A Study of the Radiation Tolerance of CVD Diamond to 70 MeV Protons, Fast Neutrons and 200 MeV Pions

Lukas Bäni, Andreas Alexopoulos, Marina Artuso, Felix Bachmair, Marcin Bartosik, Helge Beck, Vincenzo Bellini, Vladimir Belyaev, Benjamin Bentele, Alexandre Bes, Jean-Marie Brom, Gabriele Chiodini, Dominik Chren, Vladimir Cindro, Gilles Claus, Johann Collot, John Cumalat, Sébastien Curtoni, Anne Dabrowski, Raffaello D'Alessandro, Denis Dauvergne, Wim de Boer, Christian Dorfer, Marc Dünser, Gerald Eigen, Vladimir Eremin, Jacopo Forneris, Laurent Gallin-Martel, Marie-Laure Gallin-Martel, Kock Gan, Martin Gastal, Abderrahman Ghimouz, Mathieu Goffe, Joel Goldstein, Alexander Golubev, Andrej Gorisek, Eugene Grigoriev, Jörn Grosse-Knetter, Aidan Grummer, Bojan Hiti, Dmitry Hits, Martin Hoeferkamp, Jérôme Hosselet, Fabian Hügging, Chris Hutson, Jens Janssen, Harris Kagan, Keida Kanxheri, Richard Kass, Mladen Kis, Gregor Kramberger, Sergey Kuleshov, Ana Lacoste, Stefano Lagomarsino, Alessandro Lo Giudice, Ivan López Paz, Eric Lukosi, Chaker Maazouzi, Igor Mandic, Sara Marcatili, Alysia Marino, Cédric Mathieu, Mauro Menichelli, Marko Mikuz, Arianna Morozzi, Francesco Moscatelli, Joshua Moss, Raymond Mountain, Alexander Oh, Paolo Olivero, Daniele Passeri, Heinz Pernegger, Roberto Perrino, Federico Picollo, Michal Pomorski, Renato Potenza, Arnulf Quadt, Fatah Rarbi, Alessandro Re, Michael Reichmann, Shaun Roe, Olivier Rossetto, Diego Sanz Becerra, Christian J. Schmidt, Stephen Schnetzer, Silvio Sciortino, Andrea Scorzoni, Sally Seidel, Leonello Servoli, Dale Smith, Bruno Sopko, Vit Sopko, Stefania Spagnolo, Stefan Spanier, Kevin Stenson, Robert Stone, Bjarne Stugu, Concetta Sutera, Michael Träger, William Trischuk, Marco Truccato, Cristina Tuvè, Jaap Velthuis, Stephen Wagner, Rainer Wallny, Jianchun Wang, Norbert Wermes, Jayashani Wickramasinghe, Mahfoud Yamouni, Justas Zalieckas, Marko Zavrtanik, Kazuhiko Hara, Yoichi Ikegami, Osamu Jinnouchi, Takashi Kohriki, Shingo Mitsui, Ryo Nagai, Susumu Terada, Yoshinobu Unno2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the radiation tolerance of Chemical Vapor Deposition (CVD) diamond, a promising material for particle detectors in high-energy physics experiments. By systematically irradiating diamond samples with protons, neutrons, and pions, the researchers quantified their damage constants and developed a universal damage curve, demonstrating diamond's robustness and providing crucial data for future detector design.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

High-energy physics experiments, like those at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC), involve intense radiation environments. Particle detectors used in these experiments must be able to withstand this radiation without significant degradation in performance. Diamond, particularly CVD diamond, has emerged as a strong candidate for detector applications due to its excellent electronic properties and inherent radiation hardness. However, a comprehensive understanding of its radiation tolerance across a range of particle types and energies is crucial for optimizing detector design and predicting their lifespan in future, even more demanding, experimental conditions. This paper aims to fill this gap by providing detailed measurements of radiation damage in CVD diamond exposed to 70 MeV protons, fast reactor neutrons, and 200 MeV pions, and by comparing these results with existing data to establish universal damage trends.

Methods

The core of this study involves measuring the charge collected by diamond strip detectors after irradiation. The researchers used a 120 GeV hadron beam to probe the detectors' response. Before and after irradiation, the amount of charge generated by the beam particles passing through the diamond was measured. This charge collection is directly related to the diamond's ability to generate and transport electron-hole pairs, which is degraded by radiation-induced defects.

The key measurement is the "charge collection distance" (ccd), which represents how far an electron-hole pair drifts under an applied electric field before being collected. This was calculated from the measured signal charge. A first-order damage model was then applied to relate the inverse of the ccd to the irradiation fluence (the total number of particles incident per unit area). This relationship allowed the researchers to derive a "damage constant" for each type of radiation, quantifying how effectively that radiation degrades the diamond's performance.

To account for variations between individual diamond samples, a "universal damage curve" was developed. This involved scaling the fluences by relative damage constants and shifting the data points by a "fluence offset" to bring all datasets onto a common plot. Additionally, the FWHM/MP (Full Width at Half Maximum divided by the Most Probable Value) of the signal charge distribution was analyzed as a measure of material uniformity, which is also affected by radiation.

Datasets

The study utilized commercially available CVD diamond samples, including both single-crystalline (scCVD) and polycrystalline (pCVD) types. These samples were characterized before and after irradiation. The irradiations were performed using:

  • 70 MeV protons: Samples 1 and 2 were irradiated to fluences up to (8.8 ± 0.9) × 10¹⁵ protons/cm².
  • Fast reactor neutrons (energy > 0.1 MeV): Samples 3 and 4 were irradiated to fluences up to (1.43 ± 0.14) × 10¹⁶ neutrons/cm².
  • 200 MeV pions: Samples 5, 6, and 7 were irradiated to fluences up to (6.5 ± 1.4) × 10¹⁴ pions/cm².

The analysis also incorporated previously published data from 24 GeV and 800 MeV proton irradiations [4] and 25 MeV proton irradiations [24] to establish the universal damage curve and relative damage constants.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Diamond's Resilience: CVD diamond demonstrates remarkable radiation tolerance across a range of particle types and energies, making it highly suitable for demanding detector applications.
  • Universal Damage Behavior: Despite variations in particle type and energy, the damage to CVD diamond can be described by a universal damage curve when fluences are scaled appropriately. This simplifies predictions for detector performance under various irradiation scenarios.
  • Relative Damage Factors: The study quantifies how much more damaging certain particles are compared to a reference (24 GeV protons). This is crucial for understanding the impact of different radiation environments.
  • Uniformity Improvement: Interestingly, the FWHM/MP ratio, a measure of material uniformity, tends to decrease with irradiation for pCVD diamond, suggesting that irradiation can actually improve the uniformity of polycrystalline diamond, bringing it closer to that of single-crystal diamond.

Key Results

  • Damage Constants: The measured damage constants for CVD diamond are:
  • 70 MeV protons: 1.62 ± 0.07 (stat) ± 0.16 (syst) × 10⁻¹⁸ cm²/(pµm)
    • Fast reactor neutrons: 2.65 ± 0.13 (stat) ± 0.18 (syst) × 10⁻¹⁸ cm²/(nµm)
    • 200 MeV pions: 2.0 ± 0.2 (stat) ± 0.5 (syst) × 10⁻¹⁸ cm²/(πµm)
  • Relative Damage: Compared to 24 GeV protons (set as a baseline of 1.0):
  • 70 MeV protons are 2.60 ± 0.29 times more damaging.
  • Fast reactor neutrons are 4.3 ± 0.4 times more damaging.
  • 200 MeV pions are 3.2 ± 0.8 times more damaging.
  • Universal Curve: A universal damage curve was successfully generated, illustrating that the damage response of CVD diamond to protons, neutrons, and pions can be unified by scaling fluences and applying sample-specific offsets.
  • Comparison with Silicon: Diamond exhibits significantly better radiation tolerance than silicon for proton and pion irradiations, being more than twice as resistant. For neutron irradiations, silicon and diamond show comparable radiation tolerance.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sample Dependence: While a universal damage curve was achieved, the initial charge collection distance (λ₀) was found to be sample-dependent, requiring individual sample characterization.
  • Extrapolation: The study extrapolates findings to predict performance, which inherently carries uncertainties.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that the established universal damage curve and relative damage constants can be used to predict the effects of radiation on any planned diamond detectors. Further investigations into the underlying mechanisms of damage and the development of even more radiation-hard diamond materials could be pursued. The comparison with silicon highlights the continued potential of diamond for future high-luminosity collider experiments.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{bani2020study,
  author = {Lukas Bäni and Andreas Alexopoulos and Marina Artuso and Felix Bachmair and Marcin Bartosik and Helge Beck and Vincenzo Bellini and Vladimir Belyaev and Benjamin Bentele and Alexandre Bes and Jean-Marie Brom and Gabriele Chiodini and Dominik Chren and Vladimir Cindro and Gilles Claus and Johann Collot and John Cumalat and Sébastien Curtoni and Anne Dabrowski and Raffaello D'Alessandro and Denis Dauvergne and Wim de Boer and Christian Dorfer and Marc Dünser and Gerald Eigen and Vladimir Eremin and Jacopo Forneris and Laurent Gallin-Martel and Marie-Laure Gallin-Martel and Kock Gan and Martin Gastal and Abderrahman Ghimouz and Mathieu Goffe and Joel Goldstein and Alexander Golubev and Andrej Gorisek and Eugene Grigoriev and Jörn Grosse-Knetter and Aidan Grummer and Bojan Hiti and Dmitry Hits and Martin Hoeferkamp and Jérôme Hosselet and Fabian Hügging and Chris Hutson and Jens Janssen and Harris Kagan and Keida Kanxheri and Richard Kass and Mladen Kis and Gregor Kramberger and Sergey Kuleshov and Ana Lacoste and Stefano Lagomarsino and Alessandro Lo Giudice and Ivan López Paz and Eric Lukosi and Chaker Maazouzi and Igor Mandic and Sara Marcatili and Alysia Marino and Cédric Mathieu and Mauro Menichelli and Marko Mikuz and Arianna Morozzi and Francesco Moscatelli and Joshua Moss and Raymond Mountain and Alexander Oh and Paolo Olivero and Daniele Passeri and Heinz Pernegger and Roberto Perrino and Federico Picollo and Michal Pomorski and Renato Potenza and Arnulf Quadt and Fatah Rarbi and Alessandro Re and Michael Reichmann and Shaun Roe and Olivier Rossetto and Diego Sanz Becerra and Christian J. Schmidt and Stephen Schnetzer and Silvio Sciortino and Andrea Scorzoni and Sally Seidel and Leonello Servoli and Dale Smith and Bruno Sopko and Vit Sopko and Stefania Spagnolo and Stefan Spanier and Kevin Stenson and Robert Stone and Bjarne Stugu and Concetta Sutera and Michael Träger and William Trischuk and Marco Truccato and Cristina Tuvè and Jaap Velthuis and Stephen Wagner and Rainer Wallny and Jianchun Wang and Norbert Wermes and Jayashani Wickramasinghe and Mahfoud Yamouni and Justas Zalieckas and Marko Zavrtanik and Kazuhiko Hara and Yoichi Ikegami and Osamu Jinnouchi and Takashi Kohriki and Shingo Mitsui and Ryo Nagai and Susumu Terada and Yoshinobu Unno},
  title = {{A Study of the Radiation Tolerance of CVD Diamond to 70 MeV Protons, Fast Neutrons and 200 MeV Pions}},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3390/s20226648},
}

Loading related content...

Figure