A Study of Some Properties Which Determine the Resolution of a Lead Scintillator Sandwich Electromagnetic Shower Detector

J. Hanson, Bruce Brown, A. S. Ito, H. Jöstlein, Y. Sakai, K. Sugano, D. A. Finley, Y. Hemmi, A. Maki1980 · DOI

This paper delves into the critical factors influencing the energy resolution of lead-scintillator sampling shower detectors, a key component in particle physics experiments. The authors meticulously investigate how energy, sampling thickness, and photostatistics contribute to the detector's ability to accurately measure particle energies, providing valuable insights for the design of future, larger detectors.

TL;DR

This study quantifies the impact of sampling thickness and photostatistics on the energy resolution of lead-scintillator shower detectors. The findings confirm existing design formulas and offer a robust understanding of how to optimize detector performance, crucial for building next-generation particle physics instruments.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Accurately measuring the energy of particles is fundamental to particle physics research. Electromagnetic shower detectors, which are used to detect electrons and photons, rely on sampling materials (like lead) interspersed with active detectors (like scintillators) to measure the energy deposited by a particle as it interacts and creates a "shower" of secondary particles. The overall resolution, or the precision with which the energy can be measured, is influenced by several factors. The authors focus on two primary contributors: the thickness of the sampling layers (which affects how many interactions occur) and the number of photoelectrons produced by the scintillator light (which relates to the detector's sensitivity and noise). Understanding and quantifying these contributions is essential for designing detectors with optimal performance, especially for large-scale experiments where direct testing at all relevant energies is often infeasible.

Methods

The researchers employed a lead-scintillator sampling shower detector constructed with polystyrene scintillator and lead plates. They used a 10-50 GeV test beam at Fermilab to study the detector's response. To vary the photostatistics, they used neutral density filters with transmissions ranging from 1% to 80%. Sampling thickness was adjusted by masking alternate scintillator layers. Data analysis involved calculating the mean and sigma of the energy deposition peaks, with iterative cuts to remove outliers and account for phototube gain drifts. They also performed a pion run with increased phototube voltage to directly observe single photoelectron peaks and verify Poisson statistics.

Datasets

The primary dataset consists of data collected from a lead-scintillator sampling shower detector using electron beams at energies of 10, 15, 20, 30, and 46 GeV. This data was collected at the Fermilab test beam facility. No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, the study utilizes experimental data from a custom-built detector.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Photostatistics are Crucial: The number of photoelectrons produced is a significant factor in determining the detector's resolution. The study confirms that as the number of photoelectrons increases, the resolution improves, as predicted by theoretical models.
  • Sampling Thickness Matters: The thickness of the lead and scintillator layers directly impacts the resolution. Thicker sampling layers generally lead to better resolution, up to a point, as they allow for more interactions within the shower.
  • Confirmation of Design Formulas: The experimental results largely validate existing theoretical formulas for shower detector resolution, particularly the relationship between resolution, energy, sampling thickness, and photostatistics.
  • Direct Observation of Photoelectrons: By performing a dedicated run to observe single photoelectron peaks, the authors provided direct experimental evidence for the Poisson statistics governing photoelectron production, strengthening the theoretical underpinnings of their resolution model.

Key Results

  • The study provides a quantitative relationship between the resolution ($\sigma/E$) and the number of photoelectrons ($\mu$) for a given sampling thickness (0.57 r.l.) at 15 GeV, showing a clear improvement in resolution with increasing $\mu$.
  • The energy dependence of the resolution was studied, and the results were extrapolated to infinite photostatistics. For a sampling thickness of 0.57 r.l., the resolution at infinite photostatistics was found to be approximately 11%/$\sqrt{E}$, which is slightly larger than some previous predictions.
  • A comparison of sampling thicknesses (0.57 r.l. vs. 1.14 r.l.) at 30 GeV showed that the thicker sampling layer yielded better resolution, consistent with theoretical expectations.
  • The direct measurement of photoelectron peaks confirmed that the resolution is expected to follow Poisson statistics, with a measured constant $k=1.16 \pm 0.12$ where $k=1$ is expected.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the phototube gain did not always settle completely between filter changes, necessitating the removal of some data and the use of subsamples. Mechanical instability in the alignment of the phototube and light pipe also contributed to scatter in the data. While the study confirms the validity of the design formula, limitations due to correlations between sampling thickness and photoelectron statistics are noted as potentially important for detectors with very high light levels. Future work would likely involve applying these findings to the design and optimization of larger calorimeter systems for experiments like those at Fermilab.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Not Provided
BibTeX
@misc{hanson1980study,
  author = {J. Hanson and Bruce Brown and A. S. Ito and H. Jöstlein and Y. Sakai and K. Sugano and D. A. Finley and Y. Hemmi and A. Maki},
  title = {{A Study of Some Properties Which Determine the Resolution of a Lead Scintillator Sandwich Electromagnetic Shower Detector}},
  year = {1980},
  doi = {10.2172/1156083},
}

Loading related content...

Figure