A spin chain for the symmetric product CFT2

Ari Pakman, Leonardo Rastelli, Shlomo S. RazamatJournal of High Energy Physics 2010 · DOI · arXiv

Introduction

In the landscape of the AdS/CFT correspondence, the duality between $AdS_5$ and $CFT_4$ is often regarded as the gold standard for integrability. In that regime, the mapping of field theory operators to the states of a spin chain allows for the exact calculation of the theory's spectrum by solving the associated Hamiltonian. However, the $AdS_3/CFT_2$ correspondence—a framework essential for understanding string theory on curved backgrounds and the microstates of black holes—has remained more elusive. While string theory on $AdS_3$ shows strong evidence of integrability, its dual field theory, the symmetric product orbifold ($Sym^N T^4$), has lacked a robust spin chain description.

This research develops a systematic "position space" spin chain language for $Sym^N T^4$. By representing single-cycle operators as spin chains and calculating their mixing and renormalization, the authors provide a foundational framework for exploring integrability within the $AdS_3/CFT_2$ correspondence.

Constructing the Spin Chain

The authors define the spin chain by identifying its "sites" with the individual "colors" or copies of the $T^4$ target space that are permuted by a single-cycle twist operator. In this mapping, excitations or "impurities" are introduced by acting with fermions or currents on specific sites within the chain.

Unlike the relatively straightforward vacuum of the $\mathcal{N}=4$ SYM spin chain, the vacuum in this $CFT_2$ context is a chiral primary state. The authors conceptualize this vacuum as a "Dirac Sea"—a filled sea of fermions. This shift in the nature of the vacuum state has profound implications for the resulting dynamics of the chain.

Methodology: The Covering Surface and Perturbation

To compute correlation functions within the orbifold, the study utilizes the "covering surface" technique. This involves lifting the calculation to a surface where the twist fields are effectively removed, rendering the fields single-valued and mathematically tractable.

To investigate the theory's behavior away from the free orbifold point, the authors employ conformal perturbation theory. They deform the theory using a marginal operator (the "blow-up mode") and apply the stress-energy tensor method to calculate "one-loop" corrections to operator dimensions. This allows for the study of how operator mixing and renormalization evolve as the theory moves into the interacting regime.

Key Insights and Results

Tree-Level Mixing

A primary discovery of this work is the existence of large tree-level mixing. In the $AdS_5/CFT_4$ correspondence, states with impurities at different positions are generally orthogonal at tree level, with mixing suppressed by $1/N$. In $Sym^N T^4$, however, the authors find that states are not necessarily orthogonal at the orbifold point. This qualitative difference suggests that identifying a simple, local Hamiltonian is more complex in two dimensions than in higher-dimensional duals.

One-Loop Dynamics and Integrability

Despite the complexity of tree-level mixing, the one-loop calculations reveal a promising structure. The interactions involve contour integrals around branch cuts, which suggests that the interaction might possess a "nearest neighbor" character when expressed in an appropriate basis. This is a crucial hint that the system may indeed be integrable.

Key results include:

  • Explicit Two-Point Functions: Concrete formulas for tree-level norms and the mixing of states involving fermionic, $J^-$, and $\partial X$ impurities.
  • One-Loop Differential Equations: The derivation of a differential equation for the four-point function involving two chiral operators and two interaction vertices, which is central to determining anomalous dimensions.
  • Non-Renormalization: Verification that the chiral vacuum remains BPS-protected and does not receive anomalous dimensions at one loop.

Limitations and Future Directions

The main challenge identified is the complexity introduced by non-orthogonal position-space states. Future research will focus on identifying a more "economic" or natural orthogonal basis for impurities to simplify the Hamiltonian. Additionally, extending these calculations to states with multiple impurities will be necessary to confirm if the nearest-neighbor structure persists. Ultimately, the goal is to compute the magnon S-matrix directly from the CFT side to compare with string theory predictions, providing a definitive test for the integrability of the $AdS_3/CFT_2$ model.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{pakman2010spin,
  author = {Ari Pakman and Leonardo Rastelli and Shlomo S. Razamat},
  title = {{A spin chain for the symmetric product CFT2}},
  journal = {Journal of High Energy Physics},
  year = {2010},
  doi = {10.1007/jhep05(2010)099},
}
Figure