Abstract
To solve the problem of "Credit Discrimination against SME", firstly the relevant literature concerning the approaches to the problem is reviewed and deficiencies are pointed out. Then the role of government and the mode of credit information sharing in foreign countries are analyzed, which can be valued as the practice basis of E-government services design. Finally, on the basis of policies and regulations and actual situation in China and theoretical analysis, the paper constructed the value of cross-organizational information sharing service value network and services model, and designed E-government service system in SME lending decisions and supervision, as a new perspective to solve the problem of the discrimination. This study provides a reference for developing countries that have a similar problem of "Credit Discrimination against SME" and same conditions of credit information.
Introduction
Small and Medium Enterprises (SMEs) are vital to economic growth, yet they frequently encounter "credit discrimination" in developing economies like China. While large corporations enjoy streamlined access to capital, SMEs are often marginalized by financial institutions. This disparity stems primarily from information asymmetry: banks lack the transparent, granular data necessary to distinguish between high-risk and low-risk small businesses. This leads to "adverse selection," where banks opt to avoid lending to the sector entirely to mitigate perceived risk.
Comparative Analysis of Credit Models
To address this gap, the authors examine existing international models for credit information sharing. The "American Mode" relies on market-driven, private credit bureaus with voluntary membership, while the "European Mode" utilizes government-monopolized public credit registers with compulsory supervision.
As shown in the table above, neither model is directly transferable to China’s unique regulatory landscape. Strict bank secrecy laws prevent third-party agencies from accessing financial data, and the government currently holds over 60% of credit-relevant information in siloed "information islands."
The Proposed G2B E-government Framework
The paper proposes a middle path: a Government-to-Business (G2B) e-government framework that leverages existing public data repositories. Rooted in New Public Management Theory and Service Science, the model shifts the government's role from "management" to "service."
"Hardening" Soft Information
A core innovation of this framework is the systematic conversion of qualitative "soft" information into quantitative "hard" data. By integrating data from various departments—such as tax records, customs data, and utility payments—the system can "harden" subjective factors like management capacity or reputation into usable risk metrics for bank loan officers.
The architecture (illustrated above) outlines a process where SME information is decomposed, classified, and then processed through e-government systems to support credit decision-making and monitoring.
Key Insights and Results
The research provides a theoretical blueprint for a decentralized "Service Value Network" where the Credit Reference Center of the People’s Bank of China acts as a hub for cross-organizational sharing. Key outcomes include:
- Four-Level Stratification: A hierarchy ranging from basic government data collection to bank-level lending decisions.
- Reduced Acquisition Costs: By streamlining data access, the model lowers the cost for banks to evaluate SMEs, removing a major barrier to small-scale lending.
- Legal Compliance: The design respects Chinese commercial banking laws by maintaining data sharing within authorized government channels.
Limitations and Future Work
While the framework offers a promising structural solution, the authors note it is a "rudimental exploration." Implementation faces significant hurdles, including the bureaucratic friction between departments that created "information islands" in the first place. Furthermore, while the paper suggests using multivariate integration and uncertainty reasoning to process data, it does not detail the specific mathematical algorithms required. Future research should focus on the technical realization of these decision-making support systems and pilot studies to validate the model's impact on actual loan volumes and default rates.
Summary updated