A study of long-term GABA and high-energy phosphate alterations in the primary motor cortex using anodal tDCS and 1H/31P MR spectroscopy

Harshal Patel, Lea-Sophie Stollberg, Chang‐Hoon Choi, Michael A. Nitsche, N. Jon Shah, Ferdinand BinkofskiFrontiers in Human Neuroscience 2024 · DOI

Abstract: The approach employed in this study shows the feasibility of measuring long-term modulation of GABA and high-energy phosphates following anodal tDCS targeting the left M1, offering valuable insights into the mechanisms of neuroplasticity and energy metabolism, which may have implications for applications of this intervention in clinical populations.

Introduction

Transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS) is a widely used non-invasive technique for modulating brain excitability. While it is known to influence neuroplasticity—the brain's capacity for rewiring—the precise neurochemical mechanisms, particularly the interaction between inhibitory neurotransmitters like GABA and cellular bioenergetics, remain unclear. Changing neuronal activity is an energetically demanding process involving adenosine triphosphate (ATP) and phosphocreatine (PCr). This study addresses the gap in understanding how GABAergic activity and energy metabolism interact over an extended period (up to an hour) following stimulation.

Methods

The researchers conducted a single-blind, randomized controlled trial with 44 healthy participants (22 anodal, 22 sham). Stimulation consisted of 1 mA applied for 20 minutes over the left primary motor cortex (M1).

Data were acquired using a 3T PRISMA MRI scanner with a specialized quadrature double-tuned head coil capable of detecting both protons ($^1$H) and phosphorus ($^{31}$P). The protocol utilized MEGA-PRESS ($^1$H-MRS) to isolate the GABA signal and 3D Chemical Shift Imaging ($^{31}$P-MRS) to measure ATP, PCr, and inorganic phosphate (Pi). To prevent electromagnetic interference, participants were moved out of the scanner bore during the 20-minute stimulation period.

Experimental timeline and MR measurement protocol showing the sequence of baseline and post-stimulation measurements.

Measurements were taken at three key time points: baseline (pre-tDCS), Post-1 (~14–33 minutes after), and Post-2 (~48–72 minutes after).

Key Results and Insights

The study yielded several significant findings that challenge traditional assumptions about tDCS:

  • The GABA Paradox: While anodal tDCS is often thought to increase excitability by reducing GABA, this study observed a significant increase in GABA concentrations that remained elevated for over 40 minutes post-stimulation ($p = 0.001$ at Post-1; $p = 0.036$ at Post-2). This suggests that longer stimulation durations (20 minutes) may trigger different homeostatic mechanisms than shorter protocols.
  • Metabolic Recharging: Ratios of ATP/Pi and PCr/Pi showed a steady upward trend following anodal stimulation. This indicates that tDCS stimulates the synthesis of high-energy phosphates to meet the increased metabolic demands of stimulated neurons, effectively "recharging" the cellular battery.
  • Biochemical Linkage: The authors propose that the enzyme responsible for GABA synthesis (GAD) is regulated by energy metabolism. Higher ATP levels may accelerate the formation of the active enzyme, providing a direct link between the observed metabolic boost and increased GABA levels.

Discussion and Limitations

This research demonstrates that interleaved $^1$H and $^{31}$P MRS is a viable approach for monitoring the brain’s neurochemical state in vivo. However, several limitations remain:

  • Temporal and Spatial Resolution: The observation window was limited to ~67 minutes post-stimulation, and the study focused exclusively on the primary motor cortex.
  • Spectral Resolution: At 3T, it is difficult to distinguish Glutamate from Glutamine (Glx). Future studies at 7T could better resolve these excitatory metabolites to provide a more complete metabolic picture.
  • Variability: Inter-individual variability in response to tDCS remains a challenge for the field.

Conclusion

By simultaneously tracking neurotransmitter changes and energy metabolism, this study provides a holistic view of how the brain fuels plastic adaptations. The findings suggest that anodal stimulation supports long-term neuroplasticity through a process of metabolic enhancement and GABAergic modulation, offering new insights for clinical applications.

Summary updated

Abstract

The approach employed in this study shows the feasibility of measuring long-term modulation of GABA and high-energy phosphates following anodal tDCS targeting the left M1, offering valuable insights into the mechanisms of neuroplasticity and energy metabolism, which may have implications for applications of this intervention in clinical populations.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{patel2024study,
  author = {Harshal Patel and Lea-Sophie Stollberg and Chang‐Hoon Choi and Michael A. Nitsche and N. Jon Shah and Ferdinand Binkofski},
  title = {{A study of long-term GABA and high-energy phosphate alterations in the primary motor cortex using anodal tDCS and 1H/31P MR spectroscopy}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Human Neuroscience},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3389/fnhum.2024.1461417},
}
Figure