A Single-Scan, Rapid Whole-Brain Protocol for Quantitative Water Content Mapping With Neurobiological Implications

Ana‐Maria Oros‐Peusquens, Ricardo Loução, Zaheer Abbas, Vincent Gras, Markus Zimmermann, N. Jon ShahFrontiers in Neurology 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel, single-scan MRI protocol that rapidly and accurately maps whole-brain water content in just over 7 minutes. This method overcomes previous limitations in speed and precision, making quantitative water mapping more accessible for clinical and neuroscientific research, particularly for studying brain edema and other pathologies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Accurately measuring water content in the brain is crucial for understanding and diagnosing various neurological conditions, such as edema, stroke, and tumors, where water levels can change significantly. While MRI is a powerful tool for this, existing methods often suffer from long acquisition times, requiring multiple scans and complex post-processing, which limits their clinical applicability, especially for patients who may have difficulty remaining still. Furthermore, achieving high precision and accuracy, particularly at higher magnetic field strengths (like 3T), is challenging due to factors like RF field inhomogeneities. This paper aims to address these limitations by developing a fast, robust, and accurate single-scan method for quantitative water content mapping.

Methods

The core of the proposed method is a long-TR (10 seconds) multiple-echo gradient-echo (mGRE) sequence. The long TR minimizes T1-weighting, ensuring that the signal intensity is primarily proportional to water content. To handle RF field inhomogeneities (both transmit and receive), the authors employ a heuristic bias field correction using SPM12, a standard neuroimaging software package. This approach avoids the need for separate B1 mapping scans, significantly reducing overall scan time. For calibration, they use cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) as an internal standard, assuming it represents 100% water content. The method involves a T2* correction to account for signal decay due to magnetic field inhomogeneities, followed by SPM-based bias field correction and normalization to CSF.

Datasets

The study utilized data from 21 healthy volunteers scanned on a Siemens 3T scanner using either a 12-channel or 32-channel receiver coil. Additionally, data from 5 volunteers were acquired at both 1.5T and 3T to assess robustness across field strengths. Clinical applicability was demonstrated with data from one stroke patient and one brain tumor patient. Phantom studies were also conducted using a custom-made phantom with tubes containing known H2O/D2O mixtures.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Speed and Simplicity: The single-scan approach, achieving whole-brain coverage in just over 7 minutes, is a significant leap forward for quantitative MRI, making it more practical for routine clinical use and research.
  • Robustness to Coil Variations: The method's consistent results across different receiver coil configurations (12-channel vs. 32-channel) highlight its reliability and independence from specific hardware.
  • SPM for Bias Correction: Leveraging SPM for bias field correction is an elegant solution that simplifies the workflow and effectively handles RF inhomogeneities, a major challenge at higher field strengths.
  • CSF as a Reliable Standard: Using CSF as an internal calibration standard simplifies the process and avoids the need for external probes, which can be cumbersome and introduce variability.
  • Neurobiological Insights: The ability to map water content with high resolution reveals subtle regional differences in the brain, potentially linked to myelination and macromolecular content, opening new avenues for understanding brain structure and function.

Key Results

  • Acquisition Time: The entire whole-brain water content mapping protocol takes approximately 7 minutes and 21 seconds.
  • Accuracy: Phantom results showed excellent agreement with known water content values (within 1.5%).
  • Precision: In healthy volunteers, the mean water content for white matter was 69.1% (±1.7%) and for gray matter was 83.7% (±1.2%). Test-retest stability was excellent, with variations in mean tissue water content around 0.3% and mean voxel variability around 1%.
  • Field Strength Robustness: The method showed good performance at both 1.5T and 3T, indicating its applicability across common clinical scanner strengths.
  • Clinical Cases: The method successfully visualized increased water content in a stroke lesion and a brain tumor with surrounding edema, demonstrating its clinical relevance.

Limitations and Future Work

  • CSF Calibration Assumptions: The method relies on the assumption that CSF properties (particularly T1 relaxation) remain constant and are representative of 100% water. This might be problematic in certain patient studies where CSF properties could change due to disease.
  • Mono-exponential Decay Assumption: The assumption of mono-exponential signal decay might not hold true in pathological conditions with multiple water pools, potentially requiring more complex modeling.
  • SPM Correction Limitations: While SPM effectively corrects for smooth bias fields, it's acknowledged that it might inadvertently remove genuine, slow-varying water content changes due to disease. Further investigation is needed to ensure it doesn't remove biologically relevant signals.
  • Higher Field Strengths: While the method is expected to be applicable at higher field strengths (e.g., 4T, 7T), adjustments for more complex RF field effects and potentially longer acquisition times (due to increased T1 saturation) might be necessary.
  • Measurement Time Reduction: The authors suggest further reducing acquisition time by increasing parallel imaging acceleration factors or exploring faster acquisition strategies like EPI, though the impact on accuracy would need reassessment.
  • Partial Volume Effects: Partial volume effects at tissue boundaries can reduce accuracy, and higher resolution imaging could be a solution, albeit at the cost of increased acquisition time.

Summary updated

Abstract

Water concentration is tightly regulated in the healthy human brain and changes only slightly with age and gender in healthy subjects. Consequently, changes in water content are important for the characterization of disease. MRI can be used to measure changes in brain water content, but as these changes are usually in the low percentage range, highly accurate and precise methods are required for detection. The method proposed here is based on a long-TR (10 s) multiple-echo gradient-echo measurement with an acquisition time of 7:21 min. Using such a long TR ensures that there is no T<sub>1</sub> weighting, meaning that the image intensity at zero echo time is only proportional to the water content, the transmit field, and to the receive field. The receive and transmit corrections, which are increasingly large at higher field strengths and for highly segmented coil arrays, are multiplicative and can be approached heuristically using a bias field correction. The method was tested on 21 healthy volunteers at 3T field strength. Calibration using cerebral-spinal fluid values (~100% water content) resulted in mean values and standard deviations of the water content distribution in white matter and gray matter of 69.1% (1.7%) and 83.7% (1.2%), respectively. Measured distributions were coil-independent, as seen by using either a 12-channel receiver coil or a 32-channel receiver coil. In a test-retest investigation using 12 scans on one volunteer, the variation in the mean value of water content for different tissue types was ~0.3% and the mean voxel variability was ~1%. Robustness against reduced SNR was assessed by comparing results for 5 additional volunteers at 1.5T and 3T. Furthermore, water content distribution in gray matter is investigated and regional contrast reported for the first time. Clinical applicability is illustrated with data from one stroke patient and one brain tumor patient. It is anticipated that this fast, stable, easy-to-use, high-quality mapping method will facilitate routine quantitative MR imaging of water content.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{orospeusquens2019single,
  author = {Ana‐Maria Oros‐Peusquens and Ricardo Loução and Zaheer Abbas and Vincent Gras and Markus Zimmermann and N. Jon Shah},
  title = {{A Single-Scan, Rapid Whole-Brain Protocol for Quantitative Water Content Mapping With Neurobiological Implications}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Neurology},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3389/fneur.2019.01333},
}
Figure