A stable and quantitative method for dimensionality reduction of aortic centerline

Tao Peng, Hongji Pu, Peng Qiu, Han Yang, Ziyue Ju, Hui Ma, Juanlin Zhang, Kexin Chen, Yanqing Zhan, Rui Sheng, Yi Wang, Binshan Zha, Shu Fang, Xinwu Lu, Jinhua ZhouFrontiers in Cardiovascular Medicine 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel 3D rotation projection method to find the optimal 2D plane for analyzing aortic morphology, overcoming limitations of traditional methods that rely on subjective judgment. By objectively evaluating projection planes using contour length, enclosure area, and sum of absolute residuals, their method provides a more accurate and stable representation of the aorta, improving the analysis of aortic dissection.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Aortic dissection (AD) is a life-threatening condition where assessing the aorta's shape is crucial for diagnosis and treatment planning. Current methods often rely on projecting the 3D aorta onto one of three primary 2D planes (XOY, XOZ, YOZ). However, these "primary plane projections" (PPP) can significantly differ from the actual 3D shape of an individual's aorta, making statistical analysis difficult and potentially leading to suboptimal clinical decisions. Clinicians often subjectively choose the "best" projection, introducing variability and potential errors. The challenge is to find a consistent, objective, and accurate way to represent the complex 3D geometry of the aorta in a 2D plane for better analysis and clinical application.

Methods

The core of this paper is a new 3D rotation projection method. After reconstructing the 3D aorta from CT scans and extracting its centerline, the authors employ a series of rotations around the X, Y, and Z axes (using rotation matrices) to transform the aortic centerline into a user coordinate system. This allows for exploring a continuous range of projection planes, rather than being limited to the three orthogonal ones.

To objectively evaluate which projection plane best represents the aorta's true shape, they introduce three quantitative parameters:

  • Contour Length (CL): The length of the projected 2D curve. They hypothesize that the maximum CL (MCL) on the optimal plane would correspond to the aorta's actual length.
  • Enclosed Area (EA): The area enclosed by the projected 2D curve. They aim to find the maximum EA (MEA).
  • Sum of Absolute Residuals (SAR): A measure of how well the projected 2D points lie on a plane. This quantifies the "flatness" or coplanarity of the projection. A lower SAR indicates better coplanarity and less spatial folding.

Through analysis, they found that SAR was the most effective criterion for identifying the optimal projection plane, as it best captured the aorta's true shape with minimal distortion.

Datasets

The study utilized retrospective CT angiography (CTA) data from 140 patients:

  • 24 patients with Type A Aortic Dissection (TAAD)
  • 48 patients with Type B Aortic Dissection (TBAD)
  • 71 healthy control subjects

The data was collected between January 2017 and December 2018 using a Toshiba 64-slice CT scanner. Exclusion criteria were applied to ensure data quality and relevance, particularly for the control group to avoid confounding factors.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Subjectivity is Out, Objectivity is In: The paper strongly advocates for moving away from subjective visual selection of projection planes towards objective, quantitative criteria. This is crucial for reproducible research and reliable clinical decision-making.
  • SAR as the Gold Standard: While CL and EA are useful, the study highlights SAR as the most robust parameter for evaluating the optimal projection plane. A lower SAR signifies a projection that better preserves the aorta's intrinsic geometry with less folding and distortion.
  • 3D Rotation is Key: Limiting projections to the three primary planes is insufficient. The ability to rotate in 3D space allows for finding a projection that truly minimizes spatial winding and best represents the aorta's unfolded shape.
  • Improved AD Discrimination: The proposed method, particularly using SAR, showed better discrimination of aortic tortuosity in AD patients compared to traditional PPP. This suggests its utility in identifying AD-specific morphological changes.

Key Results

  • The YOZ plane was identified as the optimal projection plane among the traditional PPPs for the study cohort, with a minimum difference (D = CL3D - CLp) of 18.64 mm.
  • The 3D rotation projection method, using SAR as the evaluation criterion, resulted in a significantly lower SAR (714.55 mm) compared to traditional PPP (1022.74 mm) when analyzing the entire aorta.
  • For a specific segment (Zone 5), the 3D rotation projection yielded a SAR of 15.94 mm, a dramatic improvement over the traditional PPP's SAR of 459.04 mm.
  • The method demonstrated improved discrimination of aortic tortuosity (AT) in AD patients, with a P-value of 0.008 using the Mann-Whitney U test, compared to 0.015 for the traditional PPP.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sample Size and Diversity: The authors acknowledge that the clinical data of 140 cases is relatively small. They suggest that collecting more AD patient and healthy aortic CTA data, potentially with prospective collection before and after AD onset, would improve the algorithm's robustness and allow for a deeper understanding of AD's specific effects on aortic morphology.
  • Algorithm Efficiency: While the method is described as efficient (around 1 second for projection), future research could focus on developing even more efficient algorithms and concise methods.
  • Broader Applications: The authors believe their method is suitable as a pretreatment step for other AD analyses and could be extended to other aortic diseases.
  • Integration with Advanced Techniques: They envision future work integrating their method with advanced techniques like artificial intelligence and deep learning to provide a comprehensive suite of parameters for cardiovascular analysis.

Summary updated

Abstract

Aortic dissection (AD) is a fatal aortic disease with high mortality. Assessing the morphology of the aorta is critical for diagnostic and surgical decisions. Aortic centerline projection methods have been used to evaluate the morphology of the aorta. However, there is a big difference between the current model of primary plane projection (PPP) and the actual shape of individuals, which is not conducive to morphological statistical analysis. Finding a method to compress the three-dimensional information of the aorta into two dimensions is helpful to clinical decision-making. In this paper, the evaluation parameters, including contour length (CL), enclosure area, and the sum of absolute residuals (SAR), were introduced to objectively evaluate the optimal projection plane rather than artificial subjective judgment. Our results showed that the optimal projection plane could be objectively characterized by the three evaluation parameters. As the morphological criterion, SAR is optimal among the three parameters. Compared to the optimal projection plane selected by traditional PPP, our method has better AD discrimination in the analysis of aortic tortuosity, and is conducive to the clinical operation of AD. Thus, it has application prospects for the preprocessing techniques for the geometric morphology analysis of AD.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{peng2022stable,
  author = {Tao Peng and Hongji Pu and Peng Qiu and Han Yang and Ziyue Ju and Hui Ma and Juanlin Zhang and Kexin Chen and Yanqing Zhan and Rui Sheng and Yi Wang and Binshan Zha and Yang Yang and Shu Fang and Xinwu Lu and Jinhua Zhou},
  title = {{A stable and quantitative method for dimensionality reduction of aortic centerline}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Cardiovascular Medicine},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/fcvm.2022.940711},
}
Figure