A State-of-the-Art Review on the Integration of Building Information Modeling (BIM) and Geographic Information System (GIS)

Xiao Li, Xin Liu, Xiangyu Wang, Graeme Wright, Jack C. P. Cheng, Xiao Li 0003, Rui LiuIsprs Int. J. geo inf 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper provides a comprehensive review of the integration between Building Information Modeling (BIM) and Geographic Information Systems (GIS), highlighting the challenges and opportunities. It categorizes integration methods into data, process, and application levels, concluding that openness and collaboration are crucial for overcoming existing dissimilarities and achieving seamless integration.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Building Information Modeling (BIM) excels at representing detailed, semantic, and geometric information about individual buildings and facilities throughout their lifecycle. However, it often lacks the broader contextual information about the surrounding environment that Geographic Information Systems (GIS) provide. Conversely, GIS is adept at managing and analyzing large-scale spatial data but typically lacks the detailed internal information of buildings found in BIM. This disconnect creates significant challenges for applications requiring a holistic understanding of the built environment, from urban planning and infrastructure management to emergency response and asset management. The paper addresses the need to bridge this gap by reviewing existing integration efforts, identifying challenges, and proposing future directions.

Methods

The paper categorizes BIM-GIS integration methods into three levels:

  • Data Level: This involves introducing new standards (e.g., InfraGML, IndoorGML) or revising/converting existing ones (e.g., IFC, CityGML). It also includes manual and semi-automatic conversion/translation processes between BIM and GIS data formats.
  • Process Level: This approach focuses on enabling data sharing and interoperability without altering the fundamental data formats. Semantic Web technologies (using ontologies and RDF) and services-based methods (like OGC web services) are key here. These methods aim to create a seamless integration by allowing systems to communicate and understand each other's data.
  • Application Level: This level involves integrating BIM and GIS for specific use cases without changing the source data or developing new services/ontologies. This often involves customized plug-ins or using intermediate data formats (like gbXML) to facilitate information exchange for a particular task.

The paper also introduces the "EEEF" criteria (Effectiveness, Extensibility, Effort, and Flexibility) to evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of different integration solutions.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper is a review of existing research and methodologies, not an empirical study with specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Complementary Strengths: BIM and GIS are not competing technologies but rather complementary ones, each excelling in different aspects of representing and analyzing the built environment. Their integration unlocks powerful capabilities.
  • "EEEF" Criteria for Evaluation: The "Effectiveness, Extensibility, Effort, and Flexibility" (EEEF) framework provides a structured way to compare and select appropriate integration methods based on project needs.
  • Semantic Web as a Promising Solution: Semantic web technologies, particularly ontologies, offer a generalized and promising approach for achieving seamless integration by enabling machine-readable semantics and bidirectional data exchange.
  • Openness is Key: The paper strongly emphasizes that openness and collaboration among GIS and BIM users, developers, and stakeholders are paramount for overcoming the inherent dissimilarities and mismatches between the two domains.
  • Demand-Driven Integration: Integration efforts are most successful when driven by specific demands, such as smart city development, which necessitates a unified view of urban data.

Key Results

The paper doesn't present quantitative results from a specific experiment but rather synthesizes findings from numerous studies. Key qualitative findings include:

  • Data Level: New standards like CityGML and IFC are evolving to support richer 3D representations and geographic elements, moving towards better interoperability. However, conversion between them remains complex and often results in information loss.
  • Process Level: Semantic web technologies offer high effectiveness and extensibility but require significant effort, especially in ontology development. Services-based methods are effective but often lack flexibility.
  • Application Level: These methods are low in effort and flexibility but are highly problem-specific and not easily generalizable.
  • Overall: No single integration method is universally superior; the choice depends heavily on the specific problem and desired outcomes.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Information Loss: A significant challenge across many integration methods is the potential for information loss, particularly during data conversion and translation, due to differing standards and purposes.
  • Ontology Development: While semantic web technologies are promising, the development of globally agreed-upon ontologies is a time-consuming and complex manual process. Isolated development of ontologies within specific domains also poses a challenge.
  • Standardization Gaps: Existing standards like IFC are still maturing and may not fully capture all necessary semantics for seamless integration with GIS.
  • Future Work: The paper suggests continued development of open standards and ontologies, fostering collaboration between BIM and GIS communities, and exploring demand-driven integration approaches, particularly in the context of smart city initiatives. The authors encourage efforts that fundamentally solve the integration problem by creating more generalized and adaptable solutions.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{li2017state,
  author = {Xiao LI and Xin Liu and Xiangyu Wang and Graeme Wright and Jack C. P. Cheng and Xiao Li and Rui Liu},
  title = {{A State-of-the-Art Review on the Integration of Building Information Modeling (BIM) and Geographic Information System (GIS)}},
  journal = {Isprs Int. J. geo inf},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.3390/ijgi6020053},
}

Loading related content...

Figure