diverse forms of content to enhance audience comprehension.
- Balancing Commercial Interests and Cultural Values: Addressing the challenge of integrating commercial aspects with the preservation of cultural authenticity.
- Sustainable Development: Investigating how short videos can effectively promote the sustainable development of ICH.
- Content Innovation: Strengthening production through content arrangement and innovation to improve dissemination effectiveness.
Summary updated