A SMALL-SCALE COMPARATIVE STUDY OF ONLINE HIGHER MUSIC THEORY COURSE AND PRACTICE COURSE

Rui MaProceedings of INTCESS 2021- 8th International Conference on Education and Education of Social Sciences 2021 · DOI

Abstract

At the beginning of 2020, affected by the COVID-19 epidemic, the vast majority of higher education in China adopted the form of online teaching. This study collected research materials through questionnaire surveys, interviews, and online teaching platforms to conduct a small-scale comparative study on the music theory course and solfeggio course of music majors at Beijing City University. The study investigated the students' learning situation of the two online courses and compared the differences in learning motivation, learning experience, learning time, and learning effect between the two courses. The results indicated that the two courses have obvious differences in students' learning experience, have their own advantages in learning motivation, and have no significant differences in learning duration and academic record. Finally, the implications of this study are also discussed.

Introduction

The sudden shift to online education during the COVID-19 pandemic raised significant questions about the efficacy of digital platforms for diverse subjects. Music education, which balances abstract cognitive theory with skill-based auditory practice, serves as a critical case study. This research investigates whether the "online-only" format creates a disparity in how students engage with theoretical knowledge (Music Theory) versus practical skill development (Solfeggio).

Methodology

The researcher employed a mixed-methods approach centered on the ARCS model of motivation (Attention, Relevance, Confidence, and Satisfaction) developed by John M. Keller.

  • Participants: 37 music majors from the Class of 2019 at Beijing City University.
  • Quantitative: Students completed the Instructional Materials Motivation Survey (IMMS), a 36-item questionnaire designed to measure the four ARCS dimensions.
  • Qualitative: Semi-structured interviews captured the learning experience beyond the numbers.
  • Analytics: The study analyzed logs from the UMOOC online teaching platform, including learning duration and assessment scores from February 2020 to June 2021.

Results and Discussion

Motivational Profiles

The quantitative data from the IMMS comparison highlights the motivational trade-offs between the two course types:

Dimension Music Theory (Avg) Solfeggio (Avg)
Attention 3.86 3.65
Relevance 3.80 3.92
Confidence 3.25 3.63
Satisfaction 3.69 3.96

Music Theory scored higher in Attention, likely due to the use of "cognitive conflict"—presenting new materials that challenged students' existing knowledge to spark curiosity. Conversely, Solfeggio scored higher in Confidence and Satisfaction, as the incremental nature of ear training provides immediate "small wins" that bolster student morale in a remote setting.

Academic Parity and Engagement

Despite these different motivational profiles, the study found no significant difference in the total time students spent studying or their final academic grades. Both courses showed a steady increase in total learning hours over the semester, indicating that the online format did not cause a drop-off in engagement for the practical course.

Final academic records were remarkably close, with average total marks of 82.81 for Music Theory and 83.73 for Solfeggio.

Academic performance breakdown for the online Music Theory course
Academic performance breakdown for the online Solfeggio course

The detailed breakdown of these scores—including usual scores, stage assessments, and final assessments—reveals a consistent performance profile across both theoretical and practical domains. Qualitative interviews did reveal that abstract concepts like "figured bass" were harder to grasp online, suggesting that while basic theory translates well, complex structural analysis may require more specialized digital tools.

Conclusion

The study concludes that students are remarkably adaptable to online learning environments. While theoretical courses may be more effective at initial engagement through cognitive challenge, practical courses provide higher levels of sustained confidence and satisfaction. The parity in academic results suggests that the digital medium does not inherently disadvantage practical music instruction, provided students remain motivated to meet course requirements. Future research should explore how to better integrate synchronous teaching to create a native digital pedagogy for music education.

Summary updated

Abstract

At the beginning of 2020, affected by the COVID-19 epidemic, the vast majority of higher education in China adopts the form of online teaching. This study collected research materials through questionnaire survey, interview, online teaching platform, and conducted a small-scale comparative study on the music theory course and solfeggio course of music major in Beijing City University. The study investigated the students' learning situation of the two online courses, and compared the differences of learning motivation, learning experience, learning time and learning effect between the two courses. The results indicated that the two courses have obvious differences in students' learning experience, have their own advantages in learning motivation, and have no significant differences in learning duration and academic record. Finally, the implications of this study are also discussed.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ma2021small,
  author = {Rui Ma},
  title = {{A SMALL-SCALE COMPARATIVE STUDY OF ONLINE HIGHER MUSIC THEORY COURSE AND PRACTICE COURSE}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of INTCESS 2021- 8th International Conference on Education and Education of Social Sciences},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.51508/intcess.2021238},
}
Figure