A Stochastic Multi-Rate Control Framework For Modeling Distributed Optimization Algorithms

Xinwei Zhang, Mingyi Hong, Sairaj V. Dhople, Nicola EliaICML 2022 · OpenReview

Introduction

The field of distributed optimization currently resembles a "zoo" of specialized algorithms. Whether it's Decentralized Stochastic Gradient Descent (DSGD) for peer-to-peer networks or Federated Averaging (FedAvg) for mobile devices, each algorithm is typically developed and analyzed in isolation. This case-by-case approach creates two major challenges: it obscures the common underlying themes linking different algorithms, and it makes designing new features—such as differential privacy (DP) or communication compression—a tedious process requiring researchers to build new convergence analyses from scratch.

To address this, researchers have introduced a unified control-theoretic framework to model, analyze, and design distributed optimization algorithms. By viewing these algorithms as stochastic multi-rate feedback control systems, this framework provides a single analytical umbrella covering diverse paradigms like Decentralized Training (DT) and Federated Learning (FL).

A Double-Loop Architecture

The core innovation of this paper is modeling distributed optimization as a double-loop feedback control system. This system consists of two main components:

  1. Global Consensus Feedback Loop (GCFL): Ensures agents stay coordinated and move toward a common solution.
  2. Local Computation Feedback Loop (LCFL): Steers the individual agents toward the stationary point of their local objective functions.
The proposed multi-agent multi-rate double-loop feedback control system.

Multi-Rate Sampling

To bridge the gap between continuous-time control and discrete-time algorithms, the authors employ Zeroth-Order Hold (ZOH) discretization. By varying the sampling rates of the two loops ($\tau_g$ for global, $\tau_\ell$ for local), the framework models different algorithmic families:

  • Case I ($\tau_g = \tau_\ell$): Standard decentralized training (e.g., DGD, DGT).
  • Case II ($\tau_g > \tau_\ell$): Federated Learning, where multiple local steps are taken between communication rounds (e.g., FedPD, Scaffold).
  • Case III ($\tau_\ell > \tau_g$): Communication-accelerated algorithms.

Modeling Stochasticity

Practical constraints are modeled as different types of "noise" injected into the controllers. Additive noise models stochastic gradients and differential privacy, while multiplicative noise models random communication graphs, partial agent participation, and communication sparsification.

Key Insights

  • Control Theory as a Unified Language: The paper demonstrates that many disparate algorithms are essentially just different discretization and sampling patterns of the same underlying continuous-time control system.
  • Stochasticity as a Design Tool: Instead of treating randomness as a nuisance, the framework treats it as a modular feature. For example, "Partial Participation" in FL is mathematically equivalent to a specific form of multiplicative noise in the global consensus loop.
  • Streamlined Convergence Analysis: The authors prove that if a deterministic base system is stable (satisfies a "descent property"), then any stochastic version of it will also converge, provided the noise variance is managed. This allows researchers to focus on designing the deterministic "skeleton" of an algorithm first.

Experimental Results

The authors evaluated their framework using a non-convex regularized logistic regression problem across a network of $N=200$ agents, each with a local dataset of 1,000 samples, connected via an Erdős–Rényi random graph.

Using the framework, they designed and analyzed three variants of Decentralized Gradient Tracking (DGT):

  • DSGT (stochastic gradients): Recovered the known $O(\log(t)/\sqrt{t})$ rate for stochastic gradient methods.
  • D²GT (dynamic graphs): Achieved the fastest convergence rate ($O(1/t)$), matching the deterministic baseline with only a constant slowdown.
  • DP-DSGT (differentially private): Showed a constant error floor, which is the expected trade-off for maintaining $(\epsilon, \delta)$-differential privacy.
Convergence of the stationarity gap for different DGT variants.

Limitations and Future Work

While powerful, the framework's analysis relies on the deterministic system satisfying a specific descent property. Verifying this for highly complex or non-smooth algorithms might remain challenging. Furthermore, while the framework handles random graphs, the current analysis focuses heavily on undirected or specifically structured directed graphs. Extending this to more general time-varying directed topologies is a promising direction for future research. Finally, as with many optimization methods, choosing the right stepsize remains crucial; the framework provides theoretical bounds, but practical tuning still requires care.

Summary updated

Abstract

In modern machine learning systems, distributed algorithms are deployed across applications to ensure data privacy and optimal utilization of computational resources. This work offers a fresh persp...
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2022stochastic,
  author = {Xinwei Zhang and Mingyi Hong and Sairaj V. Dhople and Nicola Elia},
  title = {{A Stochastic Multi-Rate Control Framework For Modeling Distributed Optimization Algorithms}},
  booktitle = {International Conference on Machine Learning},
  year = {2022},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=bfPJ3GHK87E},
}
Figure