A Study of the Influence of Sex on Genome Wide Methylation

Jingyu Liu, M.y. Morgan, Kent E. Hutchison, Vince D. CalhounPLoS 2010 · DOI

Abstract

Sex differences in methylation status have been observed in specific gene-disease studies and healthy methylation variation studies, but little work has been done to study the impact of sex on methylation at the genome-wide locus-to-locus level. This study investigates the genomic sex effect on saliva DNA methylation of 197 subjects using 20,493 CpG sites. Using T-tests, PCA, and ICA, the researchers identified sex influences on both the X chromosome and autosomes. A novel correction method based on Independent Component Analysis (ICA) is proposed to remove these confounding effects in association studies.

Introduction

In Epigenome-Wide Association Studies (EWAS), identifying chemical "tags" or methylation patterns that correlate with diseases is a primary goal. However, biological sex represents a significant source of variation that can confound these results. While X-chromosome inactivation is a known driver of methylation differences, the extent of sex influence on the 22 pairs of autosomes is often overlooked. If a methylation site is influenced by both sex and a target phenotype (e.g., age, smoking, or cancer), sex becomes a confounding variable that can lead to false discoveries.

This study utilizes a primary dataset of saliva DNA from 197 subjects (54 females, 143 males) and a validation dataset of peripheral blood cell DNA (1,298 CpG sites) to map these differences and develop a robust correction tool.

Methodology

The researchers analyzed over 20,000 CpG sites using the Illumina Infinium Methylation Assay. Three statistical approaches were compared:

  1. Two-sample T-tests for direct associations between sex and specific sites.
  2. Principal Component Analysis (PCA) to identify broad variance factors.
  3. Independent Component Analysis (ICA) to isolate statistically independent sources.

The study proposes an ICA-based correction algorithm. By identifying the specific "Independent Component" most strongly correlated with sex, researchers can mathematically subtract its contribution from the dataset, effectively "de-noising" the signal while preserving other phenotypic data.

Results and Discussion

The analysis revealed that sex differences are not confined to the X chromosome. While 678 sites on the X chromosome showed significant associations, 12 autosomal sites also passed stringent Bonferroni correction. In total, 580 autosomal sites showed strong differences between males and females, clustering into functional groups such as DNA transcription and RNA splicing.

Methylation differences between males and females across specific genes (A) and the X chromosome (B).

Interestingly, the overlap of sex-affected genes between saliva and blood was high for the X chromosome (81%) but low for autosomes (8%), suggesting that autosomal sex-based regulation is highly tissue-specific.

The ICA-based correction proved superior to PCA. While PCA distributed the sex signal across multiple components, ICA isolated it into a single factor. After applying the ICA correction, the number of sites significantly associated with sex dropped to zero, while associations with other phenotypes, such as marijuana use, became clearer (increasing from 8 to 11 identified sites).

Conclusion

This research highlights the necessity of accounting for biological sex in genomic association studies. The proposed ICA-based correction method provides a data-driven way to disentangle sex influences from other phenotypic signals. Future work should expand this mapping to a wider variety of human tissues to create a comprehensive "sex-effect atlas" and further explore the biological mechanisms—such as hormonal influences—driving these epigenetic differences.

Summary updated

Abstract

Sex differences in methylation status have been observed in specific gene-disease studies and healthy methylation variation studies, but little work has been done to study the impact of sex on methylation at the genome wide locus-to-locus level or to determine methods for accounting for sex in genomic association studies. In this study we investigate the genomic sex effect on saliva DNA methylation of 197 subjects (54 females) using 20,493 CpG sites. Three methods, two-sample T-test, principle component analysis and independent component analysis, all successfully identify sex influences. The results show that sex not only influences the methylation of genes in the X chromosome but also in autosomes. 580 autosomal sites show strong differences between males and females. They are found to be highly involved in eight functional groups, including DNA transcription, RNA splicing, membrane, etc. Equally important is that we identify some methylation sites associated with not only sex, but also other phenotypes (age, smoking and drinking level, and cancer). Verification was done through an independent blood cell DNA methylation data (1298 CpG sites from a cancer panel array). The same genomic site-specific influence pattern and potential confounding effects with cancer were observed. The overlapping rate of identified sex affected genes between saliva and blood cell is 81% for X chromosome, and 8% for autosomes. Therefore, correction for sex is necessary. We propose a simple correction method based on independent component analysis, which is a data driven method and accommodates sample differences. Comparison before and after the correction suggests that the method is able to effectively remove the potentially confounding effects of sex, and leave other phenotypes untouched. As such, our method is able to disentangle the sex influence on a genome wide level, and paves the way to achieve more accurate association analyses in genome wide methylation studies.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2010study,
  author = {Jingyu Liu and M.Y. Morgan and Kent E. Hutchison and Vince D. Calhoun},
  title = {{A Study of the Influence of Sex on Genome Wide Methylation}},
  booktitle = {PLoS},
  year = {2010},
  doi = {10.1371/journal.pone.0010028},
}
Figure