A Structural and Algorithmic Study of Stable Matching Lattices of "Nearby" Instances, with Applications

Rohith Reddy Gangam, Tung Mai, Nitya Raju, Vijay V. VaziraniFSTTCS 2022 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper tackles the problem of understanding how stable matchings change when an instance of the stable matching problem is slightly perturbed. The authors introduce a new, more general way to define "nearby" instances and leverage structural properties of stable matching lattices to develop a polynomial-time algorithm for finding common stable matchings and for robust stable matching.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The stable matching problem, famously introduced by Gale and Shapley, aims to find a stable assignment between two sets of agents (e.g., men and women, or students and schools). A matching is stable if no two agents who are not matched to each other would both prefer to be matched with each other than with their current partners. The set of all stable matchings for a given instance forms a structure called a lattice.

Previous work by Mai and Vazirani (2018) explored "nearby" instances, where one instance is derived from another by a very restricted change (e.g., an agent moving one preference up). This paper generalizes the notion of "nearby" instances by allowing any agent to arbitrarily permute their preference list. The core challenge is to understand the relationship between the lattices of stable matchings of two such "nearby" instances and to develop efficient algorithms for problems that arise from these relationships, such as finding matchings that are stable in both instances or finding matchings that are stable even under certain types of errors.

Methods

The paper's approach is rooted in the structural properties of stable matching lattices. Key techniques include:

  • Lattice Theory: The authors heavily rely on the theory of distributive lattices and Birkhoff's Representation Theorem, which states that every finite distributive lattice is isomorphic to the lattice of closed sets of some partial order.
  • Rotations: Stable matching lattices can be generated by a partial order on "rotations" (cycles of agents who can improve their matches by swapping partners). The paper uses these rotations to define and manipulate sublattices.
  • Compression of Posets: A novel application of Birkhoff's Theorem is introduced, where a "compression" of a poset (representing the rotation structure) is used to generate specific sublattices. This allows them to derive the structure of common stable matchings.
  • Algorithmic Development: Based on these structural insights, the authors develop a polynomial-time algorithm. This algorithm identifies a "bouquet" of edges that defines the sublattice of common stable matchings. This bouquet is then used to find matchings that are stable across multiple perturbed instances (robust stable matchings).

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical analysis and algorithmic development for the stable matching problem, rather than empirical evaluation on specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Generalizing "Nearby" Instances: Allowing arbitrary permutations of preference lists, rather than just upward shifts, significantly expands the scope of "nearby" instances and the problems that can be studied.
  • Sublattice Structure: The paper proves that the set of stable matchings common to two "nearby" instances (M_A ∩ M_B) forms a sublattice of the individual stable matching lattices. This is a crucial structural property that underpins their algorithmic results.
  • Birkhoff's Theorem for Sublattices: The authors demonstrate a novel application of Birkhoff's Representation Theorem to derive sublattices. By "compressing" the poset of rotations, they can generate the specific sublattice corresponding to common stable matchings.
  • Robustness via Lattices: The structural understanding of common stable matchings directly leads to an algorithm for finding "fully robust" stable matchings, which are stable across a set of perturbed instances. This is a significant step towards practical applications where input data might be noisy or manipulated.

Key Results

  • Structural Characterization: The paper proves that for two "nearby" instances A and B (where B is obtained by an arbitrary permutation of one agent's preference list), the set of common stable matchings M_A ∩ M_B forms a sublattice of both ℒ_A and ℒ_B.
  • Polynomial-Time Algorithm: A polynomial-time algorithm is presented to find a partial order that generates the sublattice of common stable matchings. This allows for the generation of all such matchings.
  • Robust Stable Matching Algorithm: The algorithm can be used to find a fully robust stable matching for a given set of potential errors (permutations), provided the set of errors is polynomially sized.
  • Incentive Compatibility Insights: The work provides a framework for analyzing incentive compatibility properties of stable matching algorithms, particularly in scenarios where agents might try to manipulate their preferences.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Arbitrary Instances: The current work focuses on "nearby" instances where only one agent's preferences are changed. Extending the analysis to cases where multiple agents change their preferences simultaneously is identified as a significant open problem.
  • Probabilistic Robustness: The paper notes that their current approach for robust stable matching does not extend to the probabilistic setting (where errors occur with a given probability distribution), leaving this as an open problem.
  • Other Matching Problems: The authors suggest exploring extensions to the stable roommate problem and scenarios with incomplete preference lists.
  • Practical Applications: While the paper discusses potential applications in incentive compatibility and robust matching, further research is needed to translate these theoretical findings into practical solutions for real-world matching markets.

Summary updated

Abstract

Recently [Mai and Vazirani, 2018] identified and initiated work on a new problem, namely understanding structural relationships between the lattices of solutions of two "nearby" instances of stable matching. They also gave an application of their work to finding a robust stable matching. However, the types of changes they allowed in going from instance A to B were very restricted, namely any one agent executes an upward shift. In this paper, we allow any one agent to permute its preference list arbitrarily. Let M_A and M_B be the sets of stable matchings of the resulting pair of instances A and B, and let ℒ_A and ℒ_B be the corresponding lattices of stable matchings. We prove that the matchings in M_A ∩ M_B form a sublattice of both ℒ_A and ℒ_B and those in M_A ⧵ M_B form a join semi-sublattice. These properties enable us to obtain a polynomial time algorithm for not only finding a stable matching in M_A ∩ M_B, but also for obtaining the partial order, as promised by Birkhoff’s Representation Theorem [Birkhoff, 1937]. As a result, we can generate all matchings in this sublattice. Our algorithm also helps solve a version of the robust stable matching problem. We discuss another potential application, namely obtaining new insights into the incentive compatibility properties of the Gale-Shapley Deferred Acceptance Algorithm.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{gangam2022structural,
  author = {Rohith Reddy Gangam and Tung Mai and Nitya Raju and Vijay V. Vazirani},
  title = {{A Structural and Algorithmic Study of Stable Matching Lattices of "Nearby" Instances, with Applications}},
  booktitle = {FSTTCS},
  year = {2022},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=QRBDtpgIUz},
}
Figure