A Study of Correlation between Metacognitive Strategy, Self-Efficacy and Arabic Achievements of University Level Students in Malaysian Public Universities

Xuan Di, Wail Muin Ismail, Muhammad Azhar Zailani, Zawawi IsmailAl-Dad 2022 · DOI

Abstract

This study investigated the correlation of metacognitive strategies, self-efficacy and academic performance of university-level Arabic learners. A total of 317 university level Arabic learners from Year 1 to Year 4 participated in this study. The quantitative research approach was utilised by using Motivated Strategies for Learning Questionnaire (MSLQ) and the Self-Regulated Online Learning Questionnaire (SOL-Q) as instrument of the study. SPSS analysis of the data indicated a high level of metacognitive skills and self-efficacy. Metacognitive skills and self-efficacy correlated with each other significantly predicted academic performance. Subsequent data analysis also yielded a significant difference in metacognitive strategies and self-efficacy beliefs among Year 1, Year 2, Year 3, and Year 4 learners. The implications of the results for language learning and educational practice are discussed.

Introduction

Learning a second language is a complex cognitive hurdle. For university students in Malaysia, Arabic presents unique challenges due to its linguistic distance from the native Malay language. Despite decades of instruction, many students struggle with verbal proficiency. While most educational research focuses on pedagogical methods, this study shifts the lens to the learner's internal cognitive and psychological drivers.

The research specifically examines the interplay between Metacognitive Strategies (MS)—the "managerial" side of learning where students set goals and monitor progress—and Self-Efficacy (SE)—the internal confidence that one can master the material. The study aims to determine if these traits correlate and if they can predict academic achievement (GPA).

Conceptual framework of the study integrating social learning theory and language acquisition processes.

Methodology

The researchers employed a quantitative survey-based approach, collecting data from 317 Arabic learners across five major Malaysian public universities: Universiti Malaya (UM), University Kebangsaan Malaysia (UKM), International Islamic University Malaysia (IIUM), Universiti Putra Malaysia (UPM), and Universiti Sains Islam Malaysia (USIM).

Two established instruments were used:

  • Motivated Strategies for Learning Questionnaire (MSLQ): To assess self-efficacy.
  • Self-Regulated Online Learning Questionnaire (SOL-Q): Adapted to measure metacognitive strategies.

To ensure data validity for the Malay-speaking cohort, questionnaires were translated into Malay. Given the non-normal data distribution (confirmed via Kolmogorov-Smirnov tests), non-parametric statistics were applied, including the Kruskal-Wallis test for group differences and Spearman’s rho for correlations. Linear regression was subsequently used to model the impact on GPA.

Key Results and Insights

The study revealed several critical findings regarding the psychological state of Arabic learners:

The Reciprocal Loop

A strong positive correlation ($r = .63$) was confirmed between metacognition and self-efficacy. This suggests a reciprocal relationship: confident students are more likely to employ complex planning strategies, and the successful application of these strategies further bolsters their confidence.

Predictive Power for Academic Success

Linear regression analysis demonstrated that both MS ($\beta = .162, p < .05$) and SE ($\beta = .178, p < .01$) are significant predictors of academic achievement. Overall, the student population showed high baseline levels of these traits, with 60.2% reporting regular use of metacognitive skills and 65.7% reporting high self-efficacy.

The "Freshman Enthusiasm" Paradox

A significant difference was found across year groups ($p < .001$ for MS; $p = .001$ for SE). Surprisingly, Year 1 learners scored the highest in both categories. This contradicts standard Social Cognitive Theory, which typically expects these traits to mature with experience. The researchers hypothesize that as the curriculum difficulty spikes in Years 2 and 3, students' confidence may temporarily decline as they struggle to adapt their strategies to a heavier workload.

Discussion and Implications

The data suggests that successful Arabic learners prioritize active problem-solving over rote memorization. Students scored highest on "alternative problem solving," indicating they are looking for diverse ways to navigate linguistic challenges.

The "Year 2 slump" highlights a need for targeted support during the middle years of university study. Furthermore, the predictive power of MS and SE suggests that language instructors should move beyond grammar and vocabulary to explicitly teach "how to learn." This includes instruction in mnemonics, effective note-taking, and self-questioning techniques.

Limitations and Future Research

As a cross-sectional study, these results provide a snapshot of the current student body rather than tracking individual growth over time. Future research should consider:

  • Longitudinal Tracking: Following a single cohort from Year 1 to Year 4 to confirm if the observed trends are consistent.
  • Gender Analysis: Investigating potential differences in strategy adoption between male and female students.
  • Interventional Studies: Testing the efficacy of teaching metacognitive strategies directly in the classroom.

Summary updated

Abstract

This study investigated the correlation of metacognitive strategies, self-efficacy and academic performance of university-level Arabic learners. A total of 317 university level Arabic learners from Year 1 to Year 4 participated in this study. The quantitative research approach was utilised by using Motivated Strategies for Learning Questionnaire (MSLQ) and the Self-Regulated Online Learning Questionnaire (SOL-Q) as instrument of the study. SPSS analysis of the data indicated a high level of metacognitive skills and self-efficacy. Metacognitive skills and self-efficacy correlated with each other significantly predicted academic performance. Subsequent data analysis also yielded a significant difference in metacognitive strategies and self-efficacy beliefs among Year 1, Year 2, Year 3, and Year 4 learners. The implications of the results for language learning and educational practice are discussed.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{di2022study,
  author = {Xuan Di and Wail Muin Ismail and Muhammad Azhar Zailani and Zawawi Ismail},
  title = {{A Study of Correlation between Metacognitive Strategy, Self-Efficacy and Arabic Achievements of University Level Students in Malaysian Public Universities}},
  booktitle = {Al-Dad},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.22452/aldad.vol6no2.1},
}
Figure