A Simulation of the Spatial Expansion Process of Shrinking Cities Based on the Concept of Smart Shrinkage: A Case Study of the City of Baishan

Wancong Li, Hong Li, Feilong Hao, Zhiqiang Feng, Shijun WangLand 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the growing challenge of urban shrinkage in China by proposing and simulating a "smart shrinkage" planning approach. Using a novel coupled PLUS-SD model, they demonstrate that this approach can lead to more sustainable land use and development compared to traditional growth-focused or laissez-faire scenarios, offering a crucial framework for cities facing population decline.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Many cities globally, and increasingly in China, are experiencing urban shrinkage – a decline in population and economic activity. Traditionally, urban planning has been growth-oriented, assuming continuous expansion. This paradigm is ill-suited for shrinking cities, leading to issues like inefficient land use, vacant buildings, and a disconnect between population and infrastructure. China, despite rapid urbanization, has a significant number of shrinking cities, particularly in its northeastern industrial heartland. This paper addresses the critical need for a new planning strategy that acknowledges and actively manages urban decline, moving beyond simply preserving the status quo or continuing growth-focused policies. The authors specifically focus on Baishan, a representative shrinking city in Northeast China, to explore the feasibility and impact of "smart shrinkage" planning.

Methods

The core methodological innovation is the development and application of a coupled PLUS-SD model. This hybrid approach combines:

  • PLUS (Patch-Generating Land Use Simulation) model: This model excels at simulating land use change by considering spatial relationships and patch dynamics. It uses a random forest algorithm to predict land use suitability and a cellular automata (CA) mechanism for spatial simulation.
  • SD (System Dynamics) model: This model is adept at simulating complex systems with feedback loops, making it ideal for capturing the interdependencies between population, economy, and land use over time. The authors developed two SD models: Model I focusing on land use structure and Model II on construction land structure, incorporating population, economy, land use, and environmental factors.

The coupled model leverages the strengths of both: PLUS for spatial pattern simulation and SD for quantity control and dynamic feedback. They also employed an entropy value method to determine the weights of various indicators for construction land intensification and used a kappa coefficient and relative error to validate the simulation accuracy. Three distinct scenarios were simulated: Natural Growth (NGS), Traditional Planning (TPS), and Smart Shrinkage (SSS).

Datasets

The study utilized several datasets for Baishan city:

  • Land use data (30m resolution): Obtained from the Resource and Environmental Data Cloud Platform for the years 2000, 2010, and 2020. This data was categorized into seven land use types: cropland, forest, grassland, water, construction land, unused land, and other construction land.
  • Population data: Derived from the National Population Census (fifth, sixth, and seventh censuses).
  • Socio-economic data: Sourced from the China Urban Statistical Yearbook, China Urban Construction Statistical Yearbook, and provincial statistical yearbooks.
  • Driving factors for land use simulation: A comprehensive set including natural environmental factors (water resources, land resources, vegetation, climate, geology, topography) and socio-economic factors (population density, GDP, traffic, location accessibility). These were obtained from various sources like the Resource and Environment Science Data Center, Geospatial Data Cloud, and Open Street Map.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The inadequacy of traditional planning: The study strongly suggests that continuing growth-oriented planning (TPS) in shrinking cities like Baishan will only exacerbate existing problems, leading to more land expansion and a greater disconnect between population and infrastructure.
  • "Smart Shrinkage" as a viable alternative: The concept of smart shrinkage, focusing on controlled reduction, optimization of existing land, and enhancing quality of life, emerges as a scientifically sound and feasible approach for sustainable urban development in declining cities.
  • The power of coupled modeling: The combined PLUS-SD model proved superior to the standalone PLUS model, demonstrating the benefit of integrating spatial simulation with system dynamics for a more holistic understanding of urban land use evolution.
  • Spatial patterns of shrinkage: The research highlights that construction land changes in shrinking cities tend to occur at the edges of landforms, often following specific geographical axes (e.g., southeast-northwest in Baishan).
  • Balancing growth and decline: The paper underscores the need to shift from a "growth at all costs" mentality to one that balances population decline with strategic land use, prioritizing ecological health and resident well-being.

Key Results

  • Model Validation: The coupled PLUS-SD model achieved a kappa coefficient of 0.822 and an overall accuracy of 0.937, outperforming the standalone PLUS model and demonstrating high simulation fidelity. Historical tests for the SD model showed relative errors less than 5%.
  • Scenario Impacts on Construction Land:
    • NGS: Projected a 30.72% increase in construction land by 2030, leading to continued low-density development and potential decline in quality of life.
  • TPS: Projected a significant 50.40% increase in construction land, driven by economic growth priorities, potentially impacting food security and exacerbating the human-land imbalance.
  • SSS: Showed a minimal increase of only 0.62 km² in construction land, indicating controlled expansion and a move towards intensification and optimization.
  • Land Use Efficiency: Under the SSS, construction land intensification increased, with improvements in utilization intensity, output benefits, and sustainability, contrasting with the decline observed in NGS and TPS scenarios.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data limitations: The authors acknowledge the lack of detailed spatial data on the structure of construction land in Baishan, which limited the model's ability to optimize the spatial layout of the construction land structure itself.
  • Complexity of Shrinking Cities: The paper notes that shrinking cities are a complex, multi-dimensional, and multi-scale global phenomenon. Applying these concepts to China, with its unique governance and development context, is an ongoing challenge.
  • Future Research Directions: The authors suggest that future research should focus on developing more sophisticated methods for guiding urbanization in China and avoiding disorderly urban fringe development. Further investigation into the scientific and rational guidance of China's urbanization is also recommended.

Summary updated

Abstract

The coexistence of urban expansion and shrinkage in China has become increasingly apparent; therefore, the current strategic model of growth-oriented urban planning as the top-level design needs to be adjusted. This paper focuses on the city of Baishan, which is a typical shrinking city in China, and explores the feasibility of implementing the concept of smart shrinkage planning in shrinking cities in China by constructing a coupled PLUS-SD model. The results demonstrate the following conclusions: (1) The overall simulation of the coupled PLUS-SD model is superior to that of the PLUS model. In Baishan, the areas with the most changes in construction land will be located at the edges of the landforms by 2030. (2) Using the traditional planning scenario would only exacerbate the rate of construction land expansion in Baishan, deepening the incongruity between the city’s population and construction land. (3) The smart shrinkage scenario will require strict control of the scale of construction land and optimization of the structure of the urban construction land, which would push the city in the direction of healthy and sustainable development. (4) The concept of smart shrinkage planning is a scientific and feasible plan for realizing the efficient and sustainable use of construction land in shrinking cities.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2024simulation,
  author = {Wancong Li and Hong Li and Feilong Hao and Zhiqiang Feng and Shijun Wang},
  title = {{A Simulation of the Spatial Expansion Process of Shrinking Cities Based on the Concept of Smart Shrinkage: A Case Study of the City of Baishan}},
  booktitle = {Land},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/land13020239},
}
Figure