A Study of Young Chinese Intentions to Purchase “Online Paid Knowledge”: An Extended Technological Acceptance Model

Aiting Xu, Wei Li, Zhiyu Chen, Shouzhen Zeng, Carlos Llopis‐Albert, Yuhan ZhuFrontiers in Psychology 2021 · DOI

Abstract

Under the catalysis of knowledge anxiety and cognitive surplus, knowledge sharing platforms have experienced rapid growth, accelerating the integration of online knowledge resources. Consumers play a pivotal role in the sustainable development of online paid knowledge (OPK). This study constructs an extended Technological Acceptance Model (TAM) to examine factors influencing young Chinese people's willingness to pay for OPK. Surveying 405 participants and utilizing structural equation modeling (SEM), the findings indicate that perceived ease of use positively associates with perceived usefulness and attitudes, which in turn drive purchase intention. Perceived risk and group conformity indirectly affect willingness to pay. This research advances the field by empirically testing the impact of perceived risk and cultural influence on purchasing intention.

Introduction

The "Online Paid Knowledge" (OPK) industry in China—featuring platforms like Zhihu, Weibo Q&A, and Himalaya FM—has reached a market scale of nearly 40 billion RMB. Despite this growth, the industry faces a retention crisis, with low repurchase rates and only 41% user satisfaction. Standard consumer behavior models often overlook the unique uncertainty of knowledge products and the specific cultural context of the Chinese market. This study aims to identify the functional and social levers motivating young, highly educated Chinese users to pay for digital content.

Theoretical Framework and Methodology

The researchers utilized an Extended Technological Acceptance Model (TAM). While the standard TAM focuses on Perceived Usefulness (PU) and Perceived Ease of Use (PEOU), this study incorporates two critical external variables:

  1. Perceived Risk (PR): Concerns regarding privacy and the potential for "worthless" or redundant information.
  2. Group Conformity (GC): A cultural construct reflecting social influence from peers and group norms.
The proposed research model with nine hypotheses (H1-H9) connecting external variables to the core TAM constructs.

The study surveyed 405 participants, primarily undergraduate and postgraduate students (95.8%) from 20 universities in Zhejiang Province. Data was analyzed using Structural Equation Modeling (SEM) to test nine hypotheses.

Key Results and Analysis

The SEM analysis supported all nine hypotheses with high statistical significance.

Structural equation modeling results showing path coefficients and R-squared values for the extended TAM.

Direct and Indirect Drivers

  • Direct Drivers: Perceived Usefulness (path coefficient 0.442) and Attitude (0.369) were the strongest predictors of Purchase Intention.
  • Indirect Drivers:
    • Perceived Risk exerted a significant negative indirect effect (-0.228) on purchase intention.
  • Group Conformity showed a significant positive indirect effect (0.198).
  • Model Fit: The model demonstrated a strong fit (RMSEA = 0.059; CFI = 0.926), validating the extended TAM for this market.

Behavioral Insights

  • The "Ease of Use" Multiplier: PEOU was the most significant factor, directly enhancing the perceived value of the knowledge itself. A clunky platform interface diminishes the perceived utility of the content.
  • Risk as a Cognitive Barrier: Fear of overcharging or data insecurity creates a "cognitive drag," lowering the perceived utility and ease of use.
  • Cultural Collectivism: In the Chinese context, "Group Conformity" is a major driver. Social validation significantly influences how useful and easy to use a service is perceived to be.

Conclusion and Implications

The study highlights that "knowledge anxiety"—the fear of falling behind in a competitive society—is a primary catalyst for OPK growth, particularly for professional knowledge.

Theoretical and Practical Implications: * For Platforms: Improving user interface (PEOU) is not just about aesthetics; it directly impacts perceived value. Platforms must also address perceived risk through transparent pricing and data security. * Cultural Strategy: Marketing should leverage social proof and group norms, given the high impact of group conformity.

Limitations: The study's focus on college students in one province may limit generalizability. Future research should explore "fuzzy sets" for decision-making uncertainty and conduct cross-cultural comparisons to test the weight of group conformity in individualistic societies.

Summary updated

Abstract

Under the catalysis of knowledge anxiety and cognitive surplus, knowledge sharing platforms has experienced rapid growth, which has accelerated the integration of knowledge resources online. As with all new successful and sustainable business products, the consumers will play an important role in the future development of online paid knowledge. Therefore, we constructed an extended technological acceptance model by examining factors that influence young Chinese people's willingness to pay for online paid knowledge. The study surveyed 405 young Chinese participants, in which the extended technological acceptance model was tested by using structural equation modeling. Findings indicate that perceived ease of use is positively associated with perceived usefulness and associated attitudes, whereas perceived usefulness and attitude is positively associated with purchase intention. Perceived risk and group conformity are found to indirectly affect consumers' willingness to pay. The study advances the current body of knowledge by empirically testing the impact of perceived risk and the role of cultural influence (group conformity) on purchasing intention. Finally, theoretical and practical implications are discussed.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{xu2021study,
  author = {Aiting Xu and Wei Li and Zhiyu Chen and Shouzhen Zeng and Carlos Llopis‐Albert and Yuhan Zhu},
  title = {{A Study of Young Chinese Intentions to Purchase “Online Paid Knowledge”: An Extended Technological Acceptance Model}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychology},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyg.2021.695600},
}
Figure